Council archive · source document
Attachment 10- Amended Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment MCU12/0208
Very large file (29.3 MB): the whole original can take several minutes to open, especially on a phone. Text is quick to read.
Noosa on Weyba Insert report title here Insert project name Insert job reference Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment 5101-19 Prepared for Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd 11 October 2013
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of pages 2 to 65 (of 127)
Page 2
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
Contact Information Document Information
Cardno (QLD) Pty Ltd Prepared for Northbrook Corporation Pty
ABN 57 051 074 992 Ltd
Project Name Noosa on Weyba
Level 11 Green Square North Tower
File Reference I:\5101-19\wp\Koala\Koala
515 St Paul’s Terrace
Assessment v2.docx
Fortitude Valley QLD 4006
Locked Bag 4006 Fortitude Valley Job Reference 5101-19
Date 11 October 2013
Telephone: 07 3369 9822
Facsimile: 07 3369 9722
International: +61 7 3369 9822
[email protected]
www.cardno.com.au
Document Control
Date Description of Prepared Reviewed
Reviewed
Version
Prepared
Revision (Signature) (Signature)
By
By
Draft 24/09/2012 Draft MW M Ward JD J Delaney
1 30/11/2012 Final MW M Ward JD J Delaney
2 11/10/2013 Final JD JD
Reason for Issue Approved for Approved Approved
Release (Signature) Release Date
Version
By
2 For approvals JD 11/10/2013
© Cardno 2013. Copyright in the whole and every part of this document belongs to Cardno and may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or
reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or form or in or on any media to any person other than by agreement with Cardno.
This document is produced by Cardno solely for the benefit and use by the client in accordance with the terms of the engagement. Cardno does
not and shall not assume any responsibility or liability whatsoever to any third party arising out of any use or reliance by any third party on the
content of this document.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page ii
Page 3
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
Table of Contents
1 Introduction 1
2 Koala Biology and Ecology 3
2.1 Conservation Status of Koala 3
2.2 Distribution 3
2.3 Population Size and Dynamics 3
2.4 Habitat Requirements 4
2.5 Diet 5
2.6 Reproduction 5
2.7 Behaviour 6
3 Koala Habitat within the Noosa on Weyba Site Locality 7
3.1 Historical Context 7
3.2 Koala SPRP Habitat Values Mapping 8
3.3 Koala Habitat Trees 8
3.4 Field Based Observations 9
3.4.1 Methods 9
3.4.2 Results 9
4 Threats to Koala within the Noosa on Weyba Site Locality 12
4.1 Habitat Clearance and Fragmentation 12
4.2 Vehicular Traffic Impacts 13
4.3 Dog Related Impacts 15
5 Noosa on Weyba Koala Implications 17
5.1 Proposed Plan of Development 17
5.2 Koala Habitat Retention and Management 18
5.3 Koala Habitat Clearance 20
5.3.1 Clearance Within Mapped Koala Bushland Habitat 20
5.3.2 Clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees 22
5.3.3 Overall Clearance of Koala Habitat Trees 23
5.4 Koala Habitat Offsets 24
5.4.1 Offset Capacity of the Noosa on Weyba Project 24
5.4.2 Offset Security 27
5.5 Road Traffic Impacts and Mitigation 28
5.6 Domestic Dog Related Impacts and Mitigation Measures 30
5.7 Swimming Pool Related Impacts and Mitigation Measures 30
5.8 Community Education and Stewardship 31
6 Compliance Assessment 32
6.1 South East Queensland Koala Conservation State Planning Regulatory Provisions 32
6.2 Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 35
7 Net Benefit Assessment 38
7.1 Habitat Clearance and Degradation 38
7.2 Road Traffic Impacts 40
7.3 Domestic Dog Impacts 40
8 Conclusion 42
9 References 43
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page iii
Page 4
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
Tables
Table 1-1 Noosa on Weyba Site Details 1
Table 3-1 Extents of Koala habitat types within the Noosa on Weyba site 8
Table 3-2 Koala Habitat Types within the Noosa on Weyba project site 11
Table 4-1 Roadways in the Noosa on Weyba site locality 13
Table 4-2 Safe fauna passage roadway infrastructure 14
Table 5-1 Proposed infrastructure within mapped Koala Bushland Habitat 20
Table 5-2 Number of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees proposed to be cleared within mapped Koala
Bushland Habitat and High or Medium Value Rehabilitation Areas 23
Table 5-3 Estimated number of Koala habitat trees to be established within the Noosa on Weyba Send
site 25
Table 5-4 Estimated number of Koala habitat offset trees to be established within the Noosa on Weyba
Receive site 25
Table 5-5 Koala habitat tree species associated with different habitat (regional ecosystem) types 27
Table 5-6 Impact of Proposal on the local Road Network 28
Table 6-1 Koala SPRP Division 4 Assessment Criteria Compliance Assessment 32
Table 6-2 Koala SPRP Division 7 Assessment Criteria Compliance Assessment 34
Table 6-3 EPBC Significant Impact Criteria Assessment 35
Table 7-1 Relative extents of Koala Bushland Habitat clearance for existing uses and proposed uses of
the Noosa on Weyba site 38
Figures
Figure 1 Noosa on Weyba “Send” and “Receive” sites
Figure 2 Historical Aerial Imagery
Figure 3 Koala Habitat Values Map
Figure 4 Koala Habitat Tree Survey Transect Locations
Figure 5 Broad Vegetation Types
Figure 6 Koala Habitat Values Map with Committed Development Overlays
Figure 7 Noosa on Weyba Concept Master Plan Layout
Figure 8 Koala Habitat Values Map with Noosa on Weyba Concept Master Plan Layout Overlay
Figure 9 Koala Habitat Offset Areas
Appendices
Appendix A South East Queensland Koala Habitat Values Map (Ref: map SPP_KHV 4 SEQKPA
v1.2)
Appendix B Koala Habitat Transect Survey Methods and Results
Appendix C Broad Vegetation Community Types
Appendix D JF&P Drawing Ref: M1775-00-12 (F) dated 18 July 2012
Appendix E Noosa on Weyba Precinct, Structure and Concept Master Plans
Appendix F Preliminary Road Design
Appendix G Noosa on Weyba Request for Further Information Responses
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page iv
Page 5
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
1 Introduction
This Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment has been prepared on behalf of Northbrook Corporation Pty
Ltd in respect of the proposed Noosa on Weyba project which encompasses land that was gazetted as a
Biodiversity Development Offset Area (BDOA) by the Queensland State Government on 3 February 2012.
The Noosa on Weyba proposal is based on the BDOA mechanism, which operates within the framework
created by the South East Queensland Regional Plan 2009 – 2031 State Planning Regulatory Provisions
(SEQ SPRP) and State Planning Policy 2/10: Koala Conservation in South East Queensland (SPP 2/10), for
achieving a net benefit for Koala conservation. The declaration of the Noosa on Weyba project site as a
BDOA provides the opportunity to transfer development and use rights from some parcels of land (being the
Send site) to other parcels of land (being the Receive site) in the interest of biodiversity conservation. In
essence the BDOA mechanism involves:
> surrendering “existing, as-of-right and potentially permitted” use opportunities that exist over a Send site
and that are associated with adverse biodiversity outcomes;
> facilitating the maintenance, restoration and/or enhancement of the Send site to achieve desired intrinsic
and strategic biodiversity outcomes; and
> permitting applications to be made to secure higher value urban uses within the Receive site for purposes
that appropriately respond to the recognised biodiversity values and functions of the Receive site.
The Noosa on Weyba site is comprised of seven individual parcels of freehold land with a combined area of
approximately 303 ha. Based on preliminary environmental assessments and consideration of existing and
potential patterns of land use and development these individual parcels of land have been classified, in
accordance with the BDOA nomenclature, as either “Send” or “Receive” sites. The locations and extents of
the Noosa on Weyba “Send” and “Receive” sites are illustrated in Figure 1 and the real property descriptions
and areas of the “Send” and “Receive” sites are also provided in Table 1-1.
Table 1-1 Noosa on Weyba Site Details
Real Property Description Area (Ha) BDOA Status
Send Sites Receive Sites
Lot 7 on RP46782 1.99
Lot 2 on RP160983 93.1
Lot 1667 on M3772 44.4
Lot 2 on SP179590 12.5
Lot 53 on SP163571 110.0
Lot 11 on SP250714 40.7
Lot 12 on RP893393 0.61
Combined Areas (Ha) 303.3 139.5 163.8
The Noosa on Weyba site is traversed by Walter Hay Drive and is bound:
> to the north-east by a section of the Noosa National Park;
> to the north-west by expanding urban development including the Noosa Civic development;
> to the east by Lake Weyba;
> to the south by the 126 ha Weyba Nature Refuge (part of lot 77 on SP177938) and the Eumarella Shores
development and associated 16 ha Tainsh’s Nature Refuge; and
> to the west by rural residential development and land that forms part of the Noosa Golf Course.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 1
Page 6
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment The objectives of this Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment are to: > provide an overview of the biology and ecology of Koalas; > describe the Koala habitat values of the Noosa on Weyba site locality; > describe existing threats to Koalas that operate within the Noosa on Weyba site locality, including potential threats associated with existing use and development rights; > describe the nature of the proposed Noosa on Weyba project in terms of its likely impacts to and benefits for Koalas in comparison to continuation of existing land tenure and use arrangements, including uptake of existing/pending development commitments; and > provide an assessment of the degree of compliance that the Noosa on Weyba project achieves with the requirements of regulations specifically concerned with ensuring Koala conservation, including the SEQ Koala Conservation State Planning Regulatory Provisions 2010 (the Koala SPRP) and the Commonwealth Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (EPBC Act). This Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment contains various amendments and additions to the original Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment (Version 1, dated 30 November 2012) which was submitted with the formal development application lodged on 20 December 2012. The amendments and additions reflect changes to the plan of development that have been made in response to: > various issues raised by assessment agencies within formal Information Requests; and > the findings of a critical review of the Noosa on Weyba proposal as detailed in the Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment (v1), provided by Professor Frank Carrick AM (Carrick,2013). Appendix G provides a copy of the Request for Further Information items of relevance to this report and a summary of the responses that have been provided. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 2
Page 7
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment 2 Koala Biology and Ecology An overview of the biology and ecology of the Koala (Phascolarctos cinereus adustus) within Queensland is provided within the Nature Conservation (Koala) Conservation Plan 2006 and Management Program 2006- 2016 (EPA 2006). Key elements of that overview are reproduced below. The overview also draws on additional information provided by Professor Frank Carrick AM who completed a critical review of the Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment (v1), which was submitted in support of the Noosa on Weyba development application. 2.1 Conservation Status of Koala The Koala is classified as a Vulnerable species in the South East Queensland Bioregion under the Nature Conservation Act 1992 and in May 2012 was also classified as a Vulnerable species throughout all of Queensland, New South Wales and the Australian Capital Territory under the provisions of the EPBC Act. The Koala is also listed: > as ‘vulnerable to extinction’ under the New South Wales Threatened Species Conservation Act 1995, which also lists two populations as ‘endangered’ (Hawks Nest and Tea Gardens, Pittwater Local Government Area); and > under the United States Endangered Species Act. 2.2 Distribution Koala populations are scattered throughout eastern Australia. In Queensland, the greatest concentration is in south-east Queensland. Lower densities occur throughout much of the central and eastern parts of Queensland (Gordon and McGreevy 1978; Melzer and Lamb 1994; Patterson 1996). Koala distribution is widespread but patchy in forest and woodland vegetation. Their broad distribution (or range) has not contracted greatly since European settlement. For example, Koala populations are still found on the western and northern margins of their range in semi-arid country and also in the heavily developed south-east corner of the state (Patterson 1996). They also continue to live in many rural areas where their habitat has been highly fragmented due to clearing (Gordon 1989; Gordon et al. 1990a; White 1999). The local distribution of Koalas in Queensland at the time of European settlement is not known in detail. However, Queensland had been subject to extensive tree clearing, which must have included significant areas of Koala habitat. Therefore, it is reasonably certain that Koala populations have undergone a major contraction in local distribution, including local extinctions and local declines in abundance (Phillips 1990). 2.3 Population Size and Dynamics It is estimated that there are between 100,000 and 300,000 Koalas in Queensland. In 2000 it was estimated that there were 63,000 (±18,000) in the Mulga Lands Bioregion, which is the semi-arid country on the western limit of their range (Sullivan 2000). Carrick (2013) states that “Subsequent work has shown that this population has since crashed by ~80% to around 12,000 (Seabrook et al., 2011).” Dique et al. (2004) estimated that there were a maximum of 6,000 Koalas in the Koala Coast, an area including Redland Shire and parts of Brisbane City and Logan City, but by 2010 the population is estimated to have declined to just under 2,000 (DERM, 2010). Dique et al. (2003a) estimated that 4,500 Koalas were located within the Pine Rivers Shire, however this population had declined by at least 45% by 2010 and optimistically may now be about the same abundance as the residual Koala Coast population (Carrick 2013). The local density of Koala populations in Queensland ranges from 0.005 Koalas/ha (or 1 Koala/200ha) (Melzer and Lamb 1994) to 2.5 Koalas/ha (Gordon et al. 1990a). Higher densities have been recorded in other states and anecdotal evidence indicates that Queensland’s Koala density has been much greater in the past. Typical densities in forested habitat in south-east Queensland (where Koalas are often thought to be common) may be about 0.2–0.5 Koalas/ha, with densities reaching more than 2 Koalas/ha at some sites (White and Kunst 1990; Hasegawa 1995; Dique et al. 2003b). Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 3
Page 8
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Queensland’s Koala population has been variable over time, reaching high densities before declining or ‘crashing’. The decline phase is partly a correction of the preceding expansion and does not necessarily affect the survival of the population overall (Gordon et al. 1988). However, more recent emerging threats affect the normal fluctuations in population densities, making recovery more difficult. A number of important factors now affect Koala population size in Queensland. These are habitat fragmentation and loss, chlamydial disease, climate change, car strikes, dog attacks, fire and drought. Understanding the extent of the decline of Koalas since European settlement is complicated by a period of population growth following hunting in the southern and central parts of its Queensland distribution from the late 1800s to the early 1900s (Gordon and Hrdina 2005). The population appears to have grown to a large size, perhaps larger than the pre-settlement size when Indigenous hunting may have supressed Koala numbers, and then contracted severely between the 1920s and 1940s. The extent of decline since the period of high population growth gives a misleading impression of the overall change in status of Koalas since settlement. However, it is likely that current Koala population size is significantly smaller than the pre- settlement population due to the combined effects of the Koala fur trade and a large reduction in suitable habitat resulting from the expansion of the Queensland agricultural industry. 2.4 Habitat Requirements Koalas are found in communities of eucalypts and some related species. While Koalas choose their habitat based on the suitability of food trees, the reasons for choosing these trees are not well understood. However Carrick (2013) notes that “There are now several studies which show that roost trees used by Koalas are usually different from fodder trees and that shelter requirements are often (probably usually) as important as browse (Ellis et al., 2002; Carrick et al. 2007; Mathews et al., 2007; Woodward et al., 2008)”. There are generally more Koalas in forests and woodlands occurring on more fertile soils. Carrick (2013) notes that “..since the ‘more fertile soils’ are often also the better watered soils, it is possible that the association with Koalas (which mostly depend on consumed foliage for their water requirements as well as food) is really driven by soil water status (with landzone or soil fertility being a surrogate for water availability).” In more arid regions, water regime appears to be important, as Koalas are often more abundant along watercourses and on adjacent floodplains (Gordon et al. 1988; Melzer 1995; Munks et al. 1996). Koala populations generally attain different densities in different vegetation communities according to suitability of the habitat. Plant communities that support higher densities are regarded as preferred habitat in an area. Carrick (2013) also stresses that “.. there is a temporal aspect to Koala habitat – this can be short term (seasonal) or long term (successional or maturational). In other words, Koala habitats are not static: (i) Koalas have been shown to change occupancy and utilise different resources seasonally (e.g. Ellis et al., 1995) and (ii) the carrying capacity of an area will increase as the vegetation develops and then decline as the forest ages and foliage productivity decreases – thus areas of regrowth that contain adequate numbers of older mature trees to provide shelter often provide high carrying capacity for Koalas. For Northern Koalas (in NSW and QLD) forest / woodland floristic and structural diversity appears to be important – thus if an area of regrowth is comprised of an even aged stand of a limited mix of canopy species (such as some areas on the northern side of Eenie Creek), its value as Koala habitat may surprisingly be relatively low despite the dominance of a recognised fodder and / or shelter species. Whilst it is true that the cited references report the preferential use of larger trees, this is only part of the story since it is based on observations of daytime tree use in relatively mesic locations. Daytime tree use provides an indication of roost tree selection and it is certainly true that a proportion of larger trees is important to provide safe refuges for Koalas. However, Koalas use different trees nocturnally (sometimes relatively small ones) for browsing and in adverse weather conditions Koalas will use small trees with dense canopies (Acacia, Callitris, Leptospermum, Melaleuca, Syzigium and various rainforest species) (Ellis et al., 2007; Cristescu et al., 2011) for shelter.” Koalas successfully use highly fragmented habitats that have only small remnants of the original vegetation (Gordon 1989; Gordon et al. 1990a; White 1999). They also use young forest and highly modified vegetation such as grazed, disturbed or thinned forest and regrowth areas, moving significant distances across the ground between preferred trees. Research has also found they prefer larger trees (Sharpe 1984, Hindell and Lee 1987, White 1999). Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 4
Page 9
