Skip to the record
The first. The best. The only NoosaWatch™.

Council archive · source document

07/0786 - Response to Information Request [As Published] · 132007.786

of 10

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

Check the original when the exact wording matters.

¢\
~pmm

a conics company

 
  
 
 
  

 

Our Ref: 7500 - 1002Rd.rd
Your Ref: 20071786 PMM Sunshine Coast Pty Ltd
ABN 36 062 986 553
Date: 24 September 2007 wwwrepmm.com.au
T +61 7 5436 7888
F +61 7 5493 6630
At: Daniel Smith E [email protected] Innovation Parkway
Kawana Waters
+ . (PO BOX 149 Wurtulla)
Chief Executive Officer Queensland Australia 4575
Noosa Shire Council
PO Box 141
TEWANTIN QLD 4565
Dear Sir / Madam

RE: DETACHED DWELLING
15 WHALE DRIVE, SUNSHINE BEACH
MIKE AND KAREN ROGERS

 

We refer to a request for additional information regarding the above development dated 04 June 2007.
We have been instructed by our clients, Mike and Karen Rogers, to respond to the matters raised in
that information request as follows. For your convenience we have used the same numbering as
Council's Information Request.

Amended plans have been provided and form part of this response. The new plan numbers are as
follows:

Drawing No's: 06/14 - 000PA (Site Plan)
06/14 - 001PA (Lower Ground & Ground Floor Plan)
06/14 — 002PA (First Floor & Roof Plan)
06/14 — 003PA (Etevations)
06/14 ~ Q04PA (Section AA)

Attachments: | Attachment A — Site Cover Comparison Photo.

GENERAL

1.0 Forward dimensioned site plan and floor plan with ail structures identified (Can you also
include a line showing the 8.0 metres above natural ground on the elevations - it appears that
some of the dwelling may be over the 8.0 metres height)

Applicants Response

A dimensioned site plan has been included with the revised drawings. The plan also includes sections
which indicate height of the proposed dwelling above natural ground level at different points across the
site. The proposed design does not exceed the 8.0m height limit at any point.

urban designers town planners land surveyors

 
Full text of the other 9 pages

Page 2

Page 2

2.0 Revised plans showing a greater setback from the frontage. it is noted that the

neighbouring dwellings do have single story garages located within the setback area. However,
this proposal is vastly different in that a 2-storey building will occupy most of the frontage area.
This does not conform to the existing development in the vicinity.

Applicants Response

The proposed plans have been amended to reflect a greater setback to the front boundary. Apart from
the garage, the main building line has been moved back to a minimum of 4.5m from the boundary. The
fist floor plan shows those elements of the front elevation encroaching upon the 6m setback
requirement. The stepped design in conjunction with the orientation of the building in general mean
that the portion the front fagade encroaching upon the setback is limited to the corners of the dressing
room, stairwell and outside shower area, as well as the adjoining areas at ground level. Importantly,
the portion of the main building line between the 6m and 4.5 m setback is limited to less tan 50% of the
total front elevation mass.

Apart from the above, a greater level of articulation, including changes in materials, has been included
to the front elevation. Lightweight materials in the form of cladding and vertical timber slats help to
reduce the overall massing effect when viewed from the street level.

In conclusion, whilst it is agreed that the majority of setback encroachments within the street are limited
to garage structures, the impact of some these structures is no less obtrusive than that of the proposed
dwelling. A review of the aerial photo at Attachment A shows the number of these garage structures
that have been constructed almost to the front boundaries of lots. Furthermore, several of these
structures are higher than a typical 1 storey garage with some structures at a similar scale to the main
elevation of the proposed building. It is suggested that the combination of almost zero setbacks and
double storey design of these garage structures within the street has a comparable impact to the
proposed dwelling and garage.

3.0 The fence and retaining walls adjacent to the garage appear to be over the 2.0 metre
maximum required height. Forward revised plans or justify the concession required.

Applicants Response
A built to boundary wall meeting the requirement of the QDC forms part of the garage on the north-
western elevation. No fencing is indicated on the boundary either forward or rear of this wall.

4.0 Please indicate how the building will achieve the Specific Outcome in relation to height and
number of storeys. Noosa Plan - Building Works Code Table 14.41. Specific Outcomes 06.
Further section plans are needed to satisfy Council that the building is not 3-stories.

