Council archive · source document
2ND RFI - Attachment 7B - Response to Further Advice-Bushfire · MCU22/0118
Rob Friend & Associates Pty Ltd
Environmental Land Management Consultants
RF&A
Office – Unit 4/3 Heaslop St
Woolloongabba
Postal - 28 Merton Road
Woolloongabba Qld. 4102
p - (07) 3891 9131
f - (07) 3393 0388
m - 0419-667346
Your reference: -- e - [email protected]
w – www.robfriend.com
Our reference: -- RFA18-048
ABN 83 097 068 114
Date: - 18 July 2023 ACN 097 068 114
Patrick Murphy
Coordinator Planning
Noosa Shire Council
PO Box 141
Tewantin, Qld. 4565
Dear Mr Murphy,
Re: - Response to Further Advice – MCU22/0118
94 and 142 Noosa Drive, Noosa Heads
RAVC Noosa Resort – Eco-Cabins
Further to the issuing of the Further Advice (dated 6 April 2023), please find our specific response
to further issues raised by Council with respect to Bushfire management which includes, Issue 8,
Issue 12 and Issue 13.
The issue and information Required with respect to bushfire is;
Issue - Bushfire Management within Biodiversity Areas
The submitted application material does not provide sufficient information to demonstrate
compliance with Performance Outcome PO12 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands
Overlay Code. The proposed bushfire management measures required to be adopted do not
maintain or enhance the biodiversity of the ecological community on the site. The proposal
requires the removal of Koala habitat / feed trees, removes the mid strata layer of the regional
ecosystem down to under 500mm in height and requires the understorey be maintained to less
than 100mm in height. These changes to the Regional Ecosystem to achieve a suitable bushfire
separation distance is in opposition to the main principles of the Biodiversity, Waterways and
Wetlands Overlay Code.
It appears that there are inconsistencies between the tree removal plan, landscape plans and
bushfire management plan. The bushfire management plan requires the inner protection area
have all papery and fibrous bark trees such as Melaleuca quinquenervia and Eucalyptus robusta
be removed, including the entire shrub layer. The tree removal plan indicates the retention of these
species within the inner protection area.
The landscape plans indicate that the inner protection area extends along the western boundary in
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 7 pages
Page 2
2
front of units 1, 2, 3, and 4. The tree management plan needs to be updated to include the correct
level of vegetation clearing, which will include all papery and fibrous bark trees such as Melaleuca
quinquenervia and Eucalyptus robusta, all shrubs to be removed and ground covers no greater
that 100mm in height in accordance with the bushfire hazard assessment for inner protection
areas.
The landscape plans indicate that no trees/shrubs are to be retained within 3m of buildings. The
tree retention plan indicates many trees being retained within the 3m limit imposed by the
Landscape Plans. These plans also indicate that tree canopies cannot have any limbs that extend
to within 3 metres of the roof line of the buildings. This will require the removal of significant areas
of tree crown to comply. This is deemed as an unrealistic outcome for the development and the
long-term health of the trees.
Information Required
8. Provided a revised tree retention plans that integrate all bushfire, ecology, tree, and landscape
recommendations and utilises this information to demonstrate how the development maintain
and enhance biodiversity.
Response
1. The issues raised by Council under this request for additional information includes: -
a. Lack of sufficient information to demonstrate compliance with performance
Outcome PO12 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code;
b. The proposed bushfire management measures required do not maintain or
enhance the biodiversity of the ecological community on the site
c. The proposal requires the removal of koala habitat / feed trees, removes the mid
strata layer of the regional ecosystem to under 500 mm in height and requires the
understorey be maintained to less than 100 mm in height
d. The changes to the regional ecosystem are in opposition to the main principals of
the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code.
e. Inconsistencies between the tree removal plan, landscape plans and bushfire
management plan
f. The bushfire management plan requires the inner protection area have all papery
and fibrous bark trees to be removed including the entire shrub layer. The tree
removal plan indicates the retention of these species within the inner protection
area.
g. The landscape plans indicate that the inner protection area extends along the
western boundary in front of units 1, 2, 3 and 4.
h. The tree management plan needs to be updated to include the correct level of
vegetation clearing, which includes all papery and fibrous bark trees such as
Melaleuca quinquenervia and Eucalyptus robusta, all shrubs to be removed and
ground covers no greater that 100mm in height in accordance with the bushfire
hazard assessment for inner protection areas.
i. Retention of trees around buildings and retention of branches over hanging
buildings.