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment 2.5 Diet Koalas are specialised leaf-eaters, with food restricted mainly to species of Eucalyptus and some related genera including Corymbia, Angophora and Lophostemon. However, Koalas also feed on a number of other species, including species from the genera Melaleuca and Leptospermum. Diet is thought to be a major determinant of habitat selection. Attempts to identify Koala food trees on the basis of leaf chemistry or environmental characteristics such as soil fertility have failed to provide a full explanation of Koala food tree preference. Recent research has shown that certain eucalypt leaf compounds, formulated phloroglucinol compounds (FPCs), adversely affect mammals (Lawler et al. 1998; Moore and Foley 2000). Some possums that feed on eucalypts select trees with low levels of FPCs, and it is likely that this also has a major influence on Koala food selection (Martin and Handasyde 1999). Koalas usually show a preference for a small number of food trees in each locality, but may also feed on other species that are present. The latter are often referred to as secondary food species. Food tree preference often varies regionally and between different vegetation communities and a species that is preferred in one region or community may sometimes be avoided in another region or community. In respect of the identification and classification of “primary” and “secondary” food species, Carrick (2013) notes that “…most of the publications that have purported to have studied tree species eaten by Koalas have done no such thing (see Ellis et al., 2013 for discussion of flawed assumptions used by a number of authors). The literature lacks objective definition of ‘primary’ and ‘secondary’ food trees – this is partly because of a lack of rigour but also because it is not as simple as it seems. In the Koala Coast, Tun (1993) found that in a brief period of the year (1 to 2 months) Koalas ate substantial amounts of Lophostemon foliage (which was a trivial or non-existent component of the diet at other times) – thus although Lophostemon might appear to make a very minor contribution as a proportion of the annual diet, it may well be that it is critical to getting Koalas through a period of the year when alternative suitable (i.e. tip growth) fodder is unavailable in that area. This prompts the question as to whether it can be considered as just a ‘secondary’ food species if it is vital to the animals, albeit for a restricted period each year?”. Koalas may also show a preference for individual trees within a species (Martin and Handasyde 1999). However, Carrick (2013) notes that “..this does not mean that another common myth applies – that Koalas repeatedly utilise only a very small number of individual trees within their home ranges that are their “kitchen trees” and “bedroom trees”. This notion is based on superficial observation of some trees that certainly do show signs of repeated use (probably related to restricted numbers of large trees in many areas that provide particular shelter resources; but detailed studies show that multiple use of a tree by the same or different individuals is relatively infrequent (Ellis et al., 2002, 2013).” 2.6 Reproduction Healthy females breed from about two years of age and give birth each year. Carrick (2013) notes that “..Koala births have been observed in Queensland in every month of the year, but are quite uncommon in mid-Winter (June and July) and most common in Summer (December, January, February).” Young begin to emerge from the pouch at about six months of age and are weaned at about 12 months of age. Koalas are dependent for a long period of time compared to most other marsupials. Failure to breed for two or more successive years is usually a sign of infertility brought on by a chlamydial infection of the reproductive tract. High levels of female infertility are present in many Koala populations, with levels of more than 50 percent being recorded (Gordon et al. 1990a). This results in depression of the reproductive rate and may lead to reduced population growth or population decline. In respect of the above, Carrick (2013) notes that “…that many factors can lead to lowered fecundity in some populations; only sometimes is this related to pathological infertility. For example, by being able to undertake long term studies it has been found that there was a lack of recruitment into a Koala population for over four years during a prolonged drought, but subsequently the same ‘infertile’ females produced young after the drought was relieved. In most Queensland Koala populations there is a fairly high prevalence of chlamydial infection but almost no chlamydial disease of any kind, including reproductive tract pathology. In a few locations (particularly the southeast coastal LGAs) disease is an issue and it may be no coincidence that these are the Koala populations where ‘Koala rescue’ interventions are most common – there are concerns that lack of adequate isolation and quarantine measures in some facilities providing care may be contributing to the problem.” Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 5
Page 10
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment 2.7 Behaviour Koalas live for about 15 years in the wild. They are solitary and show fidelity to a home range (Mitchell 1990; Gordon et al. 1990b; Martin and Handasyde 1999). They tend not to be territorial, with male and female home ranges overlapping. Social interactions between adult individuals tend to be more frequent in the breeding season and are often aggressive (Mitchell 1990). Carrick (2013) notes that “Site fidelity in Koalas should not be thought of as an absolute – Fitzgibbon et al. (2007) reported that home ranges of Koalas varied over 7 years of a study, from 27% to 73%. It depends what is meant by ‘territorial’ – in animals generally, female home ranges can overlap male home ranges even when a male actively defends a territory against incursions from other males (or even when females seek to exclude other females). In the case of Koalas, male home ranges may also exhibit some degree of overlap – but although not spatially exclusive, home ranges are mostly temporally exclusive and Koalas have a repertoire of vocal and olfactory means to deter male conspecifics. Actual physical aggression is rarely observed in Queensland populations and the frequency reported by Mitchell (1990) may have been associated with the artificially established and constrained Victorian island population he was studying.” Adult females and their young share a close bond (Martin and Handasyde 1999) until the young are weaned. Recently weaned young often occupy an overlapping home range with their mothers (Ramsay 1999) until they are two years old. From about two to four years of age, a large proportion of male and female Koalas disperse from their birth areas. This usually corresponds with the breeding season (Dique et al. 2003b). The movement of adult and dispersing individuals in the breeding season increases the risk of car strikes and dog attacks (Dique et al. 2003b). Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 6
Page 11
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
3 Koala Habitat within the Noosa on Weyba Site
Locality
3.1 Historical Context
An aerial photograph of the Noosa on Weyba site locality taken in 1974 and presented below demonstrates
that past land use practices have had a substantial impact on the distribution and characteristics of Koala
habitat resources within the Noosa on Weyba site and surrounding locality.
: Noosa on Weyba Site
The above 1974 aerial photograph, and others presented in Figure 2, illustrate that in the relatively recent
past extensive areas of the Noosa on Weyba site have been subject to broad-scale vegetation clearance
activities. The majority of wooded vegetation and Koala habitat that currently exists on these previously
cleared sections of the site is regrowth arising from these clearance activities.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 7
Page 12
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
3.2 Koala SPRP Habitat Values Mapping
In 2008, the Premier of Queensland formed a Koala Taskforce which provided recommendations aimed at
halting and reversing the decline of Koalas in SEQ. One of the key recommendations was to undertake
comprehensive mapping of Koala habitat across SEQ that identifies and ranks Koala habitat from highest to
lowest value. This recommendation was implemented as documented within the Department of Environment
and Resource Management South East Queensland Koala Habitat Assessment and Mapping Project (GHD
2009).
The resultant Koala habitat mapping for the Noosa on Weyba locality is presented in the South East
Queensland Koala Habitat Values Map (Ref: map SPP_KHV 4 SEQKPA v1.2), created by the then
Department of Environment and Resource Management (DERM), and is presented in Appendix A and
reproduced in Figure 3. This figure shows the extent of the various Koala Habitat Value types mapped as
occurring within the Noosa on Weyba “Send” and “Receive” sites. Table 3-1 provides a summary of these
extents.
Table 3-1 Extents of Koala habitat types within the Noosa on Weyba site
Koala Habitat Type Extent (ha)
Send Site Receive Site Total
Bushland Habitat High Value 0.00 0.00 0.00
Bushland Habitat Medium Value 33.8 39.8 73.6
Bushland Habitat Low Value 93.6 39.3 132.9
Suitable for Rehabilitation – High Value 0.00 0.00 0.00
Suitable for Rehabilitation – High Value 5.70 74.9 80.6
Suitable for Rehabilitation – High Value 3.30 6.40 9.70
Non Habitat Areas 3.10 3.40 6.70
All 139.5 163.8 303.3
From Table 3-1 the following points are noted.
1. The Noosa on Weyba “Send” site contains predominantly Koala Bushland Habitat (Medium-Low
value) which comprises approximately 91% of the combined extent of the “Send” site (i.e. 127.4 ha),
while the areas of Rehabilitation and Non-habitat encompass approximately 9% of the combined
extent of the “Send” site (i.e. 12.1 ha).
2. Within the Noosa on Weyba “Receive” site the combined area for Koala Bushland Habitat is 79.1 ha
(48.3%), while the combined area for Rehabilitation Habitat is 81.3 ha (49.6%), and the area of non-
habitat is 3.4 ha (2.1%). In this respect the absolute and relative extents of Koala Bushland Habitat on
the Noosa on Weyba “Send” site is substantially greater than that which occurs on the Noosa on
Weyba “Receive” site.
3.3 Koala Habitat Trees
Pursuant to the Koala SPRP:
1. a Koala habitat tree means:
a. a food tree of the Corymbia, Melaleuca, Lophostemon or Eucalyptus genera; or
b. a preferred shelter species such as Angophora (note: DEHP also recognise the following as
Koala habitat (shelter) trees: Acacia spp., Allocasuaina spp. and Casuarina spp.)
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 8
Page 13
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
2. a non-juvenile Koala habitat tree is a Koala habitat tree that has:
a. a height of more than four metres; or
b. a trunk with a circumference of more than 31.5 centimetres at 1.3 metres above the ground.
For the purposes of this assessment the above definitions have been adopted.
3.4 Field Based Observations
3.4.1 Methods
Systematic transect based surveys of Koala activity and habitat resources were carried out at a total of 47
locations within and adjacent to the Noosa on Weyba site over the period between 14 June 2012 and 10
August 2012. The transect based surveys provided data concerning the following parameters at each of the
survey locations.
> Koala presence/absence;
> evidence of past Koala activity in the form of scat or scratches; and
> Koala habitat tree presence, species composition, size and abundance/density.
The locations of transect based surveys are illustrated in Figure 4 and a description of the survey methods
used is provided in Appendix B.
In addition to the transect based surveys searches for Koala presence and indicators of activity were made
throughout the Noosa on Weyba project site during general ecological surveys and site inspections carried
out in 2005-2006 (Lot 53 SP163571 and Lot 2 on SP179590 only) and on 27 September 2011; 3-4 April
2012; 1-2 May 2012; 14 June 2012; 5-6 July 2012 and 9-10 August 2012.
3.4.2 Results
Field based observations and assessments of the Koala habitat values of the Noosa on Weyba project site
have confirmed the presence of Koala within the Noosa on Weyba project site and on adjacent land, but
indicate that overall Koala densities and activity levels across the Noosa on Weyba site locality are relatively
low and not uniformly distributed. The findings of the field based Koala surveys and assessments confirm
the general accuracy of the Koala SPRP Habitat Value Mapping, with the exception of an area located to the
north and east of the junction of Tidswell Road and Hollett Road that is classified as “Non-Habitat Areas”
which should be classified as “Bushland Habitat Low Value”.
No direct observations of Koala have been made within the Noosa on Weyba site during diurnal and
nocturnal field surveys. The most commonly recorded indicators of Koala activity were scratches on the
trunks of smooth barked Eucalypts, predominately E. racemosa and E. tereticornis, such as those presented
in Plate 1. Koala scat, such as that presented in Plate 2, was infrequently located beneath the canopy of
recognised Koala primary food trees with scat most frequently recorded beneath the canopy of E. robusta
and E. tereticornis. The infrequent observation of scat may in part be due to the fact that the high rainfall
experienced within the Noosa locality over the 2010-2012 period would have substantially reduced the
persistence of Koala scat (Cristescu et al., 2012).
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 9
Page 14
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Plate 1: Fresh Koala scat recorded at based of E. robusta located Plate 2: Fresh Koala scratches on trunk of E. tereticornis within an area of remnant RE12.3.5 on 9 August 2012 Transect based surveys carried out in 2012 confirmed that there is substantial variation in the characteristics of Koala habitat present throughout the Noosa on Weyba site. The average density of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees recorded within each of the broad vegetation types identified within the Noosa on Weyba site is presented in Table 3-2 and the distributions of these vegetation types are illustrated in Figure 5. Other relevant information concerning the floristic composition, structure and extent of each vegetation type within the Noosa on Weyba site is presented in Appendix C. The plot based estimates of the density of non- juvenile Koala habitat trees within sampled vegetation types ranged from a density of less than 50 trees/ha in predominately cleared land to over 4,000 trees/ha in some areas of dense Broadleaved paperbark (Melaleuca quinquenervia) dominated regrowth. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 10
Page 15
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
Table 3-2 Koala Habitat Types within the Noosa on Weyba project site
Ref # Vegetation - Habitat Type Extent (ha) Estimated density of non-
juvenile Koala habitat
trees/ ha:
Average
(Min – Max)
1 RE 12.3.4 - Melaleuca quinquenervia, Eucalyptus 82.8 1,930
robusta open forest on or near coastal alluvial plains (802 - 4,087)
2 RE 12.3.5 - Melaleuca quinquenervia open forest on 45.5 1,882
coastal alluvium (719 - 3,245)
3 RE 12.3.11 - Eucalyptus siderophloia, E. tereticornis,
Corymbia intermedia open forest on alluvial plains
usually near coast 1,002
3a - Intact Understorey 1.84 (559 - 1,445)
3b - Cleared understorey 0.94
4 RE 12.5.3 - Eucalyptus tindaliae and/or E. racemosa
open forest on remnant Tertiary surfaces
1,129
4a - Intact understorey 37.23 (303 - 3,967)
4b - Cleared understorey 4.26
5 RE 12.3.13 - Closed heathland on seasonally 26.66 -
waterlogged alluvial plains usually near coast
6 RE 12.9-10.1 - Shrubby open forest often with 2.10 -
Eucalyptus resinifera, E. grandis, Corymbia intermedia
on sedimentary rocks.
7 Melaleuca quinquenervia Regrowth 11.75 2,291
(1,104 – 4,425)
8 Non-remnant Woodland-Open Forest Vegetation 88.24 196
(3 – 1,124)
9 Lakeside Vegetation 0.02 -
10 Waterway Vegetation 1.66 -
302.8 843
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 11
Page 16
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
4 Threats to Koala within the Noosa on Weyba Site
Locality
The general natures of the key recognised threats to Koala that operate within the Noosa on Weyba site
locality are described below.
4.1 Habitat Clearance and Fragmentation
The clearing and fragmentation of Koala habitat is considered to be the single most important factor affecting
the observed decline in the SEQ Koala populations (EPA 2006).
As is evident from the historical aerial photography presented in Figure 2, the Noosa on Weyba site locality
was in the 1960’s subjected to extensive clearance of native forests and woodlands for rural purposes which
would have impacted upon the carrying capacity of the area for Koala. In more recent times further
clearance of native forests and woodlands has occurred to facilitate urban and commercial developments to
the north and south of the Noosa on Weyba site. Regrowth of vegetation that has occurred in some areas
within the site would have reversed some of the adverse effects of the original clearing. However the Koala
habitat values of regrowth vegetation, which often tends to be less species diverse and structurally complex
than the original vegetation, can often be substantially lower than the originating vegetation.
In the 2000s Walter Hay Drive was constructed and created a substantial barrier to the safe movement of
Koala, and other terrestrial fauna, between areas of habitat associated with western foreshores of Lake
Weyba and more extensive areas of Koala habitat located within the Sunshine Coast hinterland. Walter
Hay Drive is a major arterial roadway conveying high volumes of road traffic (> 10,000 vehicles per day) at
significant velocities (80-100 kph). Eumundi Noosa Road, which runs roughly parallel to and ~2 km to the
west of Walter Hay Drive, is another major arterial roadway that represents a substantive barrier to the safe
movement of Koala through the broader landscape.
The Koala habitat in the Noosa on Weyba site locality has only tenuous links with areas of Koala habitat
located to the east of Lake Weyba (i.e. Noosa Heads), with existing urban development, Eenie Creek Road
and to a less extent Weyba Creek all restricting the free and safe movement of Koalas.
Within the Noosa on Weyba site boundaries further clearance of Koala habitat is likely to occur in the future
as existing land use and committed development rights are taken up by the land owners. Specifically in this
respect it is noted that Lot 53 on SP163571 is the subject of a current Rezoning approval (Plan of
Development No. 68) that has the effect of amending the planning scheme. A formal Reconfiguring a Lot
(RaL) development application was lodged in 2007 to give effect to this rezoning approval. That application
was the subject of a Planning and Environment Court Appeal (344/09) which was resolved on 5 July 2013.
The Court approved layout of development of Lot 53 is represented on JF&P Drawing Ref: M1775-00-12 (F)
dated 18 July 2012 and presented in Appendix D. This development would, for the purposes of the Koala
SPRP, constitute “Committed Development” and would involve clearance of Koala Bushland Habitat that
would be permitted under the Koala SPRP without the need for any associated offsets. The locations and
extents of clearance within areas of Koala Bushland Habitat that would be permitted within Lot 53 are
illustrated in Figure 6 which provides an overlay of JF&P Drawing Ref: M1775-00-12 (F) on the Koala SPRP
Koala Habitat Values Mapping. In total 6.15 ha of Koala Bushland Habitat clearance would be permissible if
the development approval over Lot 53 was taken up.
Lot 11 on SP250714 has an area of 40.7 ha and is the subject of a Material Change of Use (Rural Holiday
Accommodation) approval which allows for the establishment of a network of villas and associated
infrastructure with the capacity to accommodate up to 108 persons at the site. The approved plan of
development concentrates development in the eastern half of Lot 11. The approved plan of development is
designed to minimise the clearance of native vegetation and wildlife habitat and as such is not likely to
involve the clearance of any areas of Koala Bushland Habitat located within Lot 11, however some clearance
of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees is likely to be required to facilitate the construction and safe occupation of
the development. As this development would constitute Committed Development any necessary clearance
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 12
Page 17
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
of Koala habitat trees would be permitted and not trigger an offset requirement. The layout of the approved
plan of development is illustrated in Figure 6.
It is also noted that the above development commitments would require the upgrading of Hollett Road and
Tidswell Road to cater for the increased road traffic volumes that would be generated by these
developments. The upgrading of these existing roadways would involve further clearance of Koala habitat
located within the designated road reserves.
