REGISTER OF PRE-QUALIFIED SUPPLIERS FOR PROVISION OF TREE MANAGEMENT AND MAINTENANCE SERVICES - RP25083 · Attachment 1 - RP25083 Evaluation Workbook

Attachment 1




               Digitally signed by
               Geordie Lascelles
               Date: 19.09.2025

Evaluation Attachment 1 NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Evaluation A Register of Pre-qualified Suppliers for Provision of [ree Management and Maintenance Contract Title: : Services Contract No: RP25083 If the Evaluation Panel’s final assessment is that the response to any of the evaluation criteria assessment questions is ‘NO’ then the Evaluation Panel will consider if the Supplier’s inability to meet the criteria is limited. Where this is agreed to be the case, the Evaluation Panel may still assess the Supplier as suitable for appointment. Technical, Financial and Managerial Health & Safety - Management , , a P iteri an Environmen inabili Pri Criteria Capability Systems ent & Sustainability ice Must provide details of Health & Safety Must Pace octalls oi ee eee - tA ; ; ; Nenscementcrcenendeonn natn and complete the questionnaire provided within ; Respondent MUST provide evidence in the . ’ aa . the tender suite. MUST provide schedule of rates. Comments questionnaire provided within the tender suite. . . . . . response to suggest that the respondent does . . i Respondent MUST provide evidence in the Respondent MUST provide evidence in the NAME OF TENDERER . . Respondent MUST provide evidence in the . . No. . have the necessary Technical and Managerial ni response to suggest that the respondent, if response to suggest that the respondent, if Accept (Conforming Tenders Only) a . response to suggest that the respondent, if . . Capability necessary to perform contracts on time . engaged to perform the contract, would provide engaged to perform the contract, would provide . . . engaged to perform the contract, would provide - . are . and in accordance with agreed requirements. . ae 7 i the services to Council that identifies strategies to value for money? the services to Council in compliance with the ist C i ing the Zero Emissi Workplace Health and Safety legislation. as opel eee ede es oUs . Organisational Strategy 2016 — 2026 targets. 1 Active Tree Services Pty Ltd YES YES YES NO highly priced, based in Brisbane NO 2 |Arboreal Services Pty Ltd YES YES YES YES To be included, but not for Specialised - Reports or Consultancy Services YES 3 | Arboriculture Contractors Australia Pty Ltd NO YES YES YES Capability unknown - have not providede any information in relation to staff, NO key personnel, Plant and Equipment 4 | Aussie Tree Solutions YES YES YES YES YES 5 | Big Timber Tree Services Pty Ltd NO YES NO NO Based in Brisbane. E&S - limited response. High rates and min 6hr. NO 6 (Consult Arborist Pty Ltd YES YES YES YES YES 7 | Garwood Tree Services NO YES NO YES E&S - limited response, did not tender for traffic, personnel spreadsheet shows NO location not local 8 | JM Bushland Maintenance YES YES YES YES YES 9 | Professional Tree Surgery YES YES YES YES qimed ESS docs. To be included, but not for Specialised - Consultancy YES 10 | Specialist Arbor Services Pty Ltd YES NO NO YES Most responses were NO to WHS questionnaire. Limited E&S documentation. NO Limited submission 11 | The Trustee For Banyan Trust (Tree Solutions) YES YES WES: YES: For Tree Works the Cert 3 qualified member needs to be on site YES 12 ue Trustee For Benjamin-Young Family Trust (Arbor YES YES YES YES YES ustralis) 13 ue Trustee For Law Family Trust (Sunshine Tree YES YES YES YES YES urgery) 14 ts Trustee For The Mcdonald Family Trust (Branch YES YES YES YES YES reek Trees) 15 | Tree Fix Pty Ltd YES YES YES WES: YES 16 | Treesafe Australia Pty Ltd YES YES YES YES To be included, but not for Tree Planting and Establishment (high rates) YES Evaluation Panel Position Title Digitally signed by = The Evaluation Panel Chair confirms the : Evaluation Panel Chair & Member 1 Parks and Streetscapes Coordinator (GL) above evaluation : Geordie Lascelles Evaluation Panel Member 2 Arborist (OH) COD Date: 19.09.2025 Evaluation Panel Member 3 Tree Supervisor (CS) Evaluation Chair's signature: rarns anu ouvetscapes Coordinator (GL) Evaluation Panel Member 4 Coordinator Environmental Operationst (ML) Evaluation Panel Member 5 Roads Infrastructure Coordinator (TW) Evaluation Panel Member 6 Workplace Health & Safety Officer (JB) Evaluation Panel Member 7 senior Environmental Officer - Capital Works (S17 RP25083 - Evaluation Workbook_(0. Master).xIsx Page 1 19/09/2025