Sealed Judgement

T ABLE OF T ABLES
Table 1: Health and Structural Change from 2022 to 2025.................................................. 11
Table 2: Retention Value Change to 2025........................................................................... 12
Table 3: Breakdown of the number of trees with Retention Value change 2022 to 2025 ..... 12
Table 4: Plan numbers change 2022 DA to 2024 to 2025 ................................................... 14
Table 5: Koala Tree Retention Value by Status 2025 .......................................................... 14
Table 6: 2024 Tree Review - Koala tree advances to ‘Redundant’ status............................ 14
Table 7: 2025 Tree Review - Koala Tree advances to Redundant / Dead ........................... 16
Table 8: 2025 Bushfire tree removals.................................................................................. 17
Table 9: Biobasin tree removals.......................................................................................... 18
Table 10: Design conflict per tree........................................................................................ 19




T ABLE OF F IGURES
Figure 1: AP210910 - 10-07 - SITE PLAN - TREE RETENTION VS REMOVAL PLAN - REV
GG Legend ......................................................................................................................... 10
Figure 2: Image from the Mediation Agreement 18/03/2025................................................ 13
Figure 3: 2022 - Tree 30, vine engulfing the canopy ........................................................... 20
Figure 4: 2024 -Tree 30 failure event from the main canopy. .............................................. 20
Figure 5: 2022 - Tree 38, vine engulfing.............................................................................. 20
Figure 6: 2024 -Tree 38 increased likelihood of branch failure events................................. 20
Figure 7: 2022 - Tree 39, vine engulfing the canopy ........................................................... 21
Figure 8: 2024 -Tree 39 vine increasing branch failure likelihood ........................................ 21
Figure 9: 2022 - Tree 51 ..................................................................................................... 21
Figure 10: 2024 – Tree 51 totally engulfed and at an increased likelihood of major branch or
stem failure due to increased weight from the vine.............................................................. 21
Figure 11: 2022 - Tree 134 ................................................................................................. 22
Figure 12: 2024 - Tree 134, an increase in vine density to height into the canopy............... 22
Figure 13: 2022 - Tree 165 ................................................................................................. 22
Figure 14: 2024 – Tree 165. Vine-engulfed trunks, increasing in density and height. .......... 22
Figure 15: 2022 - Tree 205 ................................................................................................. 23
Figure 16: 2024 – Tree 205 vine increasing in height into and throughout the canopy. ....... 23
Figure 17: 2024 - Young natural regrowth being constricted by the vine, rendering it untenable
as a future tree.................................................................................................................... 23
Figure 18: 2024 - Tree 160 - failure as a result of vine engulfing and weighting the canopy 23




25_05_28_AR_RACV_RACV v NSC_Tree Retention Review_V10                                                                  Page 3 of 32




                                                                                                                                          50