4.2 Vehicular Traffic Impacts
In 1995, the Queensland Parks and Wildlife Service, the Queensland Department of Main Roads and
Redland Shire Council initiated the Koala Speed Zone Trial in the Koala Coast, south-east Queensland
(Dique et al. 2003c). The study found that from 1995–1999:
> at least 1,407 Koalas were hit by vehicles;
> 83% of Koalas hit by vehicles died; and
> 61% of Koalas hit by vehicles were young, healthy males (2–4 years old).
Males disperse more to look for mates, particularly when a population is reducing, and it is thought that this
accounts for the disproportionate number of young males killed trying to cross roads. Ultimately, deaths of
breeding-age males are likely to have an impact on the population’s viability.
Further research and Koala road strike/fatality monitoring within Southeast Queensland (Preece 2007)
demonstrates that:
1. vehicle associated mortality is one of the major factors in the decline of some Koala populations;
2. the vast majority of death and injury to Koalas caused by motor vehicles occurs between dusk and
dawn during the Koala breeding season (August – December);
3. the vast majority of this mortality occurs on high traffic volume, high speed (posted speed limit greater
than 60 kph) roads; and
4. mortality caused by motor vehicles is negligible within residential areas, where the speed limit is
mostly 50 kph.
The Noosa on Weyba site locality is traversed by a number of formed roadways that vary from rudimentary
unsealed rural roadways that covey a small number of daily vehicular movements at relatively low speeds (<
60 kph) to major arterial roadways that convey substantial volumes of high velocity (80-100 kph) vehicular
traffic. The configuration of the local road network is illustrated in Figure 1 and details concerning the
characteristics of key roadways are provided in Table 4-1.
Table 4-1 Roadways in the Noosa on Weyba site locality
Roadway Road Type 2012 Daily Posted Existing Impact Mitigation Measures
Vehicular Speed
Movements * Limit (kph)
Exclusion Fencing Crossing
Structures
Walter Hay Drive Arterial 12,950 80-100 Partial 3
Eenie Creek Road (west Arterial 80 No -
18,870
of Weyba Creek)
Eumundi – Noosa Road Arterial 12,015 80-100 No -
Eumarella Road Sealed 820 80 No -
Hollett Road (East of Unsealed Rural 50 No -
< 100
Walter Hay Drive)
Hollett Road (West of Unsealed Rural 50 No -
100-150
Walter Hay Drive)
Tidswell Road Unsealed Rural <100 50 No -
*: source - Traffic Impact Assessment – Noosa on Weyba (Cardno 2012, 2013)
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 13
Page 18
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment The movement of Koala across local roadways is largely unregulated, apart from the presence of the safe fauna passage infrastructure elements described in Table 4-2. The locations of the infrastructure are illustrated in Figure 3. Table 4-2 Safe fauna passage roadway infrastructure Infrastructure Photograph Koala Exclusion Fencing 1 km of Koala exclusion fencing extending along either side of Walter Hay Drive, with the balance 3 km of Walter Hay Drive having no Koala guide fencing. The existing exclusion fencing extends from the Hollett Road underpass (pictured opposite) in a southerly direction for a distance of approximately 1 km. Fauna Passage Culverts Two 3x3x20m box culverts beneath Walter Hay Drive, one of which also functions as a vehicular connection between the western and eastern sections of Hollett Road. The southern culvert (pictured below) incorporates a number of structures that are designed to facilitate the safe passage of native fauna (e.g. Koala escape poles and elevated walkway. Eenie Creek Bridge Walter Hay Drive incorporates a bridge over Eenie Creek, beneath which there is capacity for Koala movement along both the northern and southern banks of Eenie Creek. This is the main avenue for the safe east-west movement of Koala. The Eenie Creek Bridge is ~14m in width and the height of the bridge underpass ranges from ~4 m to ~1m. The width of the bridge underpass ranges from ~36m on the southern bank of Eenie Creek to ~140m on the northern bank of Eenie Creek. At this location Eenie Creek is ~36m in width. Escape poles are absent and could be provided beneath the bridge to assist Koala in avoiding any dogs that may attempt to ambush a Koala moving beneath the bridge. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 14
Page 19
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Infrastructure Photograph Awareness Signage Roadside signage has an important role to play in making drivers aware of the potential presence of Koala on local roadways. If driver awareness levels are high and road design and maintenance creates a low speed environment with good roadside visibility, the potential for conflict between Koala and vehicles is low. Koala awareness signage (such as that shown opposite) is not prominent on local roadways within the Noosa on Weyba locality. The absence of exclusion fencing along the majority of Walter Hay Drive means that this arterial roadway represents a significant potential source of mortality, and morbidity, to Koalas that inhabit the Noosa on Weyba site locality. It is also noted that where exclusion fencing is present its efficacy is currently compromised by inadequate maintenance as indicated by a failure to: > exclude trees and shrubs from within 3 m of the fence; > keep canopies of trees trimmed to remove links to tree canopies on the other side of the fence; and > remove fallen trees, branches and vines growing on the fence to maintain fence effectiveness. The absence of Koala exclusion fencing along Eumundi-Noosa Road, and associated provision for safe movement of Koala beneath or over that roadway, is also likely to have adverse impacts on the long-term viability of the local Koala population that is sustained by: > habitat resources available within the Noosa on Weyba site locality; and > the occasional movement of Koala between habitat located to the east and west of Eumundi-Noosa Road. Given current vehicular volumes and velocities, Hollett Road and Tidswell Road are not likely to represent any substantive threat to Koalas that inhabit the Noosa on Weyba locality. 4.3 Dog Related Impacts Domestic and feral dogs have a significant and preventable impact on Koala populations, particularly in south-east Queensland. Attacks from dogs are the third most significant known cause of death behind car strikes and habitat clearing. Although there would be some predation on Koalas by wild dogs, dog-related mortality is principally caused by domestic dogs, generally in suburban backyards. A study (de Villiers et al. in press) demonstrated that: > whilst dog attacks occur throughout the year, dogs attack occur with a greater frequency in the months leading up to the Koala breeding season (July to September); > the seasonal peak in dog attacks in September particularly affects young males; > ~96 % of recorded dog attacks are by dogs larger than 10 kg in weight with few attacks being attributed to dogs weighing less than 7 kg; > there is a higher incidence of attacks on Koala on properties where two or more dogs are present; > the frequency of dog attacks in a suburb strongly correlates with the density of dogs in the suburb; and > dog attacks on sick Koalas occur no more frequently than dog attacks on healthy Koalas. The Noosa on Weyba site locality is inhabited by a mixture of domestic and feral dogs and there is a general absence of specific regulations targeting the keeping of dogs under existing land tenure and ownership arrangements. Feral dogs and dog scat were also observed at the Noosa on Weyba site on several occasions during the field surveys (see photograph presented in Plate 3 below), including the sighting of a Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 15
Page 20
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment group of three dogs on one occasion moving from Lot 1667 on M3772 across Lot 11 on SP250714 and into the adjoining Weyba Nature Refuge. Plate 3: Feral (or unrestrained domestic) dog photographed on Lot 1667 on M3772 on 27 September 2011. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 16
Page 21
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
5 Noosa on Weyba Koala Implications
5.1 Proposed Plan of Development
The proposed Noosa on Weyba Precinct Plan (Ref: NORT0001 MP-006-D) is presented in Appendix E. For
the purpose of this assessment and as part of the Noosa on Weyba design process a Concept Master Plan
was also prepared to examine in greater detail a potential form of urban development that could occur if the
current MCU Application was to be approved. The Noosa on Weyba Concept Master Plan is also presented
in Appendix E. The layout of the Noosa on Weyba Concept Master Plan, on aerial photography of the site, is
also presented in Figure 7.
The proposed Noosa on Weyba Concept Master Plan will result in 19% of the total area being dedicated to
urban development with the remaining 81% being retained for parkland and conservation purposes. Over
45% of the Noosa on Weyba site will be dedicated to the State for incorporation into the Noosa National Park
in accordance with the Noosa on Weyba BDOA declaration.
The proposed urban portion of the Noosa on Weyba site will accommodate approximately 876 dwellings in a
mixed density configuration as well as access roadways and associated infrastructure. Future allotments will
be established into approximately three sub-categories with different densities as follows:
> 493 residential lots at an average density of 13 lots/ha;
> 377 medium density dwellings comprising apartment, townhouse and retirement living at an average of
26 lots/ha; and
> 6 rural and special residential lots at an average of 5 lots/ha.
Key aspects of the proposed Noosa on Weyba project from an environmental and biodiversity conservation
perspective are as follows.
1. Dedication of ~140 ha of high conservation value land (of which 120 ha is Koala Bushland Habitat) to
the State for incorporation into the Noosa National Park estate, including implementation of
environmental enhancement works within ~8.4 ha of land that has previously been cleared, to
regenerate native vegetation communities and Koala habitat.
2. Retention of an additional ~92 ha of high conservation value land (i.e. mapped areas of remnant
vegetation or Koala Bushland Habitat, buffers to waterways and wetlands) within that part of the
Noosa on Weyba site that is to be retained in private ownership, which is to be managed for
conservation purposes under the terms of a Body Corporate agreement.
3. A land use pattern which provides corridors of wildlife habitat that will facilitate the movement of native
wildlife species within and through the Noosa on Weyba site.
4. If the Noosa on Weyba proposal is approved, an application will also be submitted to the Department
of Environment and Heritage Protection (DEHP) for the registration of the Noosa on Weyba Receive
land as a Nature Refuge protected under the provisions of the Nature Conservation Act 1992. The
Nature Refuge declaration will be sought to provide an additional and independent of the Body
Corporate means of ensuring that the environmental commitments that have underpinned the design
of the Noosa on Weyba proposal are maintained into the future. The Noosa on Weyba Nature Refuge
would complement:
a. the Tainsh’s Nature Refuge which forms part of the adjoin Eumarella Shores development to
the south;
b. the Council controlled Weyba Nature Refuge to the south-west; and
c. the Noosa National Park dedications made as part of the Noosa on Weyba project.
The Noosa on Weyba Nature Refuge could also, or as an alternative, form part of a Co-ordinated
Conservation Area (CCA) encompassing the expanded Noosa National Park, the Weyba Nature
Refuge and Tainsh’s Nature Refuge. CCA’s are established under the provisions of the NC Act and
pursuant to s24 of the NC Act a CCA is to be managed to:
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 17
Page 22
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
a. conserve the area’s natural and cultural values by coordinated management involving the
area’s various landholders; and
b. take account of the area’s values, including its recreational, educational and commercial
values; and
c. provide for the interests of the various landholders to be maintained.
5. Establishment of urban land uses (i.e. dwellings, roadways etc) within ~58 ha (19%) of the Noosa on
Weyba site, within areas that have been selectively cleared and generally do not support areas of
remnant vegetation or Koala Bushland Habitat. The only proposed clearance of remnant vegetation
and mapped Koala Bushland Habitat is to establish:
a. a necessary road connections between proposed Precinct H and the existing Hollett Road
reserve; and
b. an internal road connection linking Precincts I, K and L, which is proposed as an alternative to
the upgrading of the existing Hollett Road which would involve a substantially greater extent of
remnant vegetation, Koala Bushland Habitat and hollow bearing tree removal.
6. Maintenance of building setbacks of ~30m between residential land uses and adjacent areas of
bushland vegetation located within or external to the Noosa on Weyba site. These building setbacks,
in combination with the establishment of a reticulated water supply and an appropriately designed and
constructed road network, will ensure that the ecological values and functions of retained areas of
bushland are not compromised by bushfire hazard management measures and concerns.
7. Design of a road network to service the Noosa on Weyba project that minimises the clearance of
Koala habitat, maintains low vehicular speeds (< 50 kph) and enhanced driver awareness of the
potential for native fauna to be encountered.
8. Management of urban residential areas under a Body Corporate (BC) arrangement which will focus
on:
> preservation, protection and appropriate management of native vegetation and fauna habitats;
> use of native plant species in all landscaping within the site;
> strategic and targeted measures to minimise impacts on Koalas and native fauna generally, with
specific controls on the keeping of domestic pets; and
> provision of an environmental levy to fund environmental and biodiversity initiatives within the
Noosa on Weyba site locality, such as extensions to and maintenance of the Walter Hay Drive
fauna exclusion fencing.
The likely implications of the proposed Noosa on Weyba development upon Koala habitat, including
consideration of measures that are proposed to mitigate and offset potentially adverse impacts, are
discussed in greater detail below.
5.2 Koala Habitat Retention and Management
Habitat loss has been identified as the greatest threat to Koala survival, with habitat clearing for urban
development, broad scale clearing in rural and semi-urban areas and fragmentation by development creating
barriers to movement between retained patches of bushland.
The relationship between the proposed layout of development and mapped areas of Koala Bushland Habitat
is illustrated in Figure 8.
The following habitat retention and management commitments form part of the Noosa on Weyba project.
1. Retention of over 120 ha of Koala Bushland Habitat contained within the Noosa on Weyba Send sites
and the formal surrender of existing use and development rights over that land and dedication of that
land to the State for inclusion within the National Park estate.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 18
Page 23
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
2. Retention of ~78 ha of Koala Bushland Habitat contained within the Noosa on Weyba Receive site,
which represents ~99% of the mapped Koala Bushland Habitat occurring within the Receive site. The
only clearance of Koala Bushland Habitat that is proposed is:
a. the clearance of ~100 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees within a 0.58 ha area of Medium Value
Koala Bushland Habitat for the purpose of establishing a necessary road linkage between
Precinct H and Hollett Road; and
b. the clearance of ~437 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees within a 0.41 ha area of Medium Value
Koala Bushland Habitat for the purpose of establishing an internal road connection linking
Precincts I, K and L, which is proposed as an alternative to the upgrading of the existing Hollett
Road which would involve a substantially greater extent of remnant vegetation, Koala Bushland
Habitat and hollow bearing tree removal.
Additional detail concerning the location, purpose and nature of this clearance is provided in Section
5.3 below.
3. Provision for the preservation and enhancement of the following habitat linkages/corridors:
a. a northeast-southwest biodiversity corridor extending through the south-east corner of Lot 53
that connects the Noosa National Park – Eenie Creek Section with the Council controlled
Weyba Nature Refuge to the south;
b. a biodiversity corridor extending along the northern boundary of Lot 53 and Eenie Creek which
provides the primary avenue for the safe east-west passage of Koala, and other terrestrial
fauna, beneath Walter Hay Drive;
c. a north-south biodiversity corridor, extending through the western portion of Lot 53 and centred
on a natural drainage line, that provides connectivity between Council controlled land to the
south and the Eenie Creek corridor;
d. three multi-functional open space corridors which will provide multiple north-south linkages
between the expanded Noosa National Park and the Tainsh’s Nature Refuge to the south of the
Noosa on Weyba site, these linkages being located:
> along the Lake Weyba foreshore;
> coincident with a band of Endangered remnant vegetation and Koala Bushland Habitat; and
> along a modified overland flow path.
Enhancement of these designated corridors will involve the removal of inappropriate fencing,
management of weeds and restoration of habitat within cleared or degraded areas.
4. Active management of retained bushland habitat within the Noosa on Weyba site to preserve and
enhance their biodiversity values, including their value as Koala habitat. This will be achieved via:
a. the development and implementation of a Biodiversity Management Strategy for the Noosa on
Weyba project which will contain detailed biodiversity management guidelines in respect of
various topics including, but not necessarily limited to, the following:
> vegetation management;
> fauna habitat and movement management;
> waterways and wetland management;
> weed management;
> pest and domestic pet management;
> landscape management;
> bushfire management for biodiversity;
> monitoring; and
> public access and education.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 19
Page 24
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
b. the recurrent funding of the implementation of biodiversity management works via the
Environmental Levy implemented as part of the Noosa on Weyba Community Management
Scheme.
5.3 Koala Habitat Clearance
5.3.1 Clearance Within Mapped Koala Bushland Habitat
The proposed Noosa on Weyba development will generally locate development outside of mapped areas of
Koala Bushland Habitat, however in several instances it is proposed to locate some infrastructure within or
through mapped areas of Koala Bushland Habitat. The nature and purpose of these infrastructure elements
and the associated extent of non-juvenile Koala habitat tree clearance that would be required are described
in Table 5-1.
Table 5-1 Proposed infrastructure within mapped Koala Bushland Habitat
Nature of Infrastructure and habitat clearance proposed within mapped Representative Photograph / Image
Koala Bushland Habitat
Internal roadway linking proposed Walter Hay Drive roundabout to
Hollett Road east.
Purpose of Infrastructure:
Proposed roadway is aligned within existing cleared corridor located on
Lot 53 on SP163571 to the East of Walter Hay Drive. The selected
alignment is the least impacting alignment for a necessary road
connection between Walter Hay Drive and the eastern sector of Hollett
Road. A tree survey has been carried out of this area to assist in
designing a road connection that minimises the clearance of non-
juvenile Koala habitat trees. The engineering design for the roadway
with relevant tree survey details is presented in Appendix F.
Extent of Clearance:
Approximately 100 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees would require
clearance to facilitate the establishment of this linear infrastructure.
Internal roadway linking Precinct I and K, running parallel to Hollett
Road west.
Purpose of Infrastructure:
Proposed roadway is aligned within existing cleared property
maintenance corridor that traverses and area of regrowth paperbark
located along the Lot 53 on SP163571 and Hollett Road (west)
boundary. The selected alignment has been chosen as an alternative
to the upgrading of the adjacent section of Hollett Road which contains
higher ecological value vegetation, including areas of Endangered and
Of concern remnant vegetation and old growth hollow bearing trees.
Extent of Clearance:
An estimated 386 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees, almost exclusively
regrowth Melaleuca quinquenervia, would require clearance to facilitate
the establishment of this 400m long piece of linear infrastructure.
