Skip to the record
Mmm.. taste the original NoosaWatch™

Council archive · source document

RFI - App A - Overriding Need Report · 132008.299.02

of 36

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

                                                                                                                             27



  Council Housing Issue                                          Applicant response
  The land is in the Medium Density Residential Zone.            This is acknowledged. However, the land already
                                                                 benefits from an existing lawful visitor hostel approval.
                                                                 The proposal is an intensification of an established use,
                                                                 not a new visitor use on an otherwise residential site.
  Noosa has a high need for permanent housing.                   This is accepted. However, the proposal does not
                                                                 remove existing permanent housing stock or convert
                                                                 permanent rental dwellings to visitor accommodation.
  Noosa has a high need for key worker accommodation.            This is accepted. However, refusal would not deliver key
                                                                 worker housing. The proposal may assist the broader
                                                                 workforce ecosystem by accommodating working
                                                                 holiday makers and independent travellers who seek or
                                                                 undertake work locally.
  The site may have theoretical residential redevelopment        Theoretical capacity should not be equated with
  potential.                                                     affordable or key worker housing delivery. Any likely
                                                                 redevelopment outcome would be a small number of
                                                                 high-value dwellings, not affordable or key worker
                                                                 accommodation.
  Visitor accommodation may compete with housing                 In this case, the existing lawful hostel use remains
  outcomes.                                                      regardless of the outcome of the change application.
                                                                 Refusal would not create housing; it would only prevent
                                                                 the proposed additional managed hostel capacity.
  Council is concerned about short-term accommodation            This proposal is materially different from unmanaged
  in residential zones.                                          whole-dwelling short-stay letting. It is a managed hostel
                                                                 with guest verification, house rules, a management plan
                                                                 and no complaint history.
Source: Housing context and historical-approval discussion is drawn from Noosa Shire Council’s Noosa Housing
Strategy 2022.[8] The residential feasibility discussion is applicant planning/feasibility context.
The applicant therefore submits that the housing issue does not weigh against the proposal in the manner suggested by
the information request. The proposal does not cause actual housing displacement. It does not prevent an approved
housing outcome. It does not convert permanent rental stock. It does not undermine an existing key worker housing
project.

By contrast, the proposal provides additional capacity within an existing lawful hostel operation that delivers a scarce
affordable accommodation product and supports the visitor economy and workforce ecosystem. That outcome is
materially different from the unmanaged short-stay accommodation model that has contributed to broader housing and
amenity concerns.

The correct planning balance is therefore not “visitor beds versus affordable housing”. The correct balance is whether
an existing lawful hostel can be modestly and responsibly intensified to meet a demonstrated accommodation, tourism
and workforce need, while maintaining residential amenity and without removing permanent housing stock.

                                            Prepared for Council information response

Used in these records

About this file

File size
1.1 MB (small file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

RFI - App A - Overriding Need Report.pdf · 1.1 MB (small file)

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.