Applicants Response

The proposed design is a maximum of 2 storeys and 8m in height at any point on the elevation.
Sections BB to FF on the revised plans indicate the maximum height of the building as it steps down
the slope from front to rear. The bulk of the structure is well below the maximum height limit.

Section AA clearly indicates that the building at no point exceeds the 2 storey maximum. The portion of
the basement protruding in excess of 1m above natural ground level is located aft of the first floor

Page 3

Page 3

roofed area. The proposal therefore achieves the acceptable solutions in relation to height and number
of storeys.

5.0 Please indicate how the building will achieve the Specific Outcome in relation to site cover.
Noosa Plan - Building Works Code Table 14.41. Specific Outcomes 08.

Applicants Response

The site plan included on new drawing 06/14-000PA indicates the area calculated as site cover to be
46.7%. This is in excess of the prescriptive requirement for a 2 storey building which stipulates a
maximum of 40%. It is suggested that the proposal meets the performance criteria based on the
following:

> The design of the dwelling incorporates a high level of articulation therefore avoiding massing
issues which is a key intention of limiting site coverage. The proposal will not present an
appearance of bulk to roads as the majority of the building will be located below road level as
is the case with all buildings on this western side of Whale Drive. Impact on adjoining
properties will likewise be in keeping with the impacts experienced by all properties within the
area. Attachment 4 gives an indication of the typical coverage and setbacks of houses within
the street.

> The topography of the site means that a large proportion of the building mass is not viewable
from the street level. Likewise, the increased site coverage will not have a discernable impact
on the adjoining properties with the overall building length and height comparable to the
adjoining buildings (see context plan included in original application and Attachment A
included with this RF! response).

> Landscaping, including retention of existing shrubs at the front of the site, will help to soften
any potential massing issues.

> Attachment A shows a comparison of site cover on buildings within the street and the area in
general. The photo clearly indicates many developments with site coverage in excess of 40%.
All of these buildings are 2 storeys with those to the east of the subject site in particular
exhibiting coverage well in excess of the maximum allowable. It should also be noted that the
elevation of these particular dwellings results in massing issues far in excess of the dwellings
on the western side of Whale Drive where developments slope down from street level.

> The topography of the site means that outdoor recreation areas located at ground level are
limited. There is however a large potion of the site given over to the conservation area at the
rear of the property and furthermore the design of the house allows for generous out door
areas on all levels. Given the constraints of the site, itis suggested that the proposed design
allows for more than adequate outdoor recreation areas.

> Vehicular access and stormwater management are not affected by the proposed variation to
minimum site coverage requirements.

Page 4

Page 4

6.0 Please provide justification on how the proposal will comply with Specific Outcome 12 of
the Detached House Code in respect to Roof Form.

Applicants Response

The amended roof forms comply with the acceptable solution $12.1 in that pitches are less than 5
degrees and roof overhangs are a minimum of 600mm in length. It should also be noted that many of
the houses within the street and surrounding area do not conform to these roofing requirements
including recently constructed dwellings to the south of the subject site.

7.0 Please indicate how the building will comply with part 3.7 of the BCA (Building code of
Australia) - in particular for the external stairs.

Applicants Response
The revised drawings indicate the external staircase within 1m of the side boundary as fire rated

masonry construction. All structures within 900mm of the side boundary, including the built to boundary
wall, will be fire rated.

8.0 The dwelling appears to be located within the easement and within the zone of influence of
the council sewer. The plans will have to be amended to meet compliance. (Please note that this
cannot be accurately ascertained without dimensions on the site plan)

Applicants Response
The amended drawings include a site plan that indicates the location of both the conservation

easement and Council's sewer line at the rear of the property. The proposed dwelling is shown located
away from both of these constraints.

The above constitutes the response to the Information Request pursuant to the IPA and the Notification
Stage shall commence forthwith.

Thank you for your prompt assistance and please do not hesitate to contact our office should you
require any further information.