Internal roadway linking Precinct K and L.
Purpose of Infrastructure:
A relatively short (i.e. <50m) long roadway connection that traverses
the edge of a mapped area of Medium Value Koala Bushland that
supports remnant Scribbly gum dominated open forest. This internal
road link is proposed to connect these two Precincts as part of the
alternative to the upgrading of the adjacent Hollett Road which contains
higher ecological value vegetation, including areas of Endangered and
Of concern remnant vegetation and old growth hollow bearing trees.
Extent of Clearance:
An estimated 51 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees would require
clearance to facilitate the establishment of this linear infrastructure.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 20
Page 25
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Nature of Infrastructure and habitat clearance proposed within mapped Representative Photograph / Image Koala Bushland Habitat Services corridor and pedestrian/cycle way Purpose of Infrastructure: Water and sewer infrastructure connections are proposed to be established within an existing property access corridor through the south-eastern corridor of Lot 53. The previously described roadway was not positioned within this corridor due to its narrow width and the extent of habitat clearance that would have been required to accommodate the road connection. Extent of Clearance: None. Clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees would not be required within mapped areas of Koala bushland habitat. Supplementary planting of primary Koala food trees (e.g. E. robusta, E. tereticornis) along the edges of the corridor will be undertaken. Access to isolated Precinct J Building Envelope, Environmental and Fire Management Trails. Purpose of Infrastructure: A network of trails will be maintained within and along the perimeter of the retained areas of bushland within the Noosa on Weyba site to facilitate general environmental and bushfire management activities. An existing access trail will also be maintained through mapped Koala Bushland Habitat to the designated building envelope in Precinct 4. Within mapped areas of Koala Bushland Habitat existing property management trails will be maintained for this purpose. Extent of Clearance: None. Clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees would not be required within mapped areas of Koala bushland habitat for the purpose of establishing environmental and fire management trails. Street Access and Activated Retail (Precinct 1) Purpose of Infrastructure: Access driveways and some infrastructure associated with a small activated retail centre is proposed within a sparsely vegetated area of Koala Bushland Habitat that extends from Hollett Road into the north- eastern sector of Lot 11 on SP250714. Extent of Clearance: None. A detailed tree survey has been undertaken in this area and all infrastructure has been located such that construction works would not be required within the Tree Protection Zone* of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees located within this area of mapped Koala Bushland Habitat. Street Access to Precinct 1 – Community Facility Purpose of Infrastructure: Internal street access to proposed Community Facility would be aligned with an existing driveway that extends through a mapped area of Koala Bushland Habitat. Extent of Clearance: None. Clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees within mapped areas of Koala bushland habitat would not be required to establish/maintain this infrastructure. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 21
Page 26
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Nature of Infrastructure and habitat clearance proposed within mapped Representative Photograph / Image Koala Bushland Habitat Stormwater Management Infrastructure Purpose of Infrastructure: A number of bioretention basins and swales are proposed as part of the development’s integrated stormwater management system. Some of this infrastructure will be located within and/or adjacent to mapped areas of Koala bushland habitat. Extent of Clearance: None. All stormwater management infrastructure would be located within existing clearings and constructed in a manner such there would be no clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees within mapped areas of Koala Bushland Habitat. Low Impact Recreational Infrastructure Purpose of Infrastructure: Low impact recreational infrastructure within areas currently mapped as Koala Bushland Habitat would be limited to walking trails. Formal seating, picnic shelters, fenced dog off-leash areas, and some playground facilities would all be located outside of areas currently mapped as Koala Bushland Habitat. Extent of Clearance: None. All low impact recreational infrastructure elements would be located within existing clearings and constructed in a manner such there would be no clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees. *: Tree Protection Zone determined in accordance with Australian Standard AS 4970—2009 - Protection of trees on development sites. 5.3.2 Clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees The vast majority of non-juvenile Koala habitat tree clearance that would be required as a consequence of the proposed Noosa on Weyba development would be confined to areas that are not mapped as supporting Koala Bushland Habitat. Detailed surveys have been carried out to collate information concerning the number and species of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees that are located within areas where vegetation clearance is likely to be required for the following purposes: > bulk earthworks; > internal road works; > building works; and > bushfire hazard reduction purposes. The extent of the area wherein it has been assumed that all existing non-juvenile Koala habitat trees would potentially be cleared for the above purposes is illustrated in Figure 8. Within this potential clearing area field based counts and transect based estimates of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees were undertaken in the manner described in Appendix B. Table 5-2 provides a summary of the extents of the Noosa on Weyba Precincts where non-juvenile Koala habitat tree clearance is proposed, and an estimate of the number of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees that would be cleared based on a combination of direct counts and transect based estimates for the different vegetation types occurring within each Precinct. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 22
Page 27
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
Table 5-2 Number of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees proposed to be cleared within mapped Koala
Bushland Habitat and High or Medium Value Rehabilitation Areas
Proposed Corresponding Total Extent of Estimated number of % of total estimated
Development Superseded Extent Clearance Zone non- juvenile Koala number of non-
Precincts Development within mapped habitat trees to be juvenile Koala
Precincts* (ha) KBH and HVR or cleared within mapped habitat trees to be
MVR areas KBH and HVR or MVR cleared
(ha) ** areas (n)
A 0.62 0.00 0 0.0
1
B,C,D & E 14.06 9.55 103 1.9
F 3.18 3.75 287 5.2
2
G 8.34 7.08 12 0.2
H 6.01 1.20 52 0.9
3
I 16.20 13.67 1,592 28.9
J 1.77 1.77 75 1.4
4 K 0.67 0.00 0 0.0
L 5.20 0.00 0 0.0
H to Hollett Rd - 0.58 100 1.8
Internal Road I to K - 0.36 415 7.5
K to L - 0.05 51 0.9
Open Space M+N 245.53 0.00 0 0.0
Conservation
Zone O 1.71 0.00 0 0.0
ALL NoW 303.3 38.01 2,687 48.7
External Road Hollett Road 1.17 0.53 406 7.4
Upgrades
(*20m wide Tidswell Road 2.91 2.26 2,421 43.9
clearance)
ALL NoW + External Roadways 307.4 40.8 5,514 100.0
*: the locations of these superseded development precincts are illustrated in Noosa on Weyba Master Plan (Ref: NORT0001-MP-005-F
Precinct Structure Plan), presented in Appendix E, which is not a plan that is being submitted for approval. **: “KBH” is an area
mapped as High, Medium or Low Value Bushland Habitat pursuant to the Koala SPRP Habitat Values mapping; “HVR” is an area
mapped as High Value Rehabilitation habitat pursuant to the Koala SPRP Habitat Values mapping; “MVR” is an area mapped as
Medium Value Rehabilitation habitat pursuant to the Koala SPRP Habitat Values mapping.
It is noted that the subsequent analysis presented in this Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment reflects
a Precinct Structure Plan that has subsequently been superseded by Precinct Plan (Ref: NORT0001 MP-
006-D) which encompasses a number of the original Precincts as indicated in Table 5-2 and Appendix E.
5.3.3 Overall Clearance of Koala Habitat Trees
The Noosa on Weyba project is likely to require the clearance of ~5,500 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees
within mapped areas of Koala SPRP Bushland Habitat and High or Medium Value Rehabilitation habitat, with
the majority of that clearance being associated with external roadway upgrades (51%) and Precinct I (29%).
In addition to the loss of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees within mapped areas of Koala SPRP Bushland
Habitat and High or Medium Value Rehabilitation habitat, it is estimated that ~5,700 non-juvenile Koala
habitat trees would be lost from Koala SPRP mapped Low Value Rehabilitation or Generally Not Suitable
habitat areas.
To place the potential loss of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees into context, context it is relevant to estimate
the total number of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees located within the Noosa on Weyba site and the Hollett
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 23
Page 28
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment and Tidswell Road reserves. In this respect it is estimated, based on the data presented in Appendix B, that there are estimated to be: > ~342,000 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees within the boundaries of the Noosa on Weyba site; and > ~18,000 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees within the boundaries of the Hollett Road and Tidswell Road reserves. Based on this estimate the Noosa on Weyba development would involve the clearance of ~3% of the total number of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees within the boundaries of the Noosa on Weyba site and associated sections of Hollett Road and Tidswell Road, with 97% of the existing non-juvenile Koala habitat trees to be retained. Furthermore the overwhelming majority of the non-juvenile Koala habitat trees that would be cleared are: > species that are not recognised as primary habitat species in the Noosa Shire (Callaghan et al, 2011), with approximately 10% of surveyed non-juvenile Koala habitat trees being comprised of preferred species identified by Callaghan et al (2011) as Primary or Secondary species in the Noosa Shire; and > are comprised of areas of relatively young, high density regrowth of Melaleuca quinquenervia. It is also noted that the assumption that all non-juvenile Koala habitat trees within Precincts A – L, and in some adjacent sectors of Precinct M and N, would be cleared is a conservative assumption for the purposes of calculating potential impacts and offset liabilities. In practice, non-juvenile Koala habitat trees would be retained wherever it was possible and safe to do. Whilst the clearance of Koala habitat trees associated with the upgrading of external public roadways has been considered as part of this assessment it is relevant to note that: > the upgrading of external public roadways would be required independent of the proposed Noosa on Weyba development as a consequence of pre-existing development commitments and approvals; and > the upgrading of external public roadways would be undertaken by Council and does not constitute development assessable against the Koala SPRP. 5.4 Koala Habitat Offsets Koala habitat restoration and enhancement works are proposed as part of the Noosa on Weyba project to offset the clearance of Koala habitat resources that would be required to facilitate the proposed urban development aspects of the Noosa on Weyba project. The nature and scale of the proposed Koala habitat offsets are designed to enable the Noosa on Weyba project to satisfy the offset requirements of the Koala SPRP Offsets for Net Gain of Koala Habitat in South East Queensland Policy (the Koala Offset Policy). The Koala Offset Policy objective can be met by requiring an offset to contribute (through an appropriate delivery option) the equivalent of five new Koala habitat trees for every one non-juvenile koala habitat tree removed from areas of mapped Koala Bushland Habitat and mapped High or Medium Value Rehabilitation Habitat, thereby providing a net benefit ratio of 5:1. 5.4.1 Offset Capacity of the Noosa on Weyba Project The 139.5 ha Noosa on Weyba Send site is to be dedicated to the State for in-corporation into Noosa National Park if requisite approvals for the Noosa on Weyba project are secured. The majority of the Send land is forested land that is classified as Koala Bushland Habitat, with ~8.4 ha of being comprised of predominately cleared land where it is proposed to undertake Koala habitat offset works. The extent of Koala habitat offsets that could be accommodated within the predominately cleared sectors of the Send land have been assessed taking into account: > the structure and species composition of the vegetation that currently exists within the identified offset areas; > the structure and species composition of the pre-clearance ecosystem types within the identified offset areas; and > the density of Koala habitat plantings that would be appropriate taking into account observed densities of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees within surrounding areas of remnant and regrowth vegetation and Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 24
Page 29
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
accepted habitat restoration guidelines (e.g. South East Queensland Ecological Restoration Framework
(2012); Koala Nature Refuges Program – Guideline for Revegetation of Koala Habitat).
The locations and extents of identified Koala habitat offset areas within the Send land are illustrated in Figure
9. Table 5-3 provides a summary of the extent and nature of Koala habitat offset plantings that could be
sustained within the cleared sectors of the Send land.
Table 5-3 Estimated number of Koala habitat trees to be established within the Noosa on Weyba
Send site
Real Property Prescribed Vegetation Type(s) Extent Offset Density Estimated
(ha) – plants/ha Number of Koala
Offset Trees
Lot 1667 on RE12.5.3 - Eucalyptus tindaliae and/or E.
M37772 racemosa open forest on remnant Tertiary 4.61 2,000 9,220
surfaces
RE12.3.4 - Melaleuca quinquenervia, Eucalyptus
robusta open forest on or near coastal alluvial 1.82 3,000 5,460
plains
Lot 2 on RE12.9.10.1-Shrubby open forest often with
RP160983 Eucalyptus resinifera, E. grandis, Corymbia 1.60 2,000 3,200
intermedia on sedimentary rocks.
Lot 7 on RE12.9.10.1-Shrubby open forest often with
RP46782 Eucalyptus resinifera, E. grandis, Corymbia 0.33 2,000 660
intermedia on sedimentary rocks.
ALL 8.36 18,540
Based on the estimated clearance of ~5,500 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees from mapped Bushland Habitat
and High or Medium Value Rehabilitation habitat areas, the Send land has the capacity to accommodate
~67% of the Koala habitat offset required to satisfy the Koala Offset Policy net benefit ratio of 5:1.
The balance of the required offsets for the clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees will need to be
provided within the Noosa on Weyba Receive land. This part of the Noosa on Weyba site encompass
substantial areas of open space totalling ~106 ha of land that is comprised of a mixture of Koala Bushland
Habitat, remnant vegetation and substantially cleared land where Koala habitat offsets can be provided as
either:
> primary restoration of native vegetation communities and fauna habitat within sparsely vegetated areas;
or
> enhancement of the Koala habitat values of vegetation communities that are regenerating from past
clearance episodes and which are characterised by a paucity of primary Koala food trees.
The locations and extents of areas where these two forms of Koala habitat offsets are proposed within the
Noosa on Weyba Receive land are illustrated in Figure 9. Table 5-4 provides a summary of the number of
Koala habitat offset trees that could be established within the cleared sectors of the Noosa on Weyba
development site.
Table 5-4 Estimated number of Koala habitat offset trees to be established within the Noosa on
Weyba Receive site
Real Prescribed Vegetation and Koala Offset Type Extent Offset Estimated
Property Habitat Type(s) (ha) Density Number of Koala
– plants/ha Offset Trees
Lot 11 on RE12.5.3 - Eucalyptus tindaliae
SP250714 and/or E. racemosa open forest on Restoration 0.54 2,000 1,080
remnant Tertiary surfaces
RE12.3.4 - Melaleuca quinquenervia,
Eucalyptus robusta open forest on or Restoration 2.69 3,000 8,070
near coastal alluvial plains
RE12.3.11 - Eucalyptus siderophloia, Enhancement 1.15 250 288
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 25
Page 30
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
Real Prescribed Vegetation and Koala Offset Type Extent Offset Estimated
Property Habitat Type(s) (ha) Density Number of Koala
– plants/ha Offset Trees
E. tereticornis, Corymbia intermedia
open forest on alluvial plains usually
near coast
Lot 53 on RE12.5.3 - Eucalyptus tindaliae
SP163571 and/or E. racemosa open forest on Restoration 0.33 2,000 660
remnant Tertiary surfaces
RE12.3.4 - Melaleuca quinquenervia,
Eucalyptus robusta open forest on or Restoration 0.16 3,000 480
near coastal alluvial plains
RE12.3.5 -Melaleuca quinquenervia
Restoration 0.32 3,000 960
open forest on coastal alluvium
RE12.3.11 - Eucalyptus siderophloia,
E. tereticornis, Corymbia intermedia
Restoration 1.17 2,000 2,340
open forest on alluvial plains usually
near coast
RE12.3.5 -Melaleuca quinquenervia
Enhancement 28.59 250 7,148
open forest on coastal alluvium
Lot 2 on RE12.5.3 - Eucalyptus tindaliae
SP179590 and/or E. racemosa open forest on Restoration 0.63 2,000 1,260
remnant Tertiary surfaces
ALL 35.67 22,286
Based on the estimated clearance of ~5,500 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees from mapped Bushland Habitat
and High or Medium Value Rehabilitation habitat areas, the proposed open space reserves within the Noosa
on Weyba Receive land have the capacity to accommodate ~82% of the Koala habitat offset required to
satisfy the Koala Offset Policy net benefit ratio of 5:1. In total the Noosa on Weyba project site has the
capacity to:
> accommodate ~149% of the offset required to satisfy the Koala SPRP requirement for a Koala Offset
Policy net benefit ratio of 5:1; and
> provide an overall offset ratio of approximately 3.5:1 for all of the non-juvenile Koala habitat trees that are
likely to be cleared, including those for which an offset is not required under the Koala SPRP.
The Koala habitat offset works will focus on full ecosystem restoration with an overall density of 5,000-
10,000 plants/ha. As noted in Table 5-3 and Table 5-4, within the nominated offset areas Koala habitat
species will be established at densities ranging from 2,000 to 3,000 plants/ha. In accordance with the DEHP
Koala Nature Refuges Program – Guideline for Revegetation of Koala Habitat the offset works would aim to
create ‘Koala friendly habitat’ based on a species mixture ratio of 80% primary food trees to 20% shelter
trees.
The particular species that will most likely be establishment within the designated offset areas, based on the
associated regional ecosystem types, are detailed in Table 5-5.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 26
Page 31
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
Table 5-5 Koala habitat tree species associated with different habitat (regional ecosystem) types
#
RE Short Description Primary Food Species Shelter and Secondary
Code Food Species
12.5.3 Eucalyptus tindaliae and/or E. racemosa E. resinifera E. racemosa
open forest on remnant Tertiary surfaces E. microcorys E. siderophloia
E. siderophloia M. quinquenervia
C. intermedia
C. trachyphloia
L. confertus
12.3.4 Melaleuca quinquenervia, Eucalyptus E. robusta M. quinquenervia
robusta open forest on or near coastal E. tereticornis L. suaveolens
alluvial plains
12.3.5 Melaleuca quinquenervia open forest on E. robusta M. quinquenervia
coastal alluvium E. tereticornis L. suaveolens
12.3.11 Eucalyptus siderophloia, E. tereticornis, E. tereticornis E. racemosa
Corymbia intermedia open forest on alluvial E. siderophloia M. quinquenervia
plains usually near coast E. seeana C. intermedia
E. grandis C. trachyphloia
L. suaveolens
#: species recognised as important koala food/habitat trees in South East Queensland (DERM, 2011) or in the Noosa Shire (Callaghan
et al, 2011).