2. In response to the particularised points, a – i above;
Page 3
3
i. For the amended plans, please see the revised Development Plans and tree
retention/removal plans which seeks to improve the integration of the development
within the site resulting in the retention of additional trees and areas within the site
compared to the earlier proposals.
ii. The concept landscape Management Plan has been replaced with a Concept
Rehabilitation Plan (Gondwana Ecology Group 2023) (see attachment 1)
iii. PO12 of the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands Overlay Code states –
PO12
Bushfire management measures are adopted based on ecological principles, which:
(a) Maintain and enhance biodiversity;
(b) Minimise threat of fire to the natural environment, as well as life and property;
and
(c) Provide for effective use and maintenance of buildings and structures.
Editor's note — The performance outcome applies to properties in bushfire hazard
areas and only where clearing is reasonably necessary for the control of bushfire risk
to a building or structure. Bushfire hazard areas are shown on Bushfire Hazard
Overlay maps in Schedule 2.
iv. In response to the Biodiversity, Waterways and Wetlands mapping and the site we
would note;
While there are a number of canopy trees, Eucalyptus robusta and sub-canopy
trees, melaleuca quinquenervia, Glochidion ferdinandi, Acmena hemilampra,
Melicope elleryana and Livistona decora within the site, all of these canopy trees
were being attacked by the aggressive climber Chonemorpha fragrans (Climbing
frangipani vine), which not only hung of all trees but also carpeted the ground
layer.
In areas where the vegetation was to be removed, the overwhelming biomass that
was to be removed were this climber as well as other significant environmental
weeds and pest plant species.
Therefore there was going to be virtually no impact on the native biodiversity
values and significant enhancement of those values with the planting of native
groundcover and shrub species.
The species selection was going in enforce the natural mitigatory affects of less
flammable plant species within the development areas which would reduce any
potential impact to that area by an unmanaged vegetation fire.
We further note based on the site assessment the Bushfire hazard mapping of
areas of high and medium bushfire hazards were incorrect due to the dominance
of the pest and environmental weed species, mapping over the mangrove and
saline vegetation communities on the right bank of Weyba Creek and the reduction
of any area of woodland to less than that which is considered under the State
Planning Policy, natural Hazards, Risk and Resilience to be hazardous vegetation.
v. In response to the issue of maintenance or enhancement of the sites ecological values,
we say the removal of the significant pest plants and environmental weeds and their
Page 4
4
replacement by native plant species consistent with the Regional Ecosystem 12.2.3
will have a significant enhancement over the existing degraded values.
It was not made clear that the maintenance of these new plantings was necessary
in the establishment phase, however once the plantings had reached a level of
maturity, in terms of foliage cover, the level of maintenance, like any area of
vegetation could be reduce to an as need level.
We note the requirement for a 20 metres wide asset protection zone with the two
areas inner and outer and two levels of maintenance was required due to the
location of the cabins 2/2 and ¾. The amended proposal will see Cabins 1/2
reduce to a single cabin and located above the car parking area thereby moving it
behind the existing RACV Noosa Resort buildings. Further this relocation will in
affect also decrease the exposure of Cabins 2/3 (was 3/4) to an area of less than
20 metres thereby enabling the reduction on the asset protection zone from 20
metres to 10 metres.
We would further note that the area within which the current asset protection zone
is also highly degraded and the removal of the pest plants and environmental
weed species and the planting of native plant species will significantly enhance the
biodiversity values of this area. Again the management and maintenance will only
continue until the plantings reach a level of maturity so that it achieved a high level
of foliage cover and the pet and environmental weed seed and vegetative parts
are depleted to a level that they are no long a disruptive element in the local area.
vi. There were no changes proposed in earlier iterations of this development proposal nor
the current proposal to the regional ecosystems. We would note that while it may be
able to be maintained based on the canopy composition, the understorey and
groundcover elements were not consistent with the mapped regional ecosystem and
that was going to be removed and replanted with plant species consistent with the
mapped Regional Ecosystem, 12.2.3. The statements about ongoing management
were not clearly outlined and this has been rectified to ensure that all maintenance of
the development area, including Zones, 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 would be undertaken until
those rehabilitation zone reach a level of maturity where the maintenance could be
reduced to an as needs basis as is the case with all areas of remnant vegetation within
a degraded local area.
