Council archive · source document
Attachment 3 - Response to Bushfire Issues · MCU22/0118
Rob Friend & Associates Pty Ltd
Environmental Land Management Consultants
RF&A
Office – Unit 4/3 Heaslop St
Woolloongabba
Postal - 28 Merton Road
Woolloongabba Qld. 4102
p - (07) 3891 9131
f - (07) 3393 0388
m - 0419-667346
Your reference: -- e - [email protected]
w – www.robfriend.com
Our reference: -- RFA18-048
ABN 83 097 068 114
Date: - 24 November 2022 ACN 097 068 114
Patrick Murphy
Coordinator Planning
Noosa Shire Council
PO Box 141
Tewantin, Qld. 4565
Dear Mr Murphy,
Re: - Response to Information Request – MCU22/0118
94 and 142 Noosa Drive, Noosa Heads
RAVC Noosa Resort – Eco-Cabins
Further to the issuing of the Information Request (dated 29 August 2022), please find our specific
response to items 4 – 8 listed under the issue of “Bushfire”.
The issue and information Required with respect to bushfire is;
Issue
Bushfire Management
The Landscape Concept Package (Aspect 2022a) (LCP) is at odds with recommendations in the
Bushfire Management Plan (BMP) for vegetation management within the site and for establishing
and maintaining the asset protection zone (APZ).
The LCP proposes the rehabilitation of bushland within the site with supplementary endemic
plantings of trees and understorey species.
Although the Terrestrial Ecology Assessment (GEG 2022) (TEA) identifies that 18 trees require
removal for bushfire management purposes, the Tree retention plan (Aspect 2022b) indicates
numerous trees will be retained near the proposed cabins and will likely overhang them.
Trees overhanging buildings can contribute to the build-up of combustible debris. This debris can
accumulate in re-entrant corners, on roof tops and access ways and around doors, vents and
windows and promote ember attack. Trees which will overhang the proposed cabins should be
removed.
The expectation in the TEA that ‘restoration of the subject land (i.e. amongst the
buildings/structures) to achieve a self-sustaining ecosystem and provide natural habitats for fauna
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 3 pages
Page 2
2
and flora’ is at odds with recommendations in the BMP for vegetation management within the site
and for establishing and maintaining the APZ.
As discussed in Section 2 of the letter, assessment of vegetation adjoining the western boundary
of the site as a non-bushfire hazard class is reliant on the design and maintenance of landscaping
within the site resulting in a low fuel hazard area with discontinuous bushfire fuels which is
comparable with vegetation hazard class (VHC) 39.2 Low to moderate tree cover in built up areas
or VHC 41.4 Discontinuous low grass or tree cover. It is our assessment that rehabilitation which
seeks to achieve a self-sustaining ecosystem will exacerbate risks of bushfire hazard and is not
appropriate.
Information Required
4. The LCP must be revised to acknowledge the BMP and that the site is within a bushfire prone
area. Rehabilitation plantings must seek to achieve a vegetated landscape which is
maintained and has discontinuous bushfire fuels.
5. Trees which will overhang the proposed cabins should be removed.
6. Appropriate design guidelines for landscaping in bushfire prone areas are provided in Part 5 of
Bushfire Resilient Building Guidance for Queensland Homes (QRA 2020) (Bushfire resilient
building) which is publicly available online.
7. Plant selection should favour species in Appendix E of Bushfire resilient building.
8. The TEA should be reviewed to consider the significance of impacts associated with the
above-mentioned tree removal and/or further advise the micro-siting of proposed cabins to
avoid the removal of significant trees.
Response
4. The LCP must be revised to acknowledge the BMP and that the site is within a bushfire prone
area. Rehabilitation plantings must seek to achieve a vegetated landscape which is
maintained and has discontinuous bushfire fuels.
A. The Landscape Concept Package has been better integrated with the necessary
requirements in terms of the management of the Outer and Inner Asset Protection Zone to
the north of Eco-cabin Unit 1 and the management of the vegetation within the remainder
of the development site around Eco-cabins 2 – 8.
B. The use of the term “rehabilitation” while generally references a rehabilitation to a natural
and potential unmanaged area of vegetation, in this context the “rehabilitation” refers to the
removal and management of the ecological damaging weed species such as the
Frangipani vine (Chonemorpha fragrans) as well as other environmental weeds occurring
on the site and the selected planting of native species which would naturally occur within
this landscape and which will not increase the potential bushfire risks to the new structures
to be constructed within the area.
C. The Landscape Concept Package provides:
a. A maintenance regime for the areas around the Eco-cabins, Area “A”, within which
primary and secondary weed removal will be undertaken and the planting of a
range of less flammable plant species with a focus on the groundcover and
replacement of canopy and upper stratum species that have succumbed to the
existing impacts of the Climbing frangipani vine (Chonemorpha fragrans).
