2017-05-09 Services & Organisation Committee Agenda

SERVICES & ORGANISATION COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA   9 MAY 2017




                                                   Page 6 of 50

SERVICES & ORGANISATION COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA              9 MAY 2017

                                             Final Evaluation                      Attachment 1
       NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL _ Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
 [Gena tis       Phoctemnineronnoee
                  Cc
     Pee at |
      (Conforming Tenders Only) (excl of GST)
      1 [Concrete Skateparks Ptyitd 0S 380,995.00 |
      2
      3 [Convic Pty Lt      585,400.00 |
      ‘ ef
      6p
      7
      Bf
      5
      wp
       NON-CONFORMING TENDERS
                        th         >      3     4     5      ‘     ;     5      5     0
      |     amt = Momcnsioments, | Oye _| Pent Stte rors | comicryees PP
      fsoaene, track taco achievement | asx | sts | io | 2 | so | 2 | se | 0 | om | © | om | o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om |
      pathoscarterrrectdetwry | asx | sos | ase | ross | ise | ws | rss | 0 | om | © | om | o | om | o | om { o {om | o | om] o | om |
       watsy     ms ots fits | ote fas [ose [To | om | io [ow | io | om | io | om | io [om | io | om] io | om |
      peammaseey | fas | om | os [oss | as | oss | o | om | 0 | om | o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om |
      fevcmentasntinatuty | se | zs | os | 2 | os | + | os | o | om | © | om | o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om |
      fenibutontoroaitconomy | sx | atrs | one | 1 | aoe | oss | oo | 0 | om | 0 | om [0 | om | o [om | o [om] o | om | o | om |
      fetstecinatscore | sme as Tae   mmm me
                                                a

       rotal Fees (Pc) 50% $380,995 $487,171
         Fees (PAV) $.eenceeseerceeenseseeee $471,189
       ce Score             119    7
          Price Score (Pn)  100    81
         ted Price Score (Pw)
                                                a                    SC
                                                   and weightings of this evaluation
      |    Assesment PaneiMember2 | Project Officer (CE)
      |    Assesment PanelMembers | Safety Officer (PR)
      |    Assesment PaneiMembers | Procurement Advisor (AM) |
      [|   Assesment PaneiMemberS

 Sunshine Beach Skatepark Renewal Evaluation Workbook 26_04_2017 - WHS                    28/04/2017

                                                              Page 6 of 50