vii. We would note the Concept Rehabilitation Plan has replaced the earlier Concept
landscape Plan and as such the updated Bushfire Hazard Assessment and Mitigation
plan is now consistent with that document with regard to the proposed treatments of
each rehabilitation zone identified in the Concept Rehabilitation Plan. Again, the
maintenance of each zone will be for the duration that the planting within those areas
reach a level of maturity that they achieve good foliage cover and the pest plant and
environmental weed dormant seed and plant germinators have been exhausted and
the maintenance can be reduced to an as needs requirement.
viii. Further the tree retention and removal plans have been also updated and are now
consistent in all documents.
ix. While the earlier inner and outer asset protection zone bushfire mitigation structure do
seek to provide a cleared area within the inner zone, the updated asset protection
zoned will seek to only require the removal of two Melaleuca quinquenervia specimens
with all other trees within the APZ retained for the ecological values. The bushfire
mitigation actions will rely upon; the shielding effect of the current RACV Noosa Resort,
Page 5
5
the planting of particular less flammable plant species within the APZ, Rehabilitation
Zone 4 and Zone 3, the detention basin to establish a low vegetative platform with
species consistent with the mapped Regional Ecosystem.
x. The extension of the inner bushfire protection zone along the western boundary was a
cartographic error which was not thought to be an issue, however it is acknowledged
that it misrepresented the status of that 4 metre wide area. This 4 metre wide area is
now forming part of Rehabilitation zone 5 and will be treated as such under the
Concept Rehabilitation Zone. The Bushfire Hazard Assessment and Mitigation plan
has indicated that due to the vegetation communities and width of the adjacent council
managed area along the right bank of Weyba Creek, this area is not wide enough to be
characterised as a bushfire hazard.
xi. With regard to tree management, the arborist reporting is consistent in that tree can be
located adjacent to any of the proposed cabins and as long as they are healthy and do
not present a significant risk to life and property they can be left alone. However, as
with all trees within and around the RACV Noosa Resort, all mature trees will be
regularly assessed and if a tree safety issue arise with a particular tree/s this/these will
be dealt with under the strict arboricultural treatments and practices for mature trees
and where required, seeking approval from Council prior to any tree management
works being undertaken.
xii. We would also note that the rehabilitation zoning as laid out in the Concept
Rehabilitation Plan seeks to integrate the maintenance and enhancement of the
existing biodiversity values and regional Ecosystem while maintain the potential
bushfire risk to a low level of bushfire risk.
Issue – Bushfire Management
The application material indicates that significant areas of native vegetation, core koala habitat,
threatened ecological communities and MSES wetlands are required to be cleared to achieve the
proposed separation distances for Units 1 and 2.
The development has not demonstrated that the bushfire mitigation measures do not have
adverse impact on the biodiversity values, connectivity and ecosystem function of the site and the
surrounding ecologically important areas.
Information Required
12. Provide revised development plans that incorporates a development footprint that does not
require vegetation clearing and ongoing maintenance to facilitate the development.
Response
1. The issues raised by Council under this issue include:
a. Areas of native vegetation, core koala habitat, threatened ecological communities and
MSES wetlands will be cleared to achieve separations distance for units 1 & 2, and
b. The development has not demonstrated that the bushfire mitigation measures do not
have an adverse impact on the biodiversity values, connectivity and ecosystem
function of the site and the surrounding ecologically important areas.
2. With regard to these issues we would note;
Page 6
6
The asset protection zone has been reduced to a width of 10 metres due to the site
factors mentioned in point “v” above.
The reduction in level of exposure and the specifications contained in the Concept
Rehabilitation Plan will, in time, allow for improved enhancements of the site
biodiversity values and result in limited ongoing management inputs as the outcomes
of the rehabilitation works reach a level of maturity.
The clarity that the Concept Rehabilitation Plan brings to this proposal should enable
the updated development proposal to satisfactorily respond in demonstrating that this
development proposal will not have an adverse impact on the biodiversity values,
connectivity and ecosystem function of the site and the surrounding ecologically
important areas.
