Skip to the record
Mmm.. taste the original NoosaWatch™
Item 7.2.2026-11-19 · OrdinaryOfficial item record

Deputation Applicant: Rod Lees Topic: Glyphosate And Roadside Weed Management In Noosa Shire Speaker/s: Rod Lees, Tim Scott

← Meeting agenda & transcript

See the votes on this matter →

What was decided?

The minuted decision sequence

No separately labelled carried Council Resolution has been identified here. Read each formal event and the complete item minutes; a lost motion is not necessarily the final outcome.

Read complete item-specific minutes

This summary follows this item’s minutes. The established voting totals use their existing method while differences are checked against the full records.

What was said?

Named discussion on NoosaWatch TV

These actual transcript passages match the item’s wording. The start and end of the item’s discussion are not yet confirmed; these excerpts are not measured item airtime or exact decision moments.

Good morning, Mayor and Councillors. First of all, I'd like to thank you for what you do, both Councillors and staff. It's a very difficult job that you do and you're kind for nothing and get hit in all different directions. And I'm about to hit you with another one. Next month I turn 81, though I try not to dwell on it. Every day I promise myself that in the unknown period I have left on this planet I should stop worrying about things so much and spend more time travelling, more time with family and friends, eating good clean food, swimming in the ocean and riding my bike down the Coast and through our amazing hinterland. This morning we nearly collected three kangaroos, or actually three kangaroos nearly collected me, so I'm here to tell the tale and then I see a utility drive down our street in the canals in Noosa Waters with a big tank on the back marked glyphosate, at least it's got the markings on. The driver is leaning out the window. With a spray wand constantly streaming glyphosate in the gutters. While he had a long sleeve shirt on he had no gloves, no glasses and no breathing protection. I then see other Council workers in the community and I've noted them in Thomas Street and Gibson. Road amongst all our residents, are there, sprayers are there. The residents have no idea what's going on. The workers are armed with a knapsack spraying glyphosate everywhere and waving the wand about in a manner that seemed to lack due care and attention. This time short sleeve shirt and shorts, no masks, no proper eye protection. While the level of protection required varies depending upon the safety data sheet, that's a different safety data sheet for each particular product amongst the thousands of varieties, the bare minimum requirement for spraying glyphosate in Queensland from WorkSafe Queensland is as follows: chemical resistant gloves, protective clothing, masks, most likely eye protection and protective footwear. WorkSafe Queensland is particularly concerned about skin contact, breathing and vapour from spray mist and accidental ingestion through poor hand hygiene now some councils in Australia go beyond the minimum for safety even though the SDS may not require it. As an example, my wife and I, lovely wife Karen there, and I were recently doing a hike around Uluru, one of Australia's most major tourist attractions. We came across a warning sign that said "Spraying in progress. Take care." We found the workers down the track who were all dressed up like they were about to land on the moon. They were spraying glyphosate to get rid of buffel grass. So for both my mental and physical health I go for a ride in the hinterland and I see the result of what appears to be random rampant spraying that has no pattern except for a concentration in the gullies and the waterways. That's where the spraying is going, in the gullies and the waterways. Most advice on location spraying clearly states these areas should be avoided. I surmise that they do this as it may be difficult to mow. It appears from my limited knowledge they may just be spraying grass that has been planted to stop the erosion. What is left is bare earth that gets washed away along with the residual spray during the next rain. Event and it all ends up in our waterways increasing sedimentation and polluting our rivers. We know that from the three-year local study, that was a local study, concluded in 2023, 2000, that glyphosate remains in the soil for at least 12 months and it kills the soil microbes in the process. Apart from the plants, it is the soil microbes that hold the soil together and gives it life. Now the debate on whether glyphosate causes cancer or not is ongoing and with only 15 minutes of time to talk about the latest research. However, any evidence that's contrary to the position of the multinational chemical companies is an immediate attack. In addition, these same chemical companies have infiltrated our universities, research centres, schools, agricultural conferences and land care. They even donated some round-up to a recent land care tree planning program. You know, I find that pre-planning and then biopsy, I have difficulty with that. My background is in education and health and I'm extremely concerned about our environment and the survival of our planet. So it's very easy to get is happening in our neighbourhood and beyond so for inspiration Karen and I we go to visit our farming friends who we've met through slow food Noosa. They are all either certified organic or at least chemical ran into two of them on Sunday and I said we were doing this