Yours faithfully
Rick Day
Senior Planner

Page 5

 

 

 

25 125 0

 

25 50

Scale 1: 1250 @ A3

75 100

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Project Client:
Whale Beach Dwelling House Thomas De Cruz Architects
Level Datum: Scale E ded C P|
xtended Context Plan ;

IMPORTANT NOTE aa 1:1250 @ A3 a conics company
bates townhenoe bn dey be patent of Nard Resores an] OO! Dale 21-09-2007 Whale Drive, Sunshine Beach Ww coma: 07 96 788
Water, Queensiand 2004 which gives no warranty in relabon to the data (including accuracy, 5 F 075493.6630 E: [email protected] au
rokabty, completeness or sutabity) and accepts no abity (inducing witout imtaon, urveyed PO Box 149 Wurtula Old 4575
lability in negigence| for any loss, damage or costs (induding consequential damage) Comp by: BH Parish. Weyba Job Ref: 1 Innovation Parkway Kawana Waters Old 45755 Australia Pian No
relating to any use of the data FB | LB: DWG Name: 7500-01.dwg Local Authority: Noosa Shire Council 7500 PMM Sunshine Coast Ply Lid ACN 058 076 878 ABN 36 062 996 553 7500-01

 

 

 

 

Page 6

 

 

 

 

NOTES:

 

 

NO DIMENSIONS ARE TO BE SCALED

SITE COVERAGE CALCULATIONS To FROM THIS DRAWING. USE FIGURED

DIMENSIONS ONLY
ALL EXISTING DIMENSIONS. LEVELS,

 

DRAIN RUNS AND SITE CONDITIONS ARE

TO BE CHECKED PRIOR TO

CONSTRUCTION OR COMMENCEMENT
(OP DRAWINGS

SITE AREA 610m sq
_. SITE COVER (HATCH) 285m sq

 

 

ALL DISCREPANCIES OR OMISSIONS ARE
TO BE REPORTED TO THE ARCHITECT

 

TOTAL % COVER 46.7% SS y

INFORM THE ARCHITECTS BEFORE ANY
WORK STARTS IF THE DRAWINGS EXCEED

 

 

 

 

 

ss ! THE QUANTITIES IN ANY WAY
a THIS DRAWING IS COPYRIGHT. 00 NOT
SECTION BB RERODUCE WITHOUT WUTTEN
PERMISSION FROM THE AUTHOR

 

 

 

 

   

 

/

ve

 

 

 

& Seas

 

 

 

 

[is 7
rR EE
beet
J
L.
/
tm
,
[
|
|
|
{
|
|
|
!

|
/

i '

UY) wn nnn nw wenn enna h

ECTION CC

 

 

“
J a
/ ———
/ —
yo 1 ~~
i i ——
~
; am} a
~~
| a z
~— ~—
a t ~~ i ~
a ~
' ae ~

8790

 

 

 

4--- SECTION DD' Pe g

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

—
g +
8 ! ~
~y
:
g rs f
ae se - — ~
“—— SECTION EE
~~ iw =
su \ onan
~~ sua t TE WHALE DRIVE, NOOSA,
—— _—— oer
se - ~~ ‘STE PLAN
. wn. Tran Rue o7
SITE PLAN “—— SECTION FF 67 ocr ™T jo
‘caer ATU teeramenen C)
von rimmce vercourmeene C1

 

 

 

 

 

Page 7

 

&

 

 

 

TERRACE

  

LOWER GROUND FLOOR PLAN

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

GROUND FLOOR PLAN

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

NOTES:

 

NO DIMENSIONS ARE TO BE SCALED
FROM THIS DRAWING. USE FIGURED
DIMENSIONS ONLY

ALL EXISTING DIMENSIONS, LEVELS,

DRAIN RUNS AND SITE CONDITIONS ARE

‘TO BE CHECKED PRIOR TO

CONSTRUCTION OR COMMENCEMENT
HOP ORAWINGS

 

 

ALL DISCREPANCIES OR OMISSIONS ARE
JO BE REPORTED TO THE ARCHITECT

 

INFORM THE ARGHITECTS BEFORE ANY
WORK STARTS IF THE DRAWINGS EXCEED
THE QUANTITIES IN ANY WAY.

 

THIS DRAWING IS COPYRIGHT, OO NOT
REPRODUCE WITHOUT WRITTEN
PERMISSION FROM THE AUTHOR,

 

 

 

 

 

=

ta cam sa Rest
eapan sem ase
aga mmc en

 

ar

1S WHALE DRIVE, NOOSA

 

LOWER GROUND & GROUND FLOOR PLAN

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

t:100 AUG 07

06/14 - 001PA Oo
erm rrav vas meeananon

ome DD eeemerevcren O

 

 

 

 

 

Page 8

 

 

 

 

FIRST FLOOR PLAN

 

 

 

 

 

ROOF PLAN

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

NOTES:

 

