Council archive · source document
Response to SARA Information Request · MCU22/0118
Court Appeals & Dispute Resolution
Applications & Assessment
Due Diligence & Compliance
Project Management
General Development Advice
Wednesday, 21st December 2022
Our Ref: 18006
Council Ref: MCU22/0118
SARA Ref: 2208-30467 SRA
State Assessment Referral Agency
South East Queensland (North) Regional Office
PO Box 1129
Maroochydore QLD 4558
By Email: [email protected]
Attention: Danika Cowie, Principal Planning Officer
Dear Danika,
Development Application for a Material Change of Use for Short-term accommodation
and new lagoon pool at the “RACV Noosa Resort”, 94 and 142 Noosa Drive, Noosa
Heads, described as Lot 3 on SP126203, Lot 0 on SP203417 and Lot 203 on SP267424
Reference is made to the request for further information by the State Assessment Referral
Agency (SARA) on 29 August 2022. Further, it is noted the information request period has been
extended to 23rd December 2022. The applicant has also responded to the two requests for
further information made by Noosa Council, which has been submitted concurrently with this
response.
The issues raised in the request for further information by SARA relate to solely to the impact
the proposed development will have on koala habitat, with the site being entirely included
within a Koala Habitat Area (KHA). The applicant has engaged Dr Ellis, Field Biologist, a well-
respected koala expert to provide advice for the development, along with a number of other
experts, including an arborist (Consult Arborist) and a terrestrial ecologist (Gondwana Ecology).
The response provided to the issues raised has been prepared by Dr Ellis, which is provided as
Appendix A. The response includes the following attachments:
• Attachment 1 - Response provided by Consult Arborist;
• Attachment 2 - Koala Management Plan prepared by Dr Ellis;
• Attachment 3 - Response to the State Code 25 prepared by Dr Ellis; and
• Attachment 4 - Amended Landscape Concept Plan
Adamson Town Planning Pty Ltd
(ACN: 163 798 374 | ABN: 73 163 798 374)
M| 0437 754 420 Mail: PO Box 894, Cooroy QLD 4563
‘Noosa Boardroom’, 28 Eenie Creek Road, Noosaville QLD 4566
Email| [email protected] Web| www.adamsontownplanning.com.au
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 4 pages
Page 2
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
Minor Changes
In response to the information requests made by Noosa Council and the SARA, the applicant
has amended the proposal plans to provide for a greater amount of tree retention. This change
relates primarily to a redesign of the parking area, which has allowed for the retention of more
koala habitat trees centrally located, which forms part of the main north south link through
the developed area of the site. Other changes include raising the level of the eco-cabins and
the boardwalk above ground to eliminate the need for earthworks, other than for the proposed
carparking area. The new design further reduces the impact upon existing trees sought to be
retained. A copy of the revised proposal plans is provided as Attachment 1.
Planning Context
It is important to acknowledge under the planning scheme the site is partly contained within
the Tourist Accommodation Zone, which provides for short-term accommodation. While the
site is entirely designated a Core Koala Habitat Area under the State mapping, some
development is envisaged under the planning scheme, which has always been the case,
including under the former planning schemes.
Consequently, a balance is to be struck by allowing some development, which is to be
integrated within the site while maintaining the majority of the koala habitat trees, with the
resulting significant residual impact being negligible. This approach will require continuous
management of the trees to be retained by an experienced arborist, in a similar manner to the
current operation at the existing RACV Noosa Resort, which has been ongoing for many years.
The site is heavily infested by an invasive weed species (Frangipani vine) which continues to
have a significant adverse impact upon many of the existing trees, in particular, koala habitat.
The experts have advised many of the trees have been adversely impacted by the vine, which
will continue if not removed and managed1. The development will allow for the invasive weed
to be removed but will require continuous maintenance, which is likely incur significant costs.
Consequently, the development will contribute in a positive manner to the ongoing
maintenance of the site in the long term that will benefit koala movement through the site,
which is in the public interest.
General Advice
The design of the proposed development has been carefully considered, which has taken an
enormous amount of planning and design with advice obtained from a range of experts. The
specific location of the cabins shown on the tree removal and retention plans has been
determined through collaboration with the arborist, ecologist, koala expert, bushfire expert
and project architect (refer Attachment 1).
1
Consult Arborist, 29 November 2022, page 3
2|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, December 2022
Page 3
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
The location of the cabins has been determined to minimise the impact on koala habitat. A
critical component of the proposed development is the elevated structures sitting lightly on
the land and integrated within the existing vegetation. The primary intention of the design is
to protect koala habitat, which also has the potential to provide a different form of visitor
accommodation and holiday experience for quests.
Gondwana Ecology and Consult Arborist were requested to consider all trees surveyed which
includes the trees within and outside the site to the extent surveyed. The proposal plans show
all trees surveyed which is important to consider the overall impact upon the koala habitat in
vicinity of the site (refer Tree Species Plans – Attachment 1).
The Tree Removal vs Tree Retention plans provide the following information:
Trees on the site:
• Total number of trees to be retained – 142
• Total number of trees to be removed – 89
• Total number of trees to be retained where possible but could be impacted by the
development (TBC2) – 10
Koala trees on the site:
• Koala trees retained – 101
• Koala trees removed – 44 (28%)
• Koala trees potentially (TBC) – 10 (6%)
Koala trees in the locality as surveyed:
• Koala trees retained – 190
• Koala trees removed – 44 (18%)
• Koala trees potentially (TBC) – 10 (4%).