deputation but I was getting cold feet. I thought I'd pull the pin and they said oh no don't do that we've got to have somebody get up and talk about this stuff. So here we are. This chemical what spray successfully this is what happens on all farms prior to the post-war growth so the chemical industry will be placed the bombs and the gas with chemical first fertilisers and pesticides along with the growth of industrial agriculture. So so at this point I'd like introduce to you to Tim Scott. He's one of the farmers we visit. Tim is from kandanga certified organic farm and store and he's here to tell you part of his story. Now while kandanga is not in the Noosa Shire, the situations and experiences are the same. Tim knows area than anyone else I know. He's been fighting the battle for over ten years. My only concern is I've given Tim five minutes and he could take five days. Anyway Tim, and then I'll come back and finish up. Thank you.
Thanks, for the opportunity and thanks Rod for organising it and yeah it's a massive topic and there are solutions out there but it takes a complete mind shift and we don't have time to explain all those steps in doing that. Today I guess the only thing really have time for as a certified organic farmer and a resident in this area and we have lots of customers over in this area. We are the only shop in the country that doesn't sell synthetic chemicals and synthetic fertilising chemicals and that's financial problem to us and this is how this industry developed is that about 50% of the revenue of most of these rural shops comes just from one product, just from LifeSafe. So it's a massive ingrained part of our system and that's why you're seeing it pushed to you guys to use everywhere. It's causing more problems though than sort what is in the media. So I guess the only thing I can really talk about quickly is reverse onus and this is a topic that came up you know we did a day the other day to try to help Vicky with how we get food into Noosa and do distribution here. And this reverse onus topic I've never really heard it before. I heard it again with a deputation through the senate inquiry into paraquat the other day and it's how the APVMA is operating now too. Once a product is approved there's an onus down on everyone else to prove that there's something wrong with it rather than proving the companies that sell it continue to prove that it's safe. So we get this a lot in the organic world because we have a certified organic farms. The onus is on us then to tell everyone don't spray our area and it's as if there's a an underlying I don't know mentality that everyone wants to be sprayed it's just the weird people that have to sign a chemical free register or whatever you call yours here an intolerance register or something some crazy thing and so what if that onus is switched around and what if you had to sign up to be sprayed? So where we are we have to put up these signs saying don't spray you know stopping us from spraying this area I don't know why we can't use GPS like every other spray contractor in the world but we have to put up signs so what if it was the other way around and everyone had to put up a sign saying you know spray my area does that change the view do people travelling to this area have a preconception that it's a biosphere area and it's clean and green so what if we started to get people that actually want to have their roadsides maintained in this way show everyone it turns it around completely this reverse onus thing is something that's going to cause a liability issue I believe for councils across the country because at the moment um they're relying a lot on the assumption that everything they're being told for the APVMA is correct and their residents want to have chemical exposure and I don't think any resident would sign up to that if they had to sign a spray register to say please spray them in so it's of thinking about it and that's and there are alternatives and we've run trials on this over the years we continue to run trials but most of it is around setting context why do you have to spray the side of the road when there's a road sign that tall why is it spray around the bottom of it it's not a visual issue so this goes back to Main Roads and there's all sorts we can go through that too but if my wife has just got a chemical residue with an organic diet for 40 years she's got that report back to say she four times over the legal limit and that's causing her an issue um so she can't really work in the business anymore and I don't she's I don't know how many people actually gone and got a biopsy test ever but when you end up in hospital that's some of the stuff you do um so how many people are on that leading up to that point and then what do we do we've got a business that we can't run so the liability lies somewhere the closest um sprayer we have is Council it's 100 metres at the end of our driveway there's a million ways to solve these problems that isn't poison thanks to Tim.