Based on the above, the Koala habitat offset works will increase the prevalence of preferred Koala habitat
trees within the Noosa on Weyba site locality as:
> the majority of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees that would require clearance to facilitate the Noosa on
Weyba project are shelter species rather than primary food species; and
> the offset works will be strongly biased towards the establishment of primary Koala food species as
opposed to replacing the same species that have been cleared.
5.4.2 Offset Security
The Noosa on Weyba project’s Koala offsets can be delivered “on-site” and in that respect would satisfy the
following Koala Offset Policy requirements.
> The koala offset site must be in an area identified as high value or medium value suitable for rehabilitation
habitat.
> Where an area of high value or medium value suitable for rehabilitation habitat is not available within the
area required by provisions below, koala offset sites should be located within low value suitable for
rehabilitation habitat, or where appropriate, within bushland habitat to enhance the quality of bushland
within the local government area.
> Offset plantings may occur either on the development site (as part of enhancement of biodiversity
corridors) or on another site. Where offsets are delivered on the development site, they must meet
protection requirements as required by this policy.
> The koala offset site must be within the same local government area as the development impacting on
koala habitat values, except where the impact occurs on koala habitat values within the Koala Coast and
Pine Rivers area.
The Koala Offsets will be protected, as required by the Koala Offset Policy, from future development impacts
on habitat by permanently securing the offset areas for conservation purposes. This will be achieved via:
> gifting the offset areas located within the Noosa on Weyba Send land to the State for incorporation into
the Noosa National Park estate; and
> registering a conservation agreement under the Nature Conservation Act 1992 and/or a covenant under
the Land Act 1994 or the Land Title Act 1994, over the offset areas that are located within the Noosa on
Weyba Receive land.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 27
Page 32
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
5.5 Road Traffic Impacts and Mitigation
In most locations, vehicle related Koala mortality and morbidity has the most significant impact on Koalas
after habitat clearing and fragmentation. Koalas living in developed areas have to cross streets and
highways to get to pockets of remaining fragmented habitat. Their ability to do this is affected by a number
of factors including traffic volume, traffic speed, road position, road design and driver awareness.
A total of twelve (12) alternative arrangements for providing road access to the Noosa on Weyba
development exist and have been considered. These alternatives are detailed in the Noosa on Weyba
Holistic Access Options Assessment Report (Cardno 2013i) and the options were assessed based on a
combination of equally weighted environmental, transport, engineering and cost criteria. The particular road
rd nd
option that was selected (Option 6) was ranked the 3 best in terms of environmental performance and 2
best in overall performance, but was selected due to the fact that the option with the best environmental
performance would not provide a functional road network able to accommodate a viable public transport
service.
The Noosa on Weyba project will be serviced by three general road classes being:
> internal roads created as part of the development and managed by the BC;
> existing local roads such as Hollett Road and Tidswell Road; and
> existing Walter Hay Drive, where a new round-about is proposed to provide the main vehicular access
point to the proposed development.
An analysis of the volume of road traffic that would likely be generated by the proposed Noosa on Weyba
project is provided in the Traffic Impact Assessment – Noosa on Weyba (Cardno 2012, 2013). A summary of
increase in traffic movements upon the local road network that would be associated with the Noosa on
Weyba project is provided in Table 5-6.
Table 5-6 Impact of Proposal on the local Road Network
Roadway Posted Max Projected 2018 Daily Projected 2018 Projected 2018 Night-
Speed Limits Vehicular Movements Daily Vehicular time (7pm-5am)
(kph) Without Development Movements Vehicular Movements
With Development With Development
Walter Hay Drive 60-100 15,280 20,545 3,698
Eenie Creek Road (west of
80 13,830 14,375 2,588
Weyba Creek)
Eumundi – Noosa Road 60-100 11,575 11,575 2,084
@
Eumarella Road 80 970 1,470 175
Internal Laneway parallel to
Hollett Road (West of Walter 40 0 210 38
Hay Drive)
Hollett Road (West of
50 <150 <150 <30
Walter Hay Drive)
Hollett Road (East of Walter
% 50 <100 3,145 566
Hay Drive)
@
Tidswell Road 50 <100 600 <108
#: estimated to be ~18% of average daily traffic movements; +: does not account for additional traffic movements that would be
generated by other committed developments for the Noosa on Weyba land; %: only a small section (i.e. < 20%) of Hollett Road east of
Walter Hay Drive would convey vehicular traffic. @: Includes nominal traffic volume utilising alternate route from that detailed in the
Traffic Impact Assessment, which assumes ~100% of traffic movements would via Water Hay Drive.
From Table 5-6 it is evident that the proposed Noosa on Weyba project will increase the volume of traffic on
the local road network with the greatest increase, relative to existing road traffic volumes, being on the low
velocity Hollett Road and Tidswell Road. Whilst the majority (~82%) of the daily traffic movements
generated by the Noosa on Weyba project would occur outside of the peak period of Koala activity and
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 28
Page 33
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
movement, various measures are proposed as part of the Noosa on Weyba project to minimise the potential
for vehicular traffic to adversely affect Koala.
The proposed impact mitigation measures vary dependent upon the nature of the roadway and are as
follows.
1. Internal Roads
All internal roads within the Noosa on Weyba development will be designed to ensure that the
potential for, and implications of, a clash between wildlife and motor vehicles are minimised. Specific
design features that will be incorporated into internal roadways include:
> road design is to be as narrow as possible and more like a driveway design;
> road design is to include physical speed controls and substantial sign posting;
> road speed is restricted to a maximum of 40 kph via physical design, signage and BC regulation;
and
> lighting and management of fringing under storey vegetation to enhance visibility.
2. Minor Council Controlled Roads
The road design for the upgrading of Tidswell Road and Hollett Road, which are local government
roadways, will be undertaken by Council with funding contributions being made by the proponents of
the Noosa on Weyba project. Consistent with the philosophy of the Noosa on Weyba project and in
recognition of the environmental values of the locality traversed by these existing roadways, it is
anticipated that these roadway upgrades will include physical and signposted 50 kph vehicle speed
controls, provision for appropriate wildlife awareness signage, lighting and management of fringing
under storey vegetation to enhance visibility. The traffic and engineering reports prepared to support
the Noosa on Weyba proposal provide preliminary low impact design details for external roadway
upgrade works.
3. Major Council/State Controlled Roads
Walter Hay Drive is the main arterial roadway that would service the Noosa on Weyba conveying:
> approximately 85% of all vehicular movements that would be generated by the development; and
> 100% of all vehicular movements lawfully occurring at a velocity greater than 50 kph.
The Noosa on Weyba project would result in a substantial (21%) increase in the volume of night-time
traffic on Walter Hay Drive with an associated potential for a substantial increase in vehicle related
Koala mortality and morbidity. It is noted that currently only 25% of Walter Hay Drive is fenced to
exclude Koalas, and other terrestrial fauna, from moving onto this high road traffic volume and high
traffic velocity roadway. As such vehicular traffic on Walter Hay Drive poses one of the greatest
threats to Koala residing within the Noosa on Weyba locality. In recognition of this fact and the
additional traffic that would be generated on Walter Hay Drive by the Noosa on Weyba project the
current Koala exclusion fencing on Walter Hay Drive will be extended such that both sides of this road
are continually fenced between the Eumarella Road roundabout through to the northern boundary of
the Noosa on Weyba site. The proponents of the Noosa on Weyba project will contribute the
necessary funds to Council to ensure that this fencing work is completed within 24 months of
commencement of work on the Noosa on Weyba development.
In addition the Noosa on Weyba BC Environmental Levy will allocate funds towards the annual
maintenance of the exclusion fencing of Walter Hay Drive to ensure that its efficacy is not
compromised.
The Noosa on Weyba project will also result in some relatively minor increases in the volume of traffic
on Eenie Creek Road (6.4%) and Eumundi-Noosa Road (4.0%). Whilst no direct offsets are proposed
in relation to these two major roadways, the private sector funding that is proposed to be directed
towards completing the fencing of Walter Hay Drive would enable available public resources to be
directed towards these roadways.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 29
Page 34
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
5.6 Domestic Dog Related Impacts and Mitigation Measures
The Noosa on Weyba project will result in an overall increase in the number of domestic dogs present within
the Noosa on Weyba site locality. In recognition of the potential impacts upon Koalas associated with an
unregulated increase in the presence of dogs the following dog ownership controls are proposed as an
integral part of the Noosa on Weyba project.
1. Residents will be restricted to the ownership of dogs as approved in the Community Management
Scheme (CMS) only, and those dogs must be registered with the BC and annually physically checked
by the BC as being approved.
2. Dogs that will not be approved in the CMS will be those types and/or sizes that are believed to create
the majority of injuries to Koala.
3. Residents will be required to retain their dogs in a fenced yard or compound within their own
allotments that will contain the dog and exclude Koala and other medium to large native fauna (e.g.
Swamp wallabies and Eastern-grey kangaroos). From dusk till dawn all dogs must be:
a. under the direct supervision and control of a competent person;
b. confined inside an enclosure or building which excludes wildlife; or
c. tethered on a lead not exceeding 2m in length.
4. Residents and visitors must keep their dogs on a leash at all times whilst on the BC Common Property
and outside of:
a. a designated yard or compound within a residential allotment that is designed or fenced to
exclude the entry of Koalas; or
b. designated BC off-leash areas.
5. The BC will provide “off-leash” fenced dog exercise parks throughout the Noosa on Weyba estate and
residents will only be allowed to have their dogs unleashed in these “off-leash” parks. The off-leash
areas are to be located outside of the boundaries of the Open Space Conservation Zone.
6. The BC will be responsible to ensure that the park fencing design is adequate and is appropriately
maintained to exclude Koalas (and other native fauna) and contain dogs.
7. The BC will have the right to remove any dog from Noosa on Weyba should a resident dog owner not
abide by the By Laws.
8. Residents must ensure that no dog (whether it be the property of the resident, the owner of the
property, a family member, tenant or a visitor) be permitted to be kept except as prescribed in the By
Laws.
9. The BC will have the right to remove any visitor’s dog that is not being appropriately controlled by the
particular resident as required by the By Laws.
10. Prospective purchasers of property within the Noosa on Weyba estate will be made aware of the
above BC Conditions at the initial point of sale and details concerning same will be contained within
the CMS to ensure that any future purchaser or renter of a property is aware of the regulations
regarding the keeping of dogs.
The Noosa on Weyba site locality also supports a population of feral domestic dogs that are likely to prey on
Koalas. The Noosa on Weyba BC will work with Council, the Queensland Parks and Wildlife Service and
adjoining landowners to develop and implement an appropriately resourced feral dog management strategy,
funded in part by the Noosa on Weyba environmental levy.
5.7 Swimming Pool Related Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Whilst Koalas can swim, pool drowning can pose a significant risk to a local population particularly when
there are a large number of pools within a small area. The Noosa on Weyba development will ensure,
through the CMS and by-laws, that all pools within the development incorporate some (or all depending on
the particular design issue) of the following features:
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 30
Page 35
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
1. a sloping beach like access point located on a shallow section of the pool (or wetland); or
2. pool fencing designed to exclude koalas (i.e. Perspex covered or glass panels).
5.8 Community Education and Stewardship
As part of the Noosa on Weyba project a community education and stewardship strategy will be developed
and implemented to ensure that all residents and visitors are aware of the Koala habitat (and other broader
biodiversity) values of the Noosa on Weyba locality. This community education and stewardship strategy will
include provision for measures such as the following.
1. Information packages for prospective residents concerning:
> the environmental values of the Noosa on Weyba site locality;
> specific design features of the Noosa on Weyba project that respond to those important
environmental values; and
> specific BC regulations and controls that residents and their guests would need to comply with to
ensure that important environmental values are protected.
2. Issue of a regular (e.g. quarterly) Environmental Newsletter providing information:
> concerning notable environmental observation or events within the Noosa on Weyba locality (e.g.
commencement of Koala breeding season);
> reminding residents of their environmental management obligations under the BC regulations; and
> contact details for the reporting of sick/injured wildlife or free-roaming dogs.
3. Initiation of a Noosa on Weyba Land Care Group (or similar) that is designed to provide residents with
the opportunity to become actively involved in the monitoring and management of the biodiversity,
including Koala habitat, values of the Noosa on Weyba.
4. Establishment and maintenance of environmental interpretative signage throughout the Noosa on
Weyba project that provides residents and visitors with information concerning the Koala ecology and
conservation issues of relevance to the Noosa on Weyba locality.
5. A formal Koala Monitoring Program for the Noosa on Weyba project that is designed to assess the
efficacy of the Koala protection and habitat enhancement measures that have been incorporated into
the design of the Noosa on Weyba project. The Koala Monitoring Program would be informed by
appropriately designed baseline surveys that would continue throughout the construction and
occupational phases of the project. Initially the Koala monitoring program would be funded by the
developer, with on-going funding being provided via the Noosa on Weyba BC Environmental Levy. It
is envisaged that the Koala monitoring program would involve collaboration with recognised research
institutions, adjacent land owners/managers and the Noosa on Weyba Land Care Group. The Koala
Monitoring Program may form an element of a broader Environmental Monitoring Program for the
Noosa on Weyba project.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 31
Page 36
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
6 Compliance Assessment
This section provides an assessment of the degree of compliance that the proposed development achieves
with the intent and performance requirements of regulations that are specifically focused on ensuring the
appropriate consideration of Koala conservation issues is incorporated into land use planning.
6.1 South East Queensland Koala Conservation State Planning Regulatory
Provisions
The South East Queensland Koala Conservation State Planning Regulatory Provisions (Koala SPRP) is an
overarching state planning instrument that regulates new development at the development assessment
stage. The Koala SPRP provides requirements for all new development activities to minimise its impact on
Koalas and Koala habitat.
For the purpose of this report and in accordance with the Koala SPRP, Koala Habitat is defined as ‘An area
that is bushland habitat, rehabilitation habitat or other area of habitat value excluding areas where Koalas
are generally not present’ as shown on the South East Queensland Koala Conservation State Planning
Regulatory Provisions Assessable Development Area Koala Habitat Values Map.
The Noosa on Weyba site is located within a Koala Assessable Development Area (KADA) and has been
identified as containing Koala Habitat on the Koala Conservation in South East Queensland State Planning
Regulatory Provisions Map created by DEHP. The Koala SPRP Koala Habitat Values Mapping is
reproduced in Figure 8 along with the proposed layout of development.
The Noosa on Weyba project will be required to demonstrate compliance with the relevant divisions of the
Koala SPRP. In this regard it is noted that two divisions of the Koala SPRP apply to the proposed
development, these being:
> Division 4 – Development that is for community or linear infrastructure - in respect of those aspects of the
Noosa on Weyba project that constitute Linear Infrastructure such as road works, water, electricity,
telecommunications and sewage distribution works; and
> Division 7 – Development that is within a Koala Assessable Development Area - which relates to the
balance of the Noosa on Weyba development that is not Linear Infrastructure.
In respect of the upgrading of sections of Hollett Road and Tidswell Road that will be undertaken to service
the Noosa on Weyba estate it is noted these Linear Infrastructure works are most likely to be undertaken by
Council with funding contributions made by the developer of the Noosa on Weyba estate. As road works
undertaken by Council within designated road reserves is not assessable under a planning scheme, then the
Tidswell Road and Hollett Road upgrade works are not assessable against the Koala SPRP.
Table 6-1 and Table 6-2 below outline that Koala SPRP assessment criteria requirements for Division 4 and
Division 7, respectively, and present an assessment of the degree of compliance that the Noosa on Weyba
proposal, as detailed in Section 5 herein, achieves with the Koala SPRP.
Table 6-1 Koala SPRP Division 4 Assessment Criteria Compliance Assessment
Koala State Planning Regulatory Provisions Compliance Assessment
(Division 4) Assessment Criteria
Assessment Criteria 1.
Site design must avoid clearing non-juvenile As detailed in Section 5.3.1, the Noosa on Weyba project will involve
Koala habitat trees in areas of bushland some clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees in mapped areas
habitat, high value rehabilitation habitat, and of Bushland Habitat, High Value Rehabilitation habitat and Medium
medium value rehabilitation habitat, with any Value Rehabilitation habitat.
unavoidable clearing minimised and offset in The only clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees in mapped
accordance with the Offsets for Net Gain of areas of Bushland Habitat will be for the purpose of establishing two
Koala Habitat in South East Queensland pieces of linear infrastructure, these being:
Policy at a ratio of five new Koala habitat trees
for every one non-juvenile Koala habitat tree > a necessary road linkage between Precinct H and Hollett Road
removed or an equivalent cash contribution. which will involve the clearance of ~100 non-juvenile Koala habitat
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 32
Page 37
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
Koala State Planning Regulatory Provisions Compliance Assessment
(Division 4) Assessment Criteria
trees within a 0.58 ha area of Medium Value Koala Bushland
Habitat; and
> the establishing an internal road connection linking Precincts I, K
and L, which is proposed as an alternative to the upgrading of the
existing Hollett Road which would have substantially greater
ecological impacts, involving the clearance of ~437 non-juvenile
Koala habitat trees within a 0.41 ha area of Medium Value Koala
Bushland Habitat.
The clearance of ~537 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees for the
purpose of establishing these two pieces of linear infrastructure would
result in a 0.2% reduction in the estimated number of non-juvenile
Koala habitat trees located within the boundaries of the Noosa on
Weyba site.
