Original source · versioned page text
2021-12-01 Special Meeting Agenda
Text sections have not been matched to the original PDF pages. Use the original document to check page numbers.
SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA 1 DECEMBER 2021
Page 10 of 18
Attachment No.1 - Final Evaluation
NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL ighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
a
Conforming and Alternste Tenders Ory 2 2 a 4 s : 7 . ° » au a
Auntretien Business Wurnter (ABN) 76 169 336 725 40 AS 2 ee a7 120808 276 @ ose 26 33.600 G23 a6
Name of Tenderer (Respondent) DECC Erwtronmsental | Mazel Bene (Cid) Pry | Spraatinframuctare | Syrral ivtbastrecture
as per Respondent Oetails ASN rt uss Tey Lse | pepindiam) | TATA Group Phy iad
Date of Subentiaion (a: per VendorPane!) 28-0821 29-Ccb22 29-821 oe 26-Oct-22
(Buniness Registered Address (City/State Onty) Wiicrert, CLD | Rurtwigh Mande, CLD | Newenrtin, NEW Newecamcie, NEW Mion, CLD
tendered Price (Exc GST) $ Seonrmm)s aseessose|$ = raaeasnze | $ | Gmz7rSs| $B 434,10642
Tendered Price finctl GST) $ Samsers)$ = Famsnres | $ = Tesios) S$ «(sms S| (8277,sa806
Corrections /(Garifications (Exe! GST) + - | 6242.30 | $ $ * $ :
Conforming of Alternate: Contorreing: Conforming. Contoming AterareArproved Contorming
| Aiernate Price Adjustments (tx! GST) $ . $ $ $ . $ °
Price (Exci GST) After Corrections / Car®cations
itect's Aiternsta} $ Solem $ Geraies S$ = 718645R2E S$ =ENIITSE S| 64S IEEAD
Price Variance % from Lowest Price aa om 7. a 278
— a : De
[Price Variance from Medien $ .asreses 5 szazeas7 | $ - | as7eoes |) $ = 1,287,72826
Price Variance ‘% from Median 20.0% cd a om oN 1:
Steortiint (¥ /1M) vo Yo = ‘eo
PART A Mon price lemmas DECK Eevicementa) Mare® Bros (Qk) Pty Symal seme
+e Prvtet And Prete Prvcedian) Tene Group Poytad
/tvelustion Criterte Weighting (S) wegen ee enti mae reer meee Weer ee es Wein mee Wegent eee ed Wegener ete oe Wegener
Capetity and Lapenence 20% 2650 37.50 14.00 1400 19.00 ooC c.00 0.00 aoc 20 aco oop
Financial Capability ns 377 4s aa au am oo ooo 0.00 oc cD 200 oo
Resourcing & Personnel cad 720 a. as ss ans oop ooo 0.00 ogc c.00 0.00 oop
Methodology 20% 160 2750 14.50 20 19.00 ao e200 020 oop e200 oso oo
Management 3pterra 10% 920 7.78 a0 a0 70 ao e200 900 ao e200 oso ac
Contribution to Local foonceny x 4.00 428 4.00 400 400 ao e200 020 oo e200 oso ooo
Total Techical Score 7% Sed so37 susz soz esr o.00 020 2.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 apo
Normalived Technical Score (Tn) an as 57.00 am 7a.020
a Bee ‘Bros (Ok) Pty | Symal
PART bps sherent Pov ant Prete mete) | SEO Smprytet
Total Fees (Fe) = $496,125 See $7,34645828 $6, 709,277.58 SAAS 10842
Price Score a 13 108 12 os o ° o ° ° o c
\Normatised Price Score (Pr) m2 20 * _ ced o ° o ° ° o °
| Weighted Price Score (Pr) 287 30.00 736 2.70 me
‘Total Score of price and non price elements on 2643 55.76 no me
Ranking 3 2
The Auaraarcerd Pane! confirru the obove scorer and wwightings of thu evaluation and corfimu the evaluation has Seer conducted aamrdance wth thw Procurement Prabtty Pisn
Asemment Pare Poaition Tithe ‘Signature,
Evaluation Panel Chair & Asseamert Panel Member 2 Project Coordinator (i) a
Asveument Panel Member 2 ATC Willers Cormuttant (GR) %
Asserment Panel Member 3 Contracts and Project Superintendent |GB) a |
Aaseiment Panel Merber 4 Workplace Health and Safety Advisor [PA) x |
Asserment Panel Member 5 Eeveronmerttal Officer (Ft) zsSee the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalSearchable page text hides email addresses. Original files are unchanged and may show email addresses.