We've probably got about five minutes left. So I need to get to the point of all this. Here are some suggestions. One Tim's already made, which is instead of 'don't spray', you know, 'spray' and I was talking to one of the organic farmers in the area the other day and he said I have to pay $1,700 every year to let people know that I'm spray-free and everyone else doesn't have to pay anything. It's that's crazy. So some issues. Is the amount of chemical spraying taking place in our community really necessary? Is it being applied appropriately and are there better alternatives? If you're going to spray glyphosate in Noosa, do you have a responsibility to warn the residents? It's a legislative requirement in a lot of other parts of Australia. Ensure that your workers are adequately protected and maybe, given Tim's experience with his wife Amber that's four times over the limit, maybe you should test the glyphosate levels of your staff who are spraying what appears to me unprotected to see how they rate. The chemical sensitivity register that Tim mentioned that's the do not spray register and it's touted in the Noosa Council staff document that was recently given to you as Councillors. Problem is it's secret. No one knows about it. I had difficulty actually registering and when my first phone call said that they don't know anything about it. Eventually I got registered then I had a call from a Councillor staff member who drove down our street he said well you're going to have difficulties you've got pavers in there and all that grass that's grown up in between the pavers even though you're on the do not spray register if there's grass they will spray it. So I have the fellow that does our yard every fortnight he comes and he's out on the road with his whipper snipper spraying through the pavers so that we don't have any stuff coming up. It takes him five minutes, it's not a big deal. Examine the implications of the current spraying levels with your desire to promote regenerative agriculture which is part of the Noosa Plan culture which is part of the New South Wales, I know trump's very involved in that. And also promote the Noosa Plan in our community and improve the health of our soils which is part of the recent LGAQ conference motion that I know Frank you took to Cairns and you got it through so you want to improve the health of the soils within Noosa it's a contradiction of terms to talk about healthy soils and regenerative agriculture if you're going to spray it just doesn't they just don't go together other implications for the renewal of the Noosa Biosphere I know in talking to biosphere staff they're concerned develop a plan to reduce the amount of spraying in our community and advertise what you're doing you have the opportunity under the 2026 biosecurity plan examine again the many alternatives that are available Tim's got a whole lot of stuff there have now been adopted there are at least 13 LGAs in Australia and it took a very quick AI search for me to come up with those 13 this is not one of them that have some alternatives to what the current spraying is they don't have an eliminated club so there's some councils tried to eliminate then they've come back on it but they have a plan they have a they have something that's there that says this is what we're going to do have a look at what Europe is doing. Germany has largely eliminated glyphosate spraying due to and they've actually measured it a 75% reduction in the insect population I said to Amelia the other day when you go for a drive at night in your car and you come home do you have the insects on your car that we used to have no we don't they're just not there why is that because there are insects are disappearing and so are bees the last time I sprayed in our yard I sprayed with some weed and feed I was into everything's got to look good and our grass was the best in the street and then I got some clover and I thought oh I better get rid of this clover it doesn't it's not right there so I sprayed it with weed and feed that I got from Bunnings and the next day I feeding on the clover and I'm calling out Donny tad now we've got clover on our front yard and we're the only one in the street that I'm proud of it. Transport and Main Roads this is a big issue because a lot of the responsibility for spraying in this community is transporting our own Main Roads and I think the ones they're the ones that I see out in the community when I ride and they're spraying in the gullies. Now somehow we've got to talk to them and say I've got finished? No that's 15. Okay. In the end I imagine from your perspective it all comes down to cost and efficiency. You have to balance the budget, you have to fulfil your biosecurity requirements. The Council staff briefing highlights this along with the continued referral. To APVMA. I won't go into APVMA, but 90% of their budget comes from the industry that they regulate, so you've got to question that. What's the long-term cost? The first court case for negligence, the overall health of the community, the clean green image of Noosa Shire Council, the damage to our soils and waterways and the loss of bees and other healthful insects. I'm about to finish. One last thought. Possibly the ugliest part of the Noosa roadsides right now are the traffic islands that have been filled with concrete and has multiple dead weeds standing straight in every crack and cranny. Just have a look at the areas between the two roundabouts joining Hilton Terrace and Gibson road and you'll see what I mean. So you've got traffic islands and all these big things sticking up. Why don't we, I say we, when budget allows, dig up the concrete, replace it with some soil, mulch and plan some ground cover for the flowers. It will keep the so-called weeds at bay and the community and the bees will love you poor. Thank you very much.
1 suggested discussion start time
  • 920.0 seconds on the council source timeline · Recording time not yet verified. The end of the discussion is not yet confirmed.

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.