NO DIMENSIONS ARE TO BE SCALED
FROM THIS DRAWING. USE FIGURED
DIMENSIONS ONLY

ALL EXISTING DIMENSIONS, LEVELS,
DRAIN RUNS AND SITE CONDITIONS ARE
‘TO BE CHECKED PRIOR TO.
CONSTRUCTION OR COMMENCEMENT
OF SHOP DRAWINGS

‘ALL DISCREPANCIES OR OMISSIONS ARE
TO BE REPORTED TO THE ARCHITECT

 

 

 

INFORM THE ARCHITECTS BEFORE ANY
WORK STARTS IF THE DRAWINGS EXCEED
THE QUANTITIES IN ANY WAY

THIS DRAWING IS COPYRIGHT. OO NOT
REPRODUCE WITHOUT WRITTEN
PERMISSION FROM THE AUTHOR,

 

 

 

 

 

 

8 =

nem con ats

 

ar
15 WHALE DRIVE, NOOSA

 

FIRST FLOOR & ROOF PLAN

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Page 9

 

 

 

 

 

NOTES:

 

       

NO DIMENSIONS ARE TO BE SCALED.
FROM THIS DRAWING. USE FIGURED
DIMENSIONS ONLY

ALL EXISTING DIMENSIONS, LEVELS.

ORAIN RUNS AND SITE CONDITIONS ARE

TO 8 CHECKED PRIOR TO

CONSTRUCTION OR COMMENCEMENT

| OF SHOP DRAWINGS

ALL DISCREPANCIES OR OMISSIONS ARE
TO BE REPORTED TO THE ARCHITECT

$2210

    

 

32.210,

42610.
#2610... -

 

INFORM THE ARCHITECTS BEFORE ANY
WORK STARTS IF THE DRAWINGS EXCEED.
THE QUANTITIES IN ANY WAY

$6890.
46.340.
$8.890._._. 1 THIS DRAWING IS COPYRIGHT. DO NOT
46.340. REPRODUCE WITHOUT WRITTEN
PEAMESSION FROM THE AUTHOR

 

 

 

 

           
 

   

43 100

Aes

42390

NORTH EAST ELEVATION

NGL ON BOUNDRY

8m HGT ON BOUNDRY
~—

a SOUTH WEST ELEVATION

32.210...

92.610.

 

 

46.890...
46.340...

 

 

 

 

 

WAS

43 100

ARR

 

 

NORTH WEST ELEVATION

8m HGT ON BOUNDRY_
—

_—

e210.

 

 

 

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

49610.

i, 66.890...

#46340... _

“42390 ao
FGL ON BOUNDRY
— Toe moe
Siro ouwa =T1o
aeons =
wares Ol ren conetmecrion OC)
SOUTH EAST ELEVATION

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Page 10

 

 

 

 

 

NOTES:

 

NO DIMENSIONS ARE TO BE SCALED
| FROM THIS DRAWING. USE FIGURED
| DIMENSIONS ONLY

‘ALL EXISTING DIMENSIONS, LEVELS,
DRAIN RUNS AND SITE CONDITIONS ARE
| ‘TO BE CHECKED PRIOR TO
CONSTRUCTION OR COMMENCEMENT
OF SHOP ORAWINGS.

ALL, DISCREPANCIES OR OMISSIONS ARE
TO BE REPORTED TO THE ARCHITECT

 

 

INFORM THE ARCHITECTS BEFORE ANY
WORK STARTS IF THE DRAWINGS EXCEED.
THE QUANTITIES IN ANY WAY

 

THIS DRAWING IS COPYRIGHT. 00 NOT
REPRODUCE WITHOUT WRITTEN,
PERMISSION FROM THE AUTHOR

 

 

 

 

~~ 8m HGT
~—~8o

  
 

 

 

           

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

~
a
——
~~
~
~
~~
—,
5145 >
~.
+ —~
~~

' ae
82.210, i ~~

| ti ~~

{ FIRST FLR i _~

! ~~

I ' —

1 eet ~~
42.610. ee ee a _— oe

. to . ~
t ~ 4 ~~
~~ a f —
GROUND FLR = —
= ~

46.890... —
46.340... —_

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

LOWER GROUND FLR

 

43 100

AR 390. -

 

t
1
'
t
1
'
t
‘
1
1
1
'
1
1
1
!

SECTION AA

 

 

 

 

 

SECTION AA
' = =
13108 ‘AUG 07
oes 047A, oO
1
cera —————

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Used in these records

About this file

File size
1.6 MB (small file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

07_0786 - Response to Information Request [As Published].pdf · 1.6 MB (small file)

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.