Page 3
3
b. Ongoing management of the whole area by the RACV Noosa Resort Grounds
management staff to ensure there is no accumulation of fire fuels under or around
the proposed Eco-cabins as well as the boardwalks.
c. Ensure the management of this area also achieves the required vegetated
outcomes within the inner and outer Bushfire Protection Area.
5. Trees which will overhang the proposed cabins should be removed.
A. With respect to bushfire mitigation and the potential for overhanging tree facilitating a
bushfire attack onto one or more of the Eco-cabins I would note: -
a. The Landscape Concept Package provides for the management of trees within
and around the Eco-cabins as well as regular maintenance of t=branches which
overhang any of the Eco-cabins.
b. With respect to bushfire mitigation, the involvement of any existing or future canopy
and upper-stratum trees is dependent on a ground fire getting to the trunk and
there being sufficient fuel around the trunk to facilitate the upward movement of the
fire up the trunk.
c. We would note that the area is to receive regular maintenance by the RACV
Noosa Resort Grounds management staff and as such the ground or surface and
near-ground fuels will be kept at minimal levels which will not facilitate the
movement of a ground fire from the vegetation to the north of the outer bushfire
protection area through the Inner bushfire protection area into the proposed
landscaped/rehabilitated around the other Eco-cabins.
d. Further, this management of the ground and near ground fuels will also limit the
ignition of the area around the Eco-cabins from an ember attack from a vegetation
fire within the vegetation to the north of the RACV Noosa Resort grounds.
e. Therefore, based on the management regime RACV Noosa Resort will implement
as part of the site development works and then the post development
management, it will ensure that no ground fire will be able to involve any tree with
fibrous or papery bark and therefore, elevate the ground fire up the trunk.
6. Appropriate design guidelines for landscaping in bushfire prone areas are provided in Part 5 of
Bushfire Resilient Building Guidance for Queensland Homes (QRA 2020) (Bushfire resilient
building) which is publicly available online.
A. The propose landscaping or rehabilitation of the area has taken the issue of bushfire
mitigation into the Landscape Concept Package which are consistent with Part 5 of the
Bushfire Resilient Building Guide for Queensland Homes (QRA 2020). This is emphasised
by the planting palette, for area “A” and the required maintenance program.
7. Plant selection should favour species in Appendix E of Bushfire resilient building.
A. The Landscape Concept Package lists a number of native plant species for the
groundcover and understorey which are consistent with Appendix E of the Bushfire
Resilient Building Guide for Queensland Homes (QRA 2020). I would note that this list is a
general list and not meant to include all native plant species which could be used in
landscaped areas to assist in mitigating the movement of a vegetation fire into and around
a residential or other structures.
Page 4
4
B. Due to the lack of connectivity to other areas of hazardous vegetation for the site, my
advice to RACV Noosa Resort and the Project Landscape Architecture Consultant was to
ensure the groundcover and understorey was integrated with the site management to
mitigate against the movement of a fire from the north into the area and therefore threaten
any of the structures, Eco-cabins and timber boardwalks.
C. The strategy is therefore not dependant on a single bushfire mitigation activity but an
integration of a passive activity, the groundcover and understorey plantings and the active
activity of regular site management and maintenance by the RACV Noosa Resort Grounds
maintenance staff.
8. The TEA should be reviewed to consider the significance of impacts associated with the
above-mentioned tree removal and/or further advise the micro-siting of proposed cabins to
avoid the removal of significant trees.
A. This issue is not a bushfire mitigation or management issue perse, however, with respect
to bushfire mitigation, the only tree that will be removed are Melaleuca quinquenervia and
Eucalyptus robusta specimens within the Inner Bushfire Protection Area and the thinning of
Melaleuca quinquenervia specimens within the outer Bushfire Protection Area. All other
tree specimens outside of the Bushfire Protection Areas are not required to be removed
for bushfire mitigation purposes.
B. Further, all consultants, Ecology, Arboriculture and Landscape as well as I, see benefit of
introducing some canopy tree specimens which are required to be removed from the
development footprint, into the area outside of the Bushfire Protection Area where there
are, existing gaps in the canopy or particular trees are in a very poor condition due to the
long history of Climbing frangipani vine impacting on those trees.
The Bushfire Hazard Assessment and Mitigation Plan has been updated to with the latest tree
retention and removal plans and which identifies the location and extent of the Bushfire Protection
Areas, Inner and Outer.
Yours faithfully,
Rob Friend
Director
Rob Friend & Associates Pty Ltd
Used in these records
Attachment 3 - Response to Bushfire Issues.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 2.6 MB (large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
Log in to download the original file
The download may take up to a minute.