Original source · versioned page text
2016-09-12 General Committee Agenda
Text sections have not been matched to the original PDF pages. Use the original document to check page numbers.
ATTACHMENT 2
Page 10 of 19
Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet
. e \ { >) | L flea ge { z __@ :
Portion A - Road Reseal & Rehabilitation - Road Resurfaci ng
ContractNo: «1617 TOZD
PRICE
“Monee | F—-—-—F—F— +--+
Night Rate)
0 ' 2 » 0 8 7) n ~ %0
No. |NAME OF TENDERER (excl of GST) Unacete ve Pe Poo Gen Ver Good Econo
1 S38
3 [Stanley Macadam Pty Ltd LS The ratings
4 +0 (zero) = Unacceptable — a fail for that criteria and extreme risk
Bp + 20 (twenty) = Very Poor - the content of the submission for that criteria is of a low standard and high risk
6 PO Po + 40 (forty) = Poor - the content of the submission for that criteria is unimpressive and poses a moderate risk
* 60 (sixty) = Good — the content of the submission for that criteria is meritable and will need to be monitored if awarded
NON-CONFORMING TENDERS + 80 (eighty) = Very Good — the content of the submission for that criteria is of a high standard and advantageous
Cn Do not evaluate * 100 (one-hundred) = Exceptional — the content of the submission for that criteria is flawless / outstanding and most advantageous
De not evaluat
Once all the data is entered the resultant scores based on the price and non price elements are automatically calculated for you
Number of Tenders Evaluated = CL? _]
1 2 3
Evaluation Criteria werewrwe cn | in| “een [rns “owe | rn | “een
Resultant Resultant Resultant
weighting ghting weighting
Capabiliy & Resourcing | mm | oo |e | =
comnetpeincescency | om | 0 |» (oem) » [wm °
oe
Ca ee | 8
feamasawy it mt
cwormnesmeno | (em = |» | om |
Contoton otal eon oe
Total Technical Score 70% J 82.275 81525 8S
Normalised Technical Score (Tn) LO
PART 8 Pc een ee ee
Vo Allroad Surfaces tanley Macadam
Total Fees (Pc) 30% 8 4 570
Average Fees (Pav) $............cccceecee
Price Score 60
Normalised Price Score (Pn) 48
Weighted Price Score (Pw;
Total Score of price and non price
elements
OTHER DETAILS
Assesment panel member 1 Cameron Shields - A/Works Coordinator, Planning & Infrastructure
Assesment panel member 2 Steve Deschamp - Assistant Supervisor - Plant, Planning & Infrastrucutre The Contract Administrator confirms the above weightings
Assesment panel member 3 —_—- Matthew Sanderson - HR Officer - WH&Safety, Executive Office Contract Administrator's signature:
Assesment panel member 4 David Shing - Technial Officer - Coastal and Foreshores, Planning and Infrastructur
Assesment panel member 4 Allan Hull - Civil Operations Manager, Planning & Infrastructure
Page 10 of 19See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalSearchable page text hides email addresses. Original files are unchanged and may show email addresses.