Both of these pieces of linear infrastructure have been located largely
within existing cleared corridors within the mapped areas of Koala
Bushland Habitat and designed to minimise the extent of non-juvenile
Koala habitat trees clearance required.
As detailed in Section 5.4 all clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat
trees will be offset in accordance with the Offsets for Net Gain of
Koala Habitat in South East Queensland Policy.
Assessment Criteria 2.
Site design provides safe Koala movement The Noosa on Weyba project incorporates a number of design
opportunities, including Koala movement features and controls that are specifically designed to provide for the
infrastructure, as appropriate to the safe movement of Koala through the local landscape, including:
development type and habitat connectivity > preservation of multiple north-south and east-west habitat
values of the site determined by reference to
corridors extending through the Noosa on Weyba site and
the factors for consideration in Schedule 2.
connecting external areas of Koala habitat;
> extension of fauna exclusion fencing along Walter Hay Drive;
> creation of a low vehicular speed environment within the proposed
urban areas;
> restrictions on the keeping of domestic dogs; and
> regulation of swimming pool design to minimise the risk of Koala
drowning.
The above measures will combine to create a landscape which will
facilitate the safe movement of Koala within and through the Noosa on
Weyba site.
Assessment Criteria 3.
Native vegetation clearing is undertaken as All vegetation clearance required to facilitate the Noosa on Weyba
sequential clearing and under the guidance of project will be carried out in a sequential manner under the guidance
a Koala spotter where the native vegetation is of an appropriately qualified and experienced Koala spotter. Relevant
a non-juvenile Koala habitat tree. Conditions of approval requiring that this occur should be specified in
any development approvals issued for the Noosa on Weyba project.
Assessment Criteria 4.
During construction phases: A detailed Construction Environmental Management Plan (CEMP) will
a. measures are taken in construction be prepared prior to the commencement of any construction activities
practices to not increase the risk of death and will include appropriate provisions dealing with:
or injury to Koalas; and > management of construction and vegetation clearance practices to
b. native vegetation that is cleared and in avoid injury to native fauna; and
an area intended to be retained for safe
Koala movement opportunities is > habitat restoration within areas of temporary disturbance.
progressively restored and rehabilitated.
Assessment Criteria 5.
Landscaping activities provide food, shelter The landscaping principles for the Noosa on Weyba project are based
and movement opportunities for Koalas on the use of native plant species that will provide food, shelter and
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 33
Page 38
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
Koala State Planning Regulatory Provisions Compliance Assessment
(Division 4) Assessment Criteria
consistent with the site design. safe movement opportunities for Koala and other native wildlife
species.
Table 6-2 Koala SPRP Division 7 Assessment Criteria Compliance Assessment
Koala State Planning Regulatory Provisions Compliance Assessment
(Division 7) Assessment Criteria
Assessment Criteria 1:
To the extent the premises is outside the This assessment criterion applies to the Noosa on Weyba site as it is
Urban Footprint and not in an urban area located outside of the Urban Footprint and not in an urban area under
under a planning scheme, site design does a planning scheme.
not result in the clearing of non-juvenile Koala Apart from the clearing of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees in areas of
habitat trees* in areas of bushland habitat. bushland habitat for the purpose of establishing some Linear
Infrastructure elements (assessable under Division 4), the Noosa on
Weyba project will not result in the clearing of non-juvenile Koala
habitat trees within mapped areas of Koala bushland habitat.
Assessment Criteria 2:
To the extent the premises is inside the Urban This assessment criterion does not apply as the Noosa on Weyba site
Footprint, site design must avoid clearing non- is located outside of the Urban Footprint and the more stringent
juvenile Koala habitat trees in areas of Assessment Criteria 1 applies.
bushland habitat, with any unavoidable
clearing minimised and offset in accordance
with the Offsets for Net Gain of Koala Habitat
in South East Queensland Policy at a ratio of
five new Koala habitat trees for every one
non-juvenile Koala habitat tree removed or an
equivalent cash contribution.
Assessment Criteria 3:
Site design must avoid clearing non-juvenile The Noosa on Weyba project will involve the clearance of non-juvenile
Koala habitat trees in areas of high value Koala habitat trees in areas of High Value Rehabilitation habitat and
rehabilitation habitat, and medium value Medium Value Rehabilitation habitat.
rehabilitation habitat, with any unavoidable The extent of clearance has been minimised to the greatest extent
clearing minimised and offset in accordance possible whilst allowing for a commercially viable development of the
with the Offsets for Net Gain of Koala Habitat site.
in South East Queensland Policy at a ratio of
five new Koala habitat trees for every one In total ~2,687 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees located within mapped
non-juvenile Koala habitat tree removed or an High or Medium Value Rehabilitation habitat would require clearance,
equivalent cash contribution. which represents ~0.8% of the estimated total number of non-juvenile
Koala habitat trees occurring within the boundaries of the Noosa on
Weyba site (i.e. ~342,000).
As detailed in Section 5.4 all clearance of non-juvenile Koala habitat
trees will be offset in accordance with the Offsets for Net Gain of
Koala Habitat in South East Queensland Policy.
Assessment Criteria 4:
Site design provides safe Koala movement The Noosa on Weyba project incorporates a number of design
opportunities as appropriate to the features and controls that are specifically designed to provide for the
development type and habitat connectivity safe movement of Koala through the local landscape, including:
values of the site determined by reference to > preservation of multiple north-south and east-west habitat
the factors for consideration in Schedule 2.
corridors extending through the Noosa on Weyba site and
connecting external areas of Koala habitat;
> extension of fauna exclusion fencing along Walter Hay Drive;
> creation of a low vehicular speed environment within the proposed
urban areas;
> restrictions on the keeping of domestic dogs; and
> regulation of swimming pool design to minimise the risk of Koala
drowning.
The above measures will combine to create a landscape which will
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 34
Page 39
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
Koala State Planning Regulatory Provisions Compliance Assessment
(Division 7) Assessment Criteria
facilitate the safe movement of Koala within and through the Noosa on
Weyba site.
Assessment Criteria 5:
During construction phases: A detailed Construction Environmental Management Plan (CEMP) will
a. measures are taken in construction be prepared prior to the commencement of any construction activities
practices to not increase the risk of death and will include appropriate provisions dealing with:
or injury to Koalas; and > management of construction and vegetation clearance practices to
b. native vegetation that is cleared and in avoid injury to native fauna; and
an area intended to be retained for safe
Koala movement opportunities is > habitat restoration within all areas of temporary disturbance.
progressively restored and rehabilitated.
Assessment Criteria 6:
Native vegetation clearing is undertaken as All vegetation clearance required to facilitate the Noosa on Weyba
sequential clearing and under the guidance of project will be carried out in a sequential manner under the guidance
a Koala spotter where the native vegetation is of an appropriately qualified and experienced Koala spotter. Relevant
a non-juvenile Koala habitat tree. Conditions of approval requiring that this occur should be specified in
any development approvals issued for the Noosa on Weyba project.
Assessment Criteria 7:
Landscaping activities provide food, shelter The landscaping principles for the Noosa on Weyba project are based
and movement opportunities for Koalas on the use of native plant species that will provide food, shelter and
consistent with the site design. safe movement opportunities for Koala and other native wildlife
species.
In summary, the proposed Noosa on Weyba project, as described in Section 5 herein, satisfies the relevant
Assessment Criteria specified in the Koala SPRP.
6.2 Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999
The EPBC Act requires that a person must receive Commonwealth approval for any action that has, will
have, or is likely to have a significant impact on matters of national environmental significance. The
Queensland Koala population was listed as Vulnerable under the EPBC Act on 2 May 2012.
An assessment of whether the Noosa on Weyba proposal is likely to have a “significant impact” on Koalas is
presented in Table 6-3. This assessment has been prepared with reference to:
> the preceding information concerning the nature of the Noosa on Weyba proposal, its likely impact on
Koalas and their habitat, and proposed impact mitigation and offset measures;
> Interim Koala Referral Advice for Proponents (DSEWPaC June 2012); and
> Matters of National Environmental Significance - Significant impact guidelines 1.1 (DEWHA 2009).
Table 6-3 EPBC Significant Impact Criteria Assessment
Significance Impact Criteria Assessment
The EPBC Act Administrative
Guidelines on Significance state
that an action is likely to have a
significant impact on a Vulnerable
species if it is likely to:
> lead to a long-term decrease in The Noosa on Weyba project is not likely to lead to a long-term decrease in the
the size of an important size of an important population of Koala as it:
population of a species; > retains the majority (~99%) of the mapped areas of Koala Bushland Habitat
that occur within the Noosa on Weyba site;
> provides offsets for the clearance of Koala habitat that will increase both the
extent and quality of Koala habitat resources within the site locality;
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 35
Page 40
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
Significance Impact Criteria Assessment
> maintains avenues for the safe movement of Koala through the landscape;
> will reduce the risk of Koala mortality associated with local high volume and
velocity roadways (i.e. Walter Hay Drive);
> will create a low traffic speed environment on local roadways to minimise
risks to Koala; and
> will regulate the keeping of domestic dogs.
> reduce the area of occupancy of The Noosa on Weyba project will result in some reduction in the area of habitat
an important population that could be occupied by the local Koala population, with urban development
replacing some areas of cleared and semi-cleared land that is not classified as
supporting remnant vegetation, essential habitat for Koala or as Koala Bushland
Habitat. However this is not likely to have a significant impact as:
> the Koala habitat qualities of the land where urban development is proposed
are generally poor; and
> the loss of habitat will be offset by the restoration and enhancement of Koala
habitat in other parts of the Noosa on Weyba site.
> fragment an existing important The Noosa on Weyba project will not fragment an existing Koala population into
population into two or more two or more populations.
populations The proposed development incorporates a number of measures that are
specifically designed to facilitate the safe movement of Koala through the
landscape (see Section 5).
> adversely affect habitat critical The Noosa on Weyba project is not likely to affect habitat critical to the survival
to the survival of a species of Koala as it will:
> retain and secure ~99% of the identified Koala Bushland Habitat and
estimated number of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees that currently exist
within the Noosa on Weyba site;
> reinstate and/or enhance Koala habitat within areas where those values have
been degraded by past and current lawful land uses; and
> in the long term, affect a net increase in the quantity and quality of Koala
habitat available within the Noosa on Weyba site via implementation of the
offset measures detailed in Section 5.4.
> disrupt the breeding cycle of an The Noosa on Weyba project is not likely to cause any disruptions to the
important population breeding cycle of the local Koala population. The preservation and enhancement
of linked areas of Koala habitat in combination with measures proposed to
address potential threats associated with vegetation clearance operations, road
traffic and domestic dogs, should ensure that there are no discernible impacts
upon Koala breeding within the Noosa on Weyba locality.
> modify, destroy, remove, isolate The Noosa on Weyba project has been designed to achieve an overall net gain
or decrease the availability or in the availability, accessibility and quality of Koala habitat within the site locality.
quality of habitat to the extent In contrast continuation of existing land use practices and the uptake of
that the species is likely to existing/pending development commitments would be likely to result in a gradual
decline decline in the overall quality and extent of Koala habitat available within the
Noosa on Weyba site.
> result in invasive species that The Noosa on Weyba project includes provision for the management of non-
are harmful to a vulnerable native plants and animals that have the potential to either degrade Koala habitat
species becoming established (e.g. lantana thickets that restrict access to food trees) or directly impact on
in the vulnerable species habitat Koala (e.g. feral dogs).
> interferes substantially with the The Noosa on Weyba project is not likely to interfere with the recovery of Koala.
recovery of the species To the contrary the Noosa on Weyba project includes a number of design
features, impact mitigation measures and offset commitments that are
specifically designed to achieve a net conservation gain for Koala, as required by
the Queensland Koala SPRP.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 36
Page 41
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment In summary, the proposed Noosa on Weyba project, as described in Section 5 herein, is not likely to have a significant adverse impact on the local Koala population. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 37
Page 42
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
7 Net Benefit Assessment
This net benefit assessment provides an analysis of the capacity of the Noosa on Weyba project to provide a
net conservation gain for Koala, relative to continuation of existing land tenure and land use arrangements,
including the uptake of existing development commitments.
The net benefit assessment considers the following aspects that are recognised as being critical to the
conservation of Koala:
> habitat clearance;
> road traffic impacts; and
> domestic dog impacts.
7.1 Habitat Clearance and Degradation
Koala habitat clearance and degradation will occur within the Noosa on Weyba site regardless of whether
the Noosa on Weyba proposal is approved or not. An assessment of the potential benefits, if any, of the
Noosa on Weyba proposal therefore needs to consider whether the nature and extent of Koala habitat
clearance and degradation that is associated with the Noosa on Weyba proposal is substantially different
from that which will occur if the existing land tenure and use arrangements were continued into the future.
Table 7-1 provides a brief description of the existing uses of each of the land parcels forming part of the
Noosa on Weyba site, including any development commitments, and the extent of Koala Bushland Habitat
areas where clearance of habitat trees could occur and the extent of cleared land where Koala habitat
restoration is likely to be actively undertaken. Table 7-1 also provides brief description of the proposed
Noosa on Weyba uses and associated Koala Bushland Habitat outcomes for the individual land parcels
Table 7-1 Relative extents of Koala Bushland Habitat clearance for existing uses and proposed
uses of the Noosa on Weyba site
Real Existing Scenario Noosa on Weyba Proposal
Property
Description Uses & Development Koala Proposed Uses Koala
and Extent Commitments * Bushland Bushland
Habitat Habitat
Clearance Clearance
(Restoration) (Restoration)
ha ha
Lot 7 on The cleared portions of the site 0 (0) The land is to be dedicated to 0 (0.33)
RP46782 – may be actively maintained by the State for incopration into the
1.99 ha slashing and the occasional National Park estate. Existing
grazing of livestock. Construction cleared areas will be
of a single residential dwelling rehabilitated and the land is to
and keeping of domestic pets may be actively managed for
be permitted. conservation purposes.
Lot 2 on The cleared portions of the site 0 (0) National Park – as above. 0 (1.60)
RP160983 - may be actively maintained
93.1 ha maintained by slashing and the
grazing of livestock. Construction
of a single residential dwelling
and keeping of domestic pets may
be permitted.
Lot 1667 on The cleared portions of the site 0 (0) National Park – as above. 0 (6.07)
M37772 - may be actively maintained by
44.4 ha slashing and the grazing of
livestock. Construction of a single
residential dwelling and keeping
of domestic pets may be
permitted.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 38
Page 43
Noosa on Weyba
Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment
Real Existing Scenario Noosa on Weyba Proposal
Property
Description Uses & Development Koala Proposed Uses Koala
and Extent Commitments * Bushland Bushland
Habitat Habitat
Clearance Clearance
(Restoration) (Restoration)
ha ha
Lot 2 on The cleared portions of the site 0 (0) Establishment of Retirement 0 (0.63)
SP179590 - may be actively maintained by Living Cottages within
12.5 ha slashing and the grazing of predominately cleared areas of
livestock. The site also supports the site. Over 58% of Lot 2 will
an existing detached dwelling and be actively managed for
ancillary structures. conservation purposes.
Lot 53 on This site is substantially cleared 6.15 (0) A mixture of urban land uses 0.99 (2.08)
SP163571 - and actively used as a grazing and associated infrastructure.
110.0 ha property. As detailed in Section Over 77% of Lot 53 will be
4.1, Lot 53 is also the subject of a actively managed for
development commitment that conservation purposes.
would see the subdivison of the All areas of remnant vegetation
site for rural-residential purposes. and mapped Koala Bushland
As illustrated in Figure 6 this Habitat will be retained, except
development commitment would for some clearance associated
involve the clearance of Koala with the establishment of two
Bushland Habitat. No offset would internal road connections.
be required for such clearance.
Substantial clearance of non-
juvenile Koala habitat trees
located outside of mapped Koala
Bushland Habitat would also be
required.
Lot 11 on This site is substantially cleared 0 (0) A mixture of urban land uses 0 (3.23)
SP250714 - and actively used as a grazing and associated infrastructure.
40.7 ha property. As detailed in Section Approximately 49% of Lot 11 will
4.1, Lot 11 is also the subject of a be actively managed for
development commitment that conservation purposes.
would see the eastern sector of All areas of remnant vegetation
the site developed for an and mapped Koala Bushland
ecotourism facility with the Habitat will be retained.
capacity to accommodate up to
108 persons. It is anticipated that
this approved development would
not require any Koala Bushland
Habitat clearance apart from
external road upgrades.
Lot 12 on This site is predominately cleared 0 (0) This site is proposed to be used 0 (0)
RP893393 - and accommodates a detached as a Community Facility.
0.61 ha dwelling and associated Existing native vegetation will be
infrastructure. retained.
ALL 6.15 (0) 0.5 (13.94)
*: a more detailed consideration of the existing, as of right and permitted uses of the land parcels forming part of the Noosa on Weyba
site is provided in Section 3 of the Noosa on Weyba Biodiversity Development Offset Analysis (Cardno 2010) report.
From Table 7-1, it is evident that the Noosa on Weyba proposal will result in a net benefit to Koala in terms
of:
> a reduced extent in the area of Koala Bushland Habitat within which clearance of Koala habitat trees
could occur; and
> an increased extent in the areas within which works would be undertaken to actively restore Koala
Bushland Habitat.
