Council archive · source document
RFI - App A - Overriding Need Report · 132008.299.02
28
The applicant submits that it can.
12. Response to the overdevelopment assertion
Council has stated that the combined accommodation of 102 persons across the existing development at 14 Duke
Street and Lot 3 on SP228958 is considered an overdevelopment.
The applicant respectfully submits that the proposal should not be characterised as overdevelopment by reference to
the total occupancy number alone. In a hostel context, intensity must be assessed having regard to the nature of the
approved use, the operational model, the existing lawful approval, the accommodation product, the management
controls, the transport profile, amenity performance, market need and whether the proposal results in actual housing
displacement.
The proposal is not equivalent to 102 persons in conventional apartments, unmanaged short-stay houses or permanent
dwellings. It is a managed visitor hostel operation with shared facilities, guest rules, check-in procedures, management
oversight, low private-car reliance and a long operational history.
The existing use is also already lawfully established. The application does not seek to introduce a new visitor
accommodation use into an otherwise residential site. It seeks approval for a modest intensification of an existing
Visitor Accommodation Type 4 – Visitor Hostel use.
The proposed additional 42 beds represent approximately 8.2% of the existing Noosa hostel bed supply of
approximately 510 beds. In market-supply terms, that is a modest increase. The operator’s Dolphin-specific evidence
also demonstrates that the business reaches functional capacity during the primary visitor season, with operator data
indicating approximately 97% to 100% occupancy between October and March. The operator also records peak-period
waiting lists of up to approximately 60 persons for Dolphin Beach House alone. The proposed additional 42 beds would
not fully absorb that Dolphin-specific peak-period unmet demand.
The intensity is also materially moderated by the operational and transport profile. The operator advises that
approximately 75% of guests use local transport and approximately 25% have cars, with e-bikes and active transport
also used. This means the proposed hostel intensity should not be assessed as though it generates the same car
ownership, parking demand or traffic profile as conventional dwellings or apartments.
The proposal is also supported by the operator’s management framework. The operator advises that it maintains strict
management controls, guest identification and passport verification procedures for international travellers, a
management plan, house rules, and a low-impact beach, nature, yoga and surfing market position. The operator also
advises that the business has operated for approximately 25 to 30 years with no complaint history.
These matters are directly relevant to the overdevelopment question. A proposal may involve a relatively high number of
persons but still be acceptable if the use is designed and operated in a way that manages amenity, transport, behaviour,
waste, noise and operational impacts. Conversely, a lower occupancy unmanaged short-stay use may create greater
residential amenity impacts if not properly managed. The assessment should therefore focus on actual impact and
management, not only the numerical occupancy figure.
Prepared for Council information response
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
RFI - App A - Overriding Need Report.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 1.1 MB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.