Conclusions
i. The potential impacts onto MSES, Koala habitat trees and wetland areas has been
significantly reduced to a level where only two Melaleuca quinquenervia trees will be
required to be removed.
ii. The relocation of Eco-cabin 1 to a position over the proposed car parking area has in effect
resulted in the existing RACV Noosa Resort providing a shielding effect on that structure
and which has resulted in a reduction of the asset protection zone from 20 metres to 10
metres.
iii. The relocation has also reduced the potential exposure for Eco-cabins 2 and 3 to
approximately 20 metres and with the 10 metre wide asset protection zone this is sufficient
to ensure adequate bushfire protection for this structure.
iv. The area where the 10 metre wide asset protection zone is to be located is significantly
degraded in the understorey by a range of pest and environmental weeds and as such any
ongoing works in terms of new plantings of native groundcover and low shrubs and the
necessary maintenance of that area will have no impact on the site existing ecological
value. Further the plantings will significantly improve the areas ecological values with the
replacement of the weeds by local native species.
v. The implementation of the Concept Rehabilitation Plan will result in the removal of all the
pest and environmental weed species from the development footprint including Zone 4 –
Asset protection zone and Zone 5 the balance area amongst the proposed Eco-cabins.
Issue – Access for Emergency Service
The application material has not demonstrated safe access and egress to the whole development
for emergency vehicles and personnel. Some units are approximately 70 metres from the carpark
area where the bushfire hazard assessment requires ‘at least one fire hydrant stand pipe within the
central portion of the car parking area’. It is difficult to understand how QFES vehicles and
personnel are to respond in an emergency situation and protect infrastructure from fire.
Information Required
13. Demonstrate compliance with PO6 of the Bushfire Hazard Overlay Code
Response
1. The issues raised by Council under issue 13 includes;
Page 7
7
a. That access by Emergency Service can and will effectively respond to a bushfire
within or around the proposed development.
2. With respect to this issue we say;
The original development proposal for the Eco-cabins did not include any new roads
but a single car park area where short term stay guests would park and that the car
parking area could also permit access onto the Eco-cabins development by
Emergency Services for the purpose of attending to both a vegetation and structural
fire. This has not changed and on first read, PO6 was not relevant to this
development.
We do note that, the RACV Noosa Resort has an Emergency Response Plan which
covers the existing resort area and this Plan will be updated following the completion of
the proposed Eco-cabin development to include the new short stay Eco-cabins. This
plan will therefore have an emergency response for all natural hazards which will
include bushfire and structural fires and identifies actions by dedicated staff members
following the resort become aware of any natural hazard event.
With regard to a specific response to PO 6;
a. No vehicle accessible firebreaks are proposed.
b. All Emergency Service appliance will utilise the existing car parking facility for the
Eco-cabin or any other part of the RACV Noosa resort that they will require to
effectively respond to a vegetation or/or structural fire event.
c. Safe access and egress for short stay visitors will be in accordance with the
directions given by the dedicated RACV Noosa Resort Fire Chief, the guests and
staff existing the Eco-cabins via the boardwalks to the dedicated evacuation area
identified in the Emergency Response Plan. Activities specified in that plan such
as identifying and accounting for all guests from evacuated areas within the RACV
Noosa Resort as well as notification via text and other communications systems of
the emergency response the resort have implemented.
d. The Bushfire Hazard Assessment & Mitigation Plan has also recommended that a
number of Hydrant stand pipes be located within the Eco-cabin facility and that
these be generally located where they provide suitable connectivity by Emergency
Services for the purpose of vegetation and structural fire suppression operations.
e. Depending on the engineering requirements, these hydrant stand pipes can be
connected to the proposes internal water reticulation system which will service the
fire hoses at each unit or if necessary, be connected to existing high flow/low flow
valves at the entrance to the RACV Noosa Resort via a dedicated piping system.
f. The proposed new reticulated fresh water system is to be located under the
proposed boardwalk which services all of the proposed Eco-cabins and therefore, if
a dedicated high pressure emergency reticulated water network is required this can
also be located under the proposed boardwalk with hydrant standpipes located
generally within an area to service all of the Eco-units at locations generally in
accordance with those locations identified in the updated Bushfire Hazard
Assessment & Mitigation Plan (Rob Friend & Associates Pty Ltd, July 2023) and
specified as part of the detailed design and building and plumbing approvals.
Page 8
8
Conclusion
i. Therefore, based on the above PO6 is not relevant to this development proposal as no
new roads are being proposed. However, the updated proposal does and can effectively
respond to AO6.3 – AO6.5 in the Bushfire Hazard Overlay Code.
If you have any further questions regarding this response to the Further Advice Request, please
contact me or Mr Shane Adamson at your convenience.
Yours faithfully,
Rob Friend
Director
Rob Friend & Associates Pty Ltd
Used in these records
2ND RFI - Attachment 7B - Response to Further Advice-Bushfire.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 2.3 MB (large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
Log in to download the original file
The download may take up to a minute.