In addition to these raw area based differences between the continuation of existing land tenure and use
arrangements and the proposed Noosa on Weyba arrangements, substantial additional benefits would be
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013
Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 39
Page 44
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment derived from the Noosa on Weyba proposal via the fact that retained areas of Koala Bushland Habitat would be actively managed for conservation purposes. 7.2 Road Traffic Impacts Road traffic based sources of Koala mortality are recognised as one of the major causes of decline in the SEQ Koala population. The Noosa on Weyba proposal will result in a material increase in the number of vehicles moving upon the local road network, even if one takes into account the additional traffic that would be generated by uptake of the development commitments that already apply to Lot 53 on SP163571 and Lot 11 on SP250714. As detailed in Section 5.4.1, the greatest increase in the number of vehicular movements associated with the Noosa on Weyba proposal, relative to the alternative existing use scenario, would be experienced on the Hollett Road and Tidswell Road. However from a Koala impact perspective it is noted that both of these existing roadways would be upgraded and signposted to a speed limit of 50 kph. Given that relevant research indicates that Koala mortality caused by motor vehicles is negligible where the posted speed limits is 50 kph or less (refer Section 4.2), the increase in road traffic volumes on local low speed roadways is not likely to have a major impact on Koala. Of more concern from a Koala impact perspective is the high velocity road traffic movements that occur upon Walter Hay Drive. Whilst exclusion fencing is established along ~25% of the length of Walter Hay Drive, the majority is not fenced and the potential for Koala mortality is high. If the Noosa on Weyba proposal is not approved, Walter Hay Drive will continue to act as a major potential source of Koala mortality and as a barrier to the safe movement of Koala. The commitment given as part of the Noosa on Weyba proposal to complete the exclusion fencing along the entire length of Walter Hay Drive and to also contribute towards the on-going maintenance of that fencing and associated fauna underpasses will be of substantial benefit from a Koala conservation perspective. On balance, the Koala conservation benefits that the Noosa on Weyba proposal offers via the completion and maintenance of the Water Hay Drive exclusion fencing would: > mitigate and offset the impacts associated with increases in the number of vehicular movements on the local high speed (> 50 kph) and high traffic volume Walter Hay Drive, Noosa-Eumundi Road and Eenie Creek Road; > offset the negligible impacts to Koala likely to be associated with an increase in the number of vehicular movements on the local low speed (< 50 kph) and low traffic volume Hollett Road and Tidswell Road; and > contribute towards the provision of a net benefit to Koala. 7.3 Domestic Dog Impacts The presence of inadequately supervised and controlled domestic dogs is considered to be a major factor contributing to the observed decline on the SEQ Koala population. The Noosa on Weyba proposal is likely to result in an increase in the number of domestic dogs occurring within the Noosa on Weyba locality. In recognition of the above and as detailed in Section 5.6 herein, a range of measures are proposed as part of the Noosa on Weyba project to minimise the potential for a likely increase in the local domestic dog population to have an adverse impact on the local Koala population. In addition to these controls it is noted that domestic dogs would be effectively excluded from the ~140 ha of land that is to be dedicated to the State for incorporation into the Noosa National Park. The alternative scenario which involves continuation of existing land tenure and use arrangements would permit the entry and keeping of domestic dogs on all of the land parcels that comprise the Noosa on Weyba site, with none of the restrictions proposed as part of the Noosa on Weyba development. Whilst the number of dogs would be less than that potentially associated with the Noosa on Weyba project, the actual impact of that smaller number of dogs could be greater in the absence of targeted (and enforced) controls. Whilst it would be hoped that anyone keeping dogs on the land would be aware of the potential implications for Koalas, history indicates that in the absence of appropriately design and enforced controls, adverse outcomes for Koalas are likely. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 40
Page 45
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment The uptake of existing development commitments that apply over Lot 53 on SP163571 and Lot 11 on SP250714 would also see an increase in the number of domestic dogs present within Noosa on Weyba locality. The primary benefit of the Noosa on Weyba proposal related to domestic dog impact on Koalas will be to prohibit the entry of domestic dogs into those parts of the site that are to be dedicated to the State for incorporation into the Noosa National Park. This area encompasses ~140 ha of land or ~47% of the site. The potential for adverse impact associated with an increase in the number of domestic dogs residing within the Noosa on Weyba locality will be offset by an increase in the regulations governing the types of dogs that can be kept and the manner in which they must be housed and handled. The Noosa on Weyba site locality also supports a population of feral domestic dogs that are likely to prey on Koalas. An additional benefit of the Noosa on Weyba project will be that the Noosa on Weyba BC will work with Council, the Queensland Parks and Wildlife Service and adjoining landowners to develop and implement an appropriately resourced feral dog management strategy, funded in part by the Noosa on Weyba environmental levy. Overall the net benefit of the Noosa on Weyba project in respect of domestic dog related impacts on Koalas is assessed to be neutral. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 41
Page 46
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment 8 Conclusion This Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessments has considered the implications of the Noosa on Weyba proposal for the local Koala population in respect of issues that are recognised as being of particular relevance to the conservation of Koalas, including: > habitat clearance and retention; > habitat fragmentation and management; > road traffic; and > domestic dogs. An assessment of the Noosa on Weyba proposal, which incorporates a range of impact mitigation and offset measures specifically targeted at Koalas, indicates that it satisfies the assessment criteria of the Koala SPRP and is unlikely to have a significant impact, as defined by the EPBC Act, on Koalas. An assessment of the Noosa on Weyba proposal’s capacity to provide a net benefit to Koala conservation, relative to the continuation of existing patterns of land use and tenure, has also been presented. This assessment indicates that the Noosa on Weyba proposal will provide a net benefit to Koala in terms of: > securing the preservation and appropriate long-term management of key areas of Koala habitat; and > reducing the potential for Koala mortality that is associated with high velocity and high traffic volumes, particularly along Walter Hay Drive. The Noosa on Weyba project if approved and implemented in the manner detailed in Section 5 herein, will: > involve the clearance of ~11,200 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees which represents ~3% of the estimated number of non-juvenile Koala habitat trees located within the Noosa on Weyba site and the Hollett and Tidswell Road reserves; > retain ~206 ha of mapped Koala Bushland Habitat and ~335,000 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees in parts of the Noosa on Weyba site that are to be specifically managed for conservation purposes; > create an additional 14 ha of Koala Bushland Habitat containing an estimated 41,000 non-juvenile Koala habitat trees in parts of the Noosa on Weyba site that are to be specifically managed for conservation purposes; and > substantially reduce the risk of Koala mortality (and associated traffic accidents and trauma) associated with Koala attempting to cross Walter Hay Drive. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 42
Page 47
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment 9 References References Used In Preparation of this Report: Callaghan J, McAlpine C, Mitchell D, Thompson J, Bowen M, Rohdes J, de Jong C, Domalewski R and Scott A (2011) Ranking and mapping koala habitat quality for conservation planning on the basis of indirect evidence of tree-species use: a case study of Noosa Shire, south-eastern Queensland. Wildlife Research, 2011, 38, 89-102. CSIRO Publishing. Cardno (2010) Noosa on Weyba Biodiversity Development Offset Analysis. Prepared on behalf of Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd. Cardno (2012) Noosa on Weyba Traffic Impact Assessment. Prepared on behalf of Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd. Cardno (2013) Noosa on Weyba Request for Further Information Traffic Impact Assessment. Prepared on behalf of Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd. Cardno (2013i) Noosa on Weyba Holistic Access Options Assessment Report. Prepared on behalf of Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd. Carrick (2013) Noosa on Weyba - Review of Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment and Ecological Assessment Report by Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd. Prepared for Steve MacRae Development Services by Dr Frank N Carrick AM on behalf of EcoIndig Resources Pty Ltd, 17 February 2013. Cristescu, R. H., Goethals, K., Banks, P. B., Carrick, F. N. and Frere, C. (2012). Experimental evaluation of koala scat persistence and detectability with implications for pellet-based fauna census. International Journal of Zoology 2012. doi:10.1155/2012/631856 DERM (2011) Planting trees for koalas - Coastal South East Queensland. State of Queensland 2011. Queensland Parks and Wildlife Service, Department of Environment and Resource Management. BP1943 October 2011 DEWHA (2009) Matters of National Environmental Significance - Significant impact guidelines 1.1. The Department of Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts. DSEWPaC (2012) Interim Koala Referral Advice for Proponents. The Department of Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population and Communities, June 2012. EPA (2006) Nature Conservation (Koala) Conservation Plan 2006 and Management Program 2006-2016. Queensland Government, Environmental Protection Agency. GHD (2000) Department of Environment and Resource Management South East Queensland Koala Habitat Assessment and Mapping Project May 2009. GHD, Brisbane. Preece, H. (2007) Monitoring and modelling threats to Koala populations in rapidly urbanising landscapes: Koala Coast, South East Queensland, Australia. PhD Thesis, The University of Queensland. References Cited within EPA (2006): de Villiers, D. L., Preece, H. J. and Dique, D. S. (in prep) Domestic dog related koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) mortality in south east Queensland. Wildlife Research. de Villiers, D. L., Dique, D. S., Preece, H. J., Thompson, J., Leslie, R. S., de Villiers, M. A. and Penfold, G. C. (in press) The capture, handling and radio collaring of koalas Phascolarctos cinereus in south east Queensland: Associated impacts and ethical considerations. Australian Mammalogy. Dique, D. S., de Villiers, D. L. and Preece, H. J. (2003a) Evaluation of line transect sampling for estimating koala abundance in the Pine Rivers Shire, south east Queensland. Wildlife Research 30: 127–133. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 43
Page 48
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Dique, D. S., Preece, H. J., Thompson, J. and de Villiers, D. L., (2004) Determining the distribution and abundance of a regional koala population in south east Queensland for conservation management. Wildlife Research 31: 109–117. Dique, D. S., Thompson, J., de Villiers, D. L., Preece, H. J. and Carrick, F. N. (2003b) Dispersal patterns in a regional koala population in south east Queensland. Wildlife Research 30: 281–290. Dique, D. S., Thompson, J., Preece, H. J., Penfold, G. C., de Villiers, D. L. and Leslie, R. S. (2003c) Koala mortality on roads in south-east Queensland: the Koala speed-zone trial. Wildlife Research 30: 419–426. Gordon, G. (1989) Conservation of koala habitat. In: Planning for Wildlife (Koala) Habitat Protection (editor R. A. Brown). Proceedings Workshop 89, Department of Geographical Sciences, University of Queensland, pp. 16–26. Gordon, G. and Hrdina, F. (2005) Koala and possum abundance in Queensland during the harvest period, 1906–1936. Australian Zoologist 33: 69–99. Gordon, G. and McGreevy, D. G. (1978) The status of the koala in Queensland. In: The Koala: Proceedings of the Taronga Symposium (editor T. J. Bergin), Zoological Parks Board of New South Wales, Sydney, pp. 125–131. Gordon, G., Brown, A. S. and Pulsford, T. (1988) A koala (Phascolarctos cinereus Goldfuss) population crash during drought and heatwave conditions in south western Queensland. Australian Journal of Ecology 13: 451–462. Gordon, G., McGreevy, D. G. and Lawrie, B. C. (1990a) Koala populations in Queensland: major limiting factors. In: Biology of the Koala (editors A. K. Lee, K. A. Handasyde, and G. D. Sanson), Surrey Beatty & Sons, Sydney, pp. 85-95. Gordon, G., McGreevy, D. G. and Lawrie, B. C. (1990b) Koala population turnover and male social organization. In: Biology of the Koala (editors A. K. Lee, K. A. Handasyde, and G. D. Sanson), Surrey Beatty & Sons, Sydney, pp. 189–192. Hasegawa, M. (1995) Habitat utilisation by koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus) at Point Halloran, Queensland MSc Thesis, University of Queensland, Brisbane. Hindell, M. and Lee, A. K. (1987) Habitat use and tree preferences of koalas in a mixed eucalypt forest. Australian Wildlife Research 14: 349–360 Lawler, I. R., Foley, W. J., Eschler, B. M., Pass, D. M. and Handasyde, K. (1998) Intraspecific variation in Eucalyptus secondary metabolites determines food intake by folivorous marsupials. Oecologia 116: 160– 169. Martin, R. and Handasyde, K. (1999) The Koala: Natural History, Conservation and Management. University of New South Wales Press, Sydney. Melzer, A. (1995) Aspects of the ecology of the koala, Phascolarctos cinereus (Goldfuss, 1817), in the sub- humid woodlands of central Queensland. PhD Thesis, University of Queensland, Brisbane Melzer, A. and Lamb, D. (1994) Low density populations of the koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) in Central Queensland. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Queensland 104: 89–93. Mitchell, P. (1990) Social behaviour and communication of koalas. In: Biology of the Koala (editors A. K. Lee, K. A. Handasyde, and G. D. Sanson), Surrey Beatty & Sons, Sydney, pp. 151–171. Moore, B. D. and Foley, W. J. (2000) A review of diet and feeding selection in koalas. Australian Journal of Zoology 48: 317–333 Munks, S. A., Corkrey, R. and Foley, W. J. (1996) Characteristics of arboreal marsupial habitat in the semi- arid woodlands of northern Queensland. Wildlife Research 23: 185–195 Patterson, R. (1996) The distribution of koala in Queensland — 1986 to 1989. In: Koalas, Research for Management: Proceedings of the Brisbane Koala Symposium (editor G. Gordon), World Koala Research Inc., Corinda, pp. 75–81. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 44
Page 49
Noosa on Weyba Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment Phillips, B. (1990) Koalas: the little Australians we’d all hate to lose. Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra. Ramsay, S. (1999). The ecology and dispersal patterns of juvenile koalas, Phascolarctos cinereus, in fragmented habitat, PhD Thesis, Monash University, Clayton, Victoria. Sharpe, L. (1984) The social behaviour of koalas at Phillip Island, Victoria. Honours Thesis, Monash University, Clayton. Sullivan, B. J. (2000) Estimating the abundance of broadscale low density populations: koalas in the mulgalands of south west Queensland. PhD Thesis, University of Queensland, Gatton. White, N. A. (1999) Ecology of the koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) in rural south east Queensland, Australia. Wildlife Research 26: 731–744. White, N. A. and Kunst, N. D. (1990) Aspects of the ecology of the koala in southeastern queensland. In: Biology of the Koala (editors A. K. Lee, K. A. Handasyde, and G. D. Sanson), Surrey Beatty & Sons, Sydney, pp. 109–116. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd Version 2 11 October 2013 Koala Assessment v2.docx Commercial in Confidence Page 45
Page 50
Noosa on Weyba
FIGURES
Figure 1 Noosa on Weyba “Send” and
“Receive” sites
Figure 2 Historical Aerial Imagery
Figure 3 Koala Habitat Values Map
Figure 4 Koala Habitat Tree Survey
Transect Locations
Figure 5 Broad Vegetation Types
Figure 6 Koala Habitat Values Map
with Committed Development
Overlays
Figure 7 Noosa on Weyba Concept
Master Plan Layout
Figure 8 Koala Habitat Values Map
with Noosa on Weyba
Concept Master Plan Layout
Overlay
Figure 9 Koala Habitat Offset Areas
Page 51
NOOSA AND WEYBA
KOALA IMPACT AND NET BENEFIT ASSESSMENT
Noosa National Park
7
(North Weyba Section)
RP46782
2
RP160983
2
RP160983
Noosa National
Park (Eenie
Creek Section)
3 53
SP179590 53
SP163571
SP163571
1667
M37772
11 LEGEND
SP250714 12 Noosa on Weyba Site Boundary
Nature Refuge RP893393
Send Site
Receive Site
Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd All Rights Reserved 2013.
Copyright in the whole and every part of this drawing belongs to Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd and
Scale 1:10,000 (A3)
may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or
form or on any media, to any person other than by agreement with Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd.
FIGURE 1
This document is produced by Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd solely for the benefit of and use by
the client in accordance with the terms of the retainer. Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd does not
and shall not assume any responsibility or liability whatsoever to any third party arising out of
any use or reliance by third party on the content of this document.
NOOSA ON WEYBA "SEND" AND "RECEIVE" SITES
J&K Hofmann and Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd
Page 52
NOOSA AND WEYBA
KOALA IMPACT AND NET BENEFIT ASSESSMENT
1958 1974
1979 1993
Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd All Rights Reserved 2013.
Copyright in the whole and every part of this drawing belongs to Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd and LEGEND Scale 1:20,000 (A3)
may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or
form or on any media, to any person other than by agreement with Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd.
Noosa on Weyba Site Boundary
FIGURE 2
This document is produced by Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd solely for the benefit of and use by
the client in accordance with the terms of the retainer. Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd does not
and shall not assume any responsibility or liability whatsoever to any third party arising out of
any use or reliance by third party on the content of this document.
HISTORICAL AERIAL IMAGERY
J&K Hofmann and Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd
Page 53
NOOSA AND WEYBA
KOALA IMPACT AND NET BENEFIT ASSESSMENT
LEGEND
Noosa on Weyba Site Boundary
KOALA HABITAT VALUES
Medium Value Bushland
Low Value Bushland
Medium Value Rehabilitation
Low Value Rehabilitation
Medium Value Other
KOALA INFRASTRUCTURE
Koala Exclusion Fencing
Koala Underpass
Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd All Rights Reserved 2013.
Copyright in the whole and every part of this drawing belongs to Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd and
Scale 1:10,000 (A3)
may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or
form or on any media, to any person other than by agreement with Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd.
FIGURE 3
This document is produced by Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd solely for the benefit of and use by
the client in accordance with the terms of the retainer. Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd does not
and shall not assume any responsibility or liability whatsoever to any third party arising out of
any use or reliance by third party on the content of this document.
KOALA HABITAT VALUES MAP
J&K Hofmann and Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd
Page 54
NOOSA AND WEYBA
KOALA IMPACT AND NET BENEFIT ASSESSMENT
T19 T16 T17
T43
T18
T42 T40
T41
T32 T37 T36
T30
T31 T38
T45 T44
T35 T33 T46
T34
T20
T5
T9
T10
T27
T2 T1
T8 T24 T6 T22
T4 T3
T7
T23 T39 T21 T26
T14
T28
T29
T47
T25
T15
T11
T12
LEGEND
Noosa on Weyba Site Boundary
T13
T1 Transects start point
Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd All Rights Reserved 2013.
