Skip to the record
Accept no imitations.

Council archive · source document

Part 22 of 37 Appendix 20 - Earthcheck MCU12/0208

of 127

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

Very large file (86.5 MB): the whole original can take several minutes to open, especially on a phone. Text is quick to read.

     ’Ecological Sustainable Performance’
                   Using a Process Performance Tool                                           ~
MEETING THE DEMANDS WITH A NEW PROCESS TOOL


The demands flowing from such         business, legislative and moral imperatives plus the scale of
potential development generated by growing demographic population shifts is in itself stimulus
enough to seek sustainable solutions. The question is how do developers deliver them on
medium to large precinct developments? What tools do they employ to ensure that they meet
the challenge that "has arisen from a number of forces at work within society to address
concerns for the problems of environmental degradation of the planet".5 This is particularly

relevant because it can be argued that many existing standards, checklists and guides are
limited in their ability to deliver meaningful long term performance based outcomes. Also few of
the tools currently in use are able to provide meaningful evidence that environmental
improvement by a development has been achieved.

This is evidenced by noting that even many highly regarded and comprehensive frameworks or
sustainability checklists limit themselves        to   only providing   a   means   to   consider positive
measures that can be taken to reduce environmental impact or enhance social and economic

benefits on schemes. They do not usually provide mechanisms within the tool by which
developers or other stakeholders can measure the possible or actual outcomes of their planning
and design decisions. This means that many of the sustainability tools aimed at developers
tend toward a self-assessment points evaluation of environmental initiatives or impacts on
individual buildings and their immediate surrounds.     Further, the third party certification
systems used by these tools normally only provide a reactive process for reviewing (via
documentation    provided) the points claimed. Such checklists and rating tools rarely
accommodate the broader, and quite often difficult to translate socio economic approach
advocated for Noosa on Weyba.


It is argued that ’Life Cycle Assessment’ limits itself to environmental impacts and outcomes
and "should be used in      conjunction with other environmental assessment, management and
decision making tools".6 This should not be accorded that these are criticism of the tools. Their
shortcomings are due to the lead in time of underpinning research, shifts in demands and
resultant performance pressures faced by the development and construction industries over the
last two decades. Consequentially this means that current best practice is not measured by
actual performance but is more to do with predicted outcomes. Consequently whilst there are a
range of tools they do not offer a whole system view of the total development process (See
Figure 6) and therefore fail to provide a proactive, integrated and comprehensive common
framework for developers, authorities and other stakeholders.


To   meet these challenges at Noosa on Weyba the process based Earthcheck Precinct
                                     7
Planning and Design Standard           (PPDS) incorporating benchmarking and certification of
best practice performance provides the model to be used for progress in the delivering of a
sustainable development. Implicit to this document is the view that planning and design has a
key role to play in resolving many of the conflicts that such precinct developments may
generate. In the absence of good planning and design unregulated development will be an
evident risk. It is likely the development will become formless or haphazard, inefficient and
likely to lead directly to a range of negative economic, social and environmental impacts. The
developer (and in particular the advisors) have responded when planning and designing the
new precinct to the task of achieving sustainability by recognizing this critical importance.




Dr Richard Moore EC3 Global Earthcheck Assessor                                      Copyright 2012     8

Used in these records

About this file

File size
86.5 MB (very large file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Part 22 of 37 Appendix 20 - Earthcheck MCU12_0208.pdf · 86.5 MB (very large file)

The download may take a few minutes. On mobile data, it is best to wait for Wi-Fi.

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.