Gondwana Ecology has prepared further advice which is provided as Attachment 2.
Gondwana Ecology has considered the responses from other experts in a wholistic manner
and considered the application documents from a consistency perspective in terms of the
amount of tree removal and retention. Gondwana Ecology has also considered the
rehabilitation of the site under the Landscape Concept Plan and provided further advice about
the overall ecological outcomes.
Both Gondwana Ecology and Consult Arborist have explained the status of the trees with
respect to the significant health concerns being identified for many due to the Frangipani vine,
which has effectively overtaken the site. At present this invasive vine is so dense that it inhibits
movement about the site because it covers the ground like matting.
The experts advise because of the vine, if the site is left in its current state, the trees, including
koala habitat, will be lost and the north-south avenue for movement of koalas will further
diminish. A careful approach to the development of the site is being proposed to ensure koala
habitat is maintained and improved when considering the current significant weed infestation.
Some development of the land needs to occur to provide the catalyst for the remediation
2
TBC – to be confirmed intended to be retained, subject to arborist advice during construction.
3|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, December 2022
Page 4
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
work, which will be expensive and ongoing for a number of years and can be funded under an
integrated development with the existing RACV Noosa Resort.
While the proposed development will have some impact upon the koala habitat, the koala
expert (Eco-Team) has advised the likely residual impact will be negligible in the
circumstances3 (refer Attachment 3 - Appendix A). The koala expert has advised the site is an
important node within connected koala habitat for Noosa and that it would be unacceptable
for development that reduces habitat connectivity or further fragments the local koala habitat
to be approved. The proposal contains several measures that not only mitigate potential
impacts but seek to improve the quality of habitat at the site, provide for increased safety for
travelling and resident koalas and also raise awareness of koala in the area to spread the
message of koala safety in the local community4.
In considering the appropriateness of the development, the koala expert has compared the
current trajectory of vegetation quality (as detailed by the expert arborist) which suggests a
clear decline. The loss of koala habitat is mostly caused by the weed infestation when
measured against an alternative proposal for the site, including habitat enhancement with
sensitive development. The encroachment of the Frangipani vine, threatens habitat quality for
koalas on the site, strangling the canopy and hindering on ground movement. The koala expert
has also prepared a Koala Management Plan to ensure on-going maintenance of the koala
habitat value of the site, in particular for connectivity to support safe movement of koalas
(refer Attachment 2 – Appendix A).
In terms of an acceptable offset, the koala expert has advised the notional offset area is 1.02ha
under the environmental offset calculator provided under PO5 within the response to State
Code 25 (Attachment 3 – Appendix A). It is expected that SARA will require a financial offset
for the koala habitat trees being removed based on the number of trees identified.
The koala expert has also advised that Noosa Council has received recommendations for koala
and wildlife signage as a tool to reduce road trauma for this species (Ecology 2017): combined
with council imposed speed limits on Weyba Rd / Noosa Drive, such signage could also result
in an improved outcome for koalas.
The applicant would be happy to consider the implementation of these mitigation measures
where reasonable for the development being proposed. It is noted no fencing is being
provided that would hinder the movement of koalas through the site. Further, given the
proposed development is for tourist accommodation only and not for permanent residential
living, no dogs will be present on the site.
3
Refer to response to PO5 under State Code 25
4
Refer response by Eco-Team to the SARA information request, Issue 1
4|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, December 2022
Page 5
“Adamson Town Planning, specialising in providing higher order town planning advice”
Exempted Development
With respect to vegetation removal under the definition of “exempted development” under
the Planning Regulation 2017 (PR2017) being for essential management or similar, the
development has been specifically designed to be integrated within the site. The proposal
plans nominate the trees to be retained and removed, as well as the status of a small number
to be confirmed, as shown.
Under an approval, it is expected the Tree Retention vs Tree Removal Plans, including Plans A
& B (refer Attachment 1) would be specifically referred to in terms of the trees to be retained
on the site. These trees are to be protected and managed and could only be removed subject
to arborist advice. Any trees required to be removed if considered unsafe would have to be
replaced onsite by an advanced koala habitat tree.
This means despite the vegetation clearing being “exempted development” within a koala
habitat area under the PR2017, the development would be required to comply with the
development approval. Any trees required to be retained under the approval could not be
removed without changing the approval. Strict requirements would be expected to be
imposed about any tree removal as discussed above.
It is also suggested that while an environmental covenant might be appropriate in some
circumstances where an area of vegetation is to be protected and maintained on a site where
removed from a developable area, in this case, a covenant would not be practical or
appropriate, given the amount of integration. Further, given the level of detail provided under
the specific tree retention and removal plans, these plans could form part of any approval.
Development Assessment Rules
In accordance with section 13 of the Development Assessment Rules, this concludes the
response to the information request made. It is noted the changes made to the application
are in response to the issues raised in the information requests, and in any event are
considered minor.
Should you have any questions with respect to the above, please contact me.
Yours faithfully
Shane Adamson
Shane Adamson (BEngTech, GDURP, MPIA, MQELA)
Town Planning Specialist
Director - Adamson Town Planning Pty Ltd
5|Page
18006 – RACV Noosa Resort, December 2022
Used in these records
Response to SARA Information Request.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 241 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.