Copyright in the whole and every part of this drawing belongs to Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd and
Scale 1:12,500 (A3)
may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or
form or on any media, to any person other than by agreement with Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd.
FIGURE 4
This document is produced by Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd solely for the benefit of and use by
the client in accordance with the terms of the retainer. Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd does not
and shall not assume any responsibility or liability whatsoever to any third party arising out of
any use or reliance by third party on the content of this document.
KOALA HABITAT TREE SURVEY TRANSECT LOCATIONS
J&K Hofmann and Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd
Page 55
NOOSA AND WEYBA
KOALA IMPACT AND NET BENEFIT ASSESSMENT
Noosa National
12.9-10.1 12.3.4
8 Park - North
Weyba Section 12.1.1/12.1.3
6
12.3.13
8
6
5
12.3.5
12.3.5
12.3.5
4a
2 5
2
2
3a
12.3.2/12.3.1 5
12.3.13
7 7 7
5 8 3b
12.3.5 2 7 7 Noosa 12.3.13
1
8 4a
7 7 National Park -
4a
8 Eenie Creek
8
2
7 Section LEGEND
4a Noosa on Weyba Site Boundary
8
4a
8 EXTENT
7
VEGETATION - HABITAT TYPE (HA)
8
4a
7 2 4a 1 - RE 12.3.4 - Melaleuca quinquenervia, Eucalyptus robusta open forest on or 82.8
4a near coastal alluvial plains
8 2 - RE 12.3.5 - Melaleuca quinquenervia open forest on coastal alluvium 45.5
8 8 3a - RE 12.3.11 - Eucalyptus siderophloia, E. tereticornis, Corymbia intermedia 1.84
8 open forest on alluvial plains usually near coast (understorey intact)
1
8 3b - RE 12.3.11 - Eucalyptus siderophloia, E. tereticornis, Corymbia intermedia 0.94
12.3.5/12.3.4 4b open forest on alluvial plains usually near coast (understorey modified)
12.3.13 12.5.3
4a - RE 12.5.3 - Eucalyptus tindaliae and/or E. racemosa open forest on 37.23
12.5.9/12.3.5 4b
remnant Tertiary surfaces (understorey intact)
12.5.3 12.5.9 9
Nature 8
4b - RE 12.5.3 - Eucalyptus tindaliae and/or E. racemosa open forest on
remnant Tertiary surfaces (understorey modified)
4.26
10
Refuge 5 - RE 12.3.13 - Closed heathland on seasonally waterlogged alluvial plains 26.66
8 8 usually near coast
12.5.9/12.3.5 12.5.3 12.5.3
4a 6 - RE 12.9-10.1 - Shrubby open forest with Eucalyptus resinifera, E.grandis, 2.10
12.3.13/12.3.5 Corymbia intermedia on sedimentary rocks
7 - Melaleuca quinquenervia Regrowth 11.75
8
12.3.13 8 - Non-remnant Woodland - Open Forest Vegetation 88.24
12.5.9/12.3.5 12.5.3 9 - Lakeside Vegetation 0.02
12.5.9/12.3.5 12.5.3
12.3.14 10 - Waterway Vegetation 1.66
12.3.13
12.5.3
Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd All Rights Reserved 2013.
Copyright in the whole and every part of this drawing belongs to Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd and
Scale 1:10,000 (A3)
may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or
form or on any media, to any person other than by agreement with Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd.
FIGURE 5
This document is produced by Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd solely for the benefit of and use by
the client in accordance with the terms of the retainer. Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd does not
and shall not assume any responsibility or liability whatsoever to any third party arising out of
any use or reliance by third party on the content of this document.
BROAD VEGETATION TYPES
J&K Hofmann and Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd
Page 56
NOOSA AND WEYBA
KOALA IMPACT & NET BENEFIT ASSESSMENT
LEGEND
Noosa on Weyba Site
KOALA HABITAT VALUES
Medium Value Bushland
Low Value Bushland
Medium Value Rehabilitation
Low Value Rehabilitation
Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd All Rights Reserved 2013.
Copyright in the whole and every part of this drawing belongs to Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd and
Scale 1:10,000 (A3)
may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or
form or on any media, to any person other than by agreement with Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd.
FIGURE 6
This document is produced by Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd solely for the benefit of and use by
the client in accordance with the terms of the retainer. Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd does not
and shall not assume any responsibility or liability whatsoever to any third party arising out of
any use or reliance by third party on the content of this document.
KOALA HABITAT VALUES MAP WITH COMMITTED DEVELOPMENT OVERLAYS
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd
Page 57
NOOSA ON WEYBA
KOALA IMPACT & NET BENEFIT ASSESSMENT
Noosa National
Park - North
Weyba Section
Noosa National
Park - Eenie Creek
Section
Weyba Nature
Refuge
Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd All Rights Reserved 2013.
Copyright in the whole and every part of this drawing belongs to Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd and
Scale 1:10,000 (A3)
may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or
form or on any media, to any person other than by agreement with Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd.
FIGURE 7
This document is produced by Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd solely for the benefit of and use by
the client in accordance with the terms of the retainer. Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd does not
and shall not assume any responsibility or liability whatsoever to any third party arising out of
any use or reliance by third party on the content of this document.
NOOSA ON WEYBA CONCEPT MASTER PLAN LAYOUT
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd
Page 58
NOOSA ON WEYBA
KOALA IMPACT & NET BENEFIT ASSESSMENT
Noosa National
Park - North
Weyba Section
Noosa National
Park - Eenie Creek
Section
LEGEND
Noosa on Weyba Site
KOALA HABITAT VALUES
Medium Value Bushland
Weyba Nature
Refuge Low Value Bushland
Medium Value Rehabilitation
Low Value Rehabilitation
Generally Not Suitable
Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd All Rights Reserved 2013.
Copyright in the whole and every part of this drawing belongs to Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd and
Scale 1:10,000 (A3)
may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or
form or on any media, to any person other than by agreement with Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd.
FIGURE 8
This document is produced by Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd solely for the benefit of and use by
the client in accordance with the terms of the retainer. Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd does not
and shall not assume any responsibility or liability whatsoever to any third party arising out of
any use or reliance by third party on the content of this document.
KOALA HABITAT VALUES MAP WITH CONCEPT MASTER PLAN LAYOUT OVERLAY
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd
Page 59
NOOSA ON WEYBA
KOALA IMPACT & NET BENEFIT ASSESSMENT
RE12.9-10.1/0.33ha Noosa National
Park - North
Weyba Section
RE12.9-10.1/0.27ha
RE12.9-10.1/1.33ha
RE12.3.11/0.23ha
RE12.3.11/0.09ha
RE12.3.11/0.12ha
RE12.5.3/0.11ha RE12.3.11/0.42ha
Noosa National
RE12.3.11/0.12ha Park - Eenie Creek
RE12.3.11/0.31ha
Section
RE12.5.3/0.64ha
RE12.3.5/23.4ha
RE12.3.5/0.07ha
RE12.5.3/2.44ha
RE12.3.5/5.19ha RE12.5.3/0.85ha
RE12.3.4/0.16ha RE12.3.4/1.82ha
LEGEND
RE12.3.5/0.25ha RE12.5.3/1.03ha
RE12.5.3/0.20ha Send Site
RE12.5.3 /0.28ha
RE12.5.3/0.36ha Receive Site
RE12.3.11/1.15ha ENVIRONMENTAL OFFSET AREAS
Koala Habitat and Vegetation Offset Area
Weyba Nature - Send Sites
Refuge
Koala Habitat and Vegetation Offset Area
- Receive Sites
Koala Habitat Enrichment Planting Area
RE12.3.4/2.69ha
RE12.5.3/0.18ha
Restoration Regional Ecosystem Type /Extent of area.
Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd All Rights Reserved 2013.
Copyright in the whole and every part of this drawing belongs to Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd and
Scale 1:10,000 (A3)
may not be used, sold, transferred, copied or reproduced in whole or in part in any manner or
form or on any media, to any person other than by agreement with Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd.
FIGURE 9
This document is produced by Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd solely for the benefit of and use by
the client in accordance with the terms of the retainer. Cardno (Qld) Pty Ltd does not
and shall not assume any responsibility or liability whatsoever to any third party arising out of
any use or reliance by third party on the content of this document.
KOALA HABITAT OFFSET AREAS
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd
Page 60
Noosa on Weyba APPENDIX A South East Queensland Koala Habitat Values Map (Ref: map SPP_KHV 4 SEQKPA v1.2)
Page 61
State Planning Policy
(2/10):
Tewantin Koala Conservation in
South East Queensland.
Noosa Heads SEQ Koala Protection Area
Lake MacDonald Koala Habitat Values.
Doonella Lake Noosa River
Co o ro y
- N o os
Noosaville
a R oad
Sunshine Beach
Map Legend
Br u
Koala Habitat Value Category
ce H
Cooroy
Bushland Habitat
ig h w
Sunrise Beach
ay
High Value Bushland
Medium Value Bushland
Low Value Bushland
Suitable for Rehabilitation
Co
High Value Rehabilitation
or
oy
-B Medium Value Rehabilitation
e ll Lake Weyba
iC
Marcus Beach Low Value Rehabilitation
w Way
re
ek
Ro
ad
d Other Areas of Value
Dav id Lo
oa
Doonan oo
s aR High Value Other
-N
n di Medium Value Other
mu
Eu
Low Value Other
Generally not suitable
Em Water
u
M
ou
nt Urban Footprint
a in
Ar
te Cadastre (January 2010)
ri a
lR
Major Roads
Eumundi
oa
d
Peregian Beach
map SPP_KHV 4
Bru ce May 31, 2010.
r
ive
(SEQKPA v1.2)
yR
Hig h w
oc h
aro
ay
M
r th
No
Map index 1
Da v
Ro a d
Br
Yandina Creek
id L
2 3 4
ow
ow
ns
B u n ya
Cr
Wa
5 6 7
ee
y
k
Coolum Beach 8 9 10 11
Bridges
13 14
d
12 15
oa
R
m
lu
16 18 19 20
oo
17
-C
Wappa Dam
Point Arkwright
na
21
di
22 23 24 25
n
Ya
Co
o lum 26 27 28 29
Yandina Cr
eek
30 31 32
Mount Coolum
r
i ve
h yR
w ay
o oc
ar
GDA94, MGA56
e M otor
M
u th
So Scale 1 : 50,000 at A1
Sun sh in
0 0.5 1 2 3 4
Kilometres
Br u
r
ve
Data Sources
Ri
ce H
SEQ Landcover, SEQ Koala Habitat mapping (GHD, 2009);
y
ch
Digital Cadastral Database (DCDB) (Dept. of Environment and
Marcoola
ig h w
o Resources Management, Jan 2010);Drainage mapping (Geoscience Australia);
ro
State Digital Road Network (Mapinfo Australia,2006);LGA Boundary (Dept.
Ma
of Planning and Infrastructure);Towns, Built up Areas (GA, 2003)
ay
Parklands Disclaimer
While every care is taken to ensure the accuracy of this product the
Queensland Government, Mapinfo Pty Ltd and the Australian Government make
Kureelpa
no representations or warranties about the accuracy, reliability, completeness
or suitability for any particular purpose and disclaims all responsibility
and all liability (including without limitation, liability in negligence) for all
expenses, losses, damages (including indirect or consequential damage)
and costs you may incur as a result of the product being inaccurate
Bli Bli Road or incomplete in any way or for any reason. Landsat TM imagery 2008,
Bli Bli Mudjimba Island supplied by the Statewide Landcover and Tree Study (SLATS),
Highworth
was also used in producing this information.
Pacific Paradise
© The State of Queensland 2010
Mapleton Nambour
Mapleton Mudjimba
w ay
in e M otor
Page 62
Noosa on Weyba APPENDIX B Koala Habitat Transect Survey Methods and Results [OCR of page images] Noosa on Weyba APPENDIX Koala Habitat Transect Survey Methods and Results cD Cardna Shaping the Future
Page 63
Noosa on Weyba
Appendix B - Koala Habitat Surveys and Results
The application of the Koala SPRP Offsets for Net Gain of Koala Habitat in South East Queensland Policy (the Koala
Offset Policy) requires compensation for the unavoidable loss of non-juvenile koala habitat trees (NJKHT) once all
applicable regulatory requirements are met.
A NJKHT is a koala habitat tree that has:
a. a height of more than four metres; or
b. a trunk with a circumference of more than 31.5 centimetres at 1.3 metres above the ground.
A Koala habitat tree (KHT) is:
a. a food tree of the Corymbia, Melaleuca, or Lophostemon or Eucalyptus genera; or
b. a preferred shelter species such as Angophora.
To determine the quantum of NJKHT offsets that would be required by the proposed Noosa on Weyba project, and to
collate other information concerning Koala activity, transect based surveys of Koala activity and habitat resources were
carried out at a total of 47 locations within and adjacent to the Noosa on Weyba site over the period between 14 June
2012 and 10 August 2012. The transect based surveys were appropriately distributed within the various broad
vegetation types comprising the site, and provided data concerning the following parameters at each of the survey
locations.
> Koala presence/absence;
> Evidence of past Koala activity in the form of scat or scratches; and
> Koala habitat tree presence, species composition, size and abundance/density.
The locations of transect based surveys are illustrated in Figure 4 of the Koala Impact and Net Benefit Assessment.
The number of NJKHT that would require clearance to facilitate the Noosa on Weyba project was estimated using a
combination of:
1) direct tree counts in sparsely vegetated areas using a combination of counts from high resolution aerial
photography and direct field based verification counts; and
2) a Count Sampling method based on a form of Variable Area Transects (VAT, Parker 1979) to estimate the
density of NJKHT within densely vegetated areas.
Justification for the selection of the VAT method, together with a detailed description of the method, is provided below.
VAT Survey Method
Two methods are commonly employed when measuring the density of plant communities and closed animal
populations where the animals are relatively stationary: quadrats and distance-measures (Parker, 1979). Both of these
methods have limitation, particularly when being used in the field to derive estimates where:
the density of the target species may vary considerably and the use of a standard quadrat size may not be
practicable [For example a NJKHT survey method based on a standardised 20mx20m quadrat may require
Page i of xiv
Page 64
Noosa on Weyba
excessive survey effort (e.g. in densely vegetated areas) or not provide a meaningful non-zero estimate of
density (e.g. in sparsely vegetated areas)]; and
for distance-measure estimates of density, which rely on an accurate measurement of the distance from a
selected point to the nearest nth individual, the difficulty (effort involved) in determining with confidence
which is the nth individual.
Variable Area Transects (VAT) provide a means of avoiding some of the difficulties (and effort) associated with quadrats
and distance-measures density estimation methods by sampling such that the search for the nth individual is a
consequence of traversing a transect (Parker, 1979). Effectively the VAT method can be considered a combination of
distance-measures and quadrat methods (Engerman et al, 2005) and allows for density estimations without the lengthy
search times associated with other plotless density estimators (Obrowski and Murphy, 2006).
A VAT survey method was used to obtain estimates of the densities of NJKHT within the Noosa on Weyba locality for
the following reasons:
the method is robust to variation in the density of NJKHT that is associated with different vegetation types that
required survey; and
the method is efficient, with a single person being able to complete a VAT with limited time required for survey
set up.
The VAT survey method used for the purpose of obtaining estimates of the density of NJKHT within different vegetation
types located within the Noosa on Weyba site locality involved the following.
1) Survey sites were selected within a representative area of vegetation. The selection of the survey site was
biased given that the primary purpose of the survey was to estimate the number of NJKHT located within the
vegetation that was a risk of clearance in the event of the Noosa on Weyba project being approved.
2) At each survey site the latitude and longitude of the start (and end) point of the VAT was recorded and the
bearing (direction) of the VAT was determined so that the VAT generally followed the natural contour of the
land. The exception to this was when a VAT was specifically located within a road reserve, in which case the
bearing of the VAT was biased so that it traversed the entire road reserve, including the road clearing.
3) From the starting point of the VAT a measuring tape was laid out along the chosen bearing of the transect.
4) A photograph was taken at the start point of the transect orientated along the chosen bearing and a further
photograph was taken at the end of each transect orientated back towards the start point of the transect.
5) The width of the VAT (Tw) was set at a constant width of 2 m. This width was selected as it enabled the
surveyor to make a single pass along the centre line of the transect and distinguish between NJKHT situated
within (< 1 m from the centre line) or situated outside of (> 1 m from the centre line) of the VAT.
6) The VAT length (TL ) was:
a.if not located within a road reserve, determined by the distance along the transect that was traversed
until:
i. a total of 10 NJKHT had been encountered; or
ii. there was a discernible change in the vegetation type being traversed.
b. if located within a road reserve, the width of the road reserve.
7) For each NJKHT located within each VAT the following data was recorded:
tree species,
tree height;
tree trunk diameter at a height of ~ 1.3m above the ground;
the presence of a Koala within the tree;
evidence of scratch marks on the trunk of the tree; and
the presence of Koala scat beneath the canopy of the tree.
Page ii of xiv
Page 65
Noosa on Weyba
Visual scans for the presence of Koala within trees adjacent to the VAT were also made.
The general layout of the VAT datasheets used in the Noosa on Weyba surveys is presented below.
Date: Transect #: Name:
Start Loc'n
Finish Loc'n
Bearing
Mapped Veg (RE)
Canopy:
Veg Description Sub-Canopy:
Ground Cover:
Photo #'s and
Description
Distance along Ht Koala habitation
Tree # Species transect (m) (m) DBH (cm) indicators
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Density
Calculation
(KHT/ha) NJKHT/ha = D*10000
Where D= n/(2*Transect Length) n = number of NJKHT
General Notes
Page iii of xiv
The text continues on page 66.
Used in these records
About this file
- File size
- 29.3 MB (very large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
The download may take a few minutes. On mobile data, it is best to wait for Wi-Fi.