Council archive · source document
Attachment 16- Amended Stormwater Management Plan MCU12/0208
Plans and drawings: the text below has words only, no drawings.
It is proposed to combine a detention function within several bio-retention devices. Whilst it is claimed that more information about these devices will be provided at the detailed design phase, the main concerns with this approach is the viability of combining detention with bio-retention where vegetation could be drowned by prolonged periods of rainfall. The use of bio-retention within detention basins is standard practice. The extended detention zone will not be different to that of bio-retention basins, and the area will be planted with suitable plants that can tolerate prolonged periods of ponding. Only the bio-retention zone within the basin will experience prolonged periods of ponding. The remainder of the basin will be located at a higher level and function similar to a traditional detention basin. The outlets of the basins will be suitably sized using a program such as XP-SWMM to show that sufficient attenuation of peak flows can be provided for all storm events. The bio-retention extended detention zone will be assumed to be full, as antecedent rainfall may fill this storage volume prior to the peak storm event occurring. The Healthy Waterways MUSIC Modelling Guidelines (2010) state that when bio-retention is incorporated into the base of a retarding basin, that the volume above the top of the extended detention depth should not be included in the model for water quality assessment. Flood storage was not included in the stormwater quality modelling. BCC practice notes for bio-retention basins also state that they can be incorporated into retarding basins. Off-line detention basins have only been proposed for catchments E3, F7 and F8. These are the catchments that drain directly to Eenie Creek and its tributaries. The other catchments that drain to Keyser Creek or Eenie Creek will have “on-line” attenuation of peak flows for all storm events provided by the proposed culvert crossings. The results of this assessment are summarised in Section 8.2 and Appendix G of the Flood Study (Cardno, September 2013). Refer to comparison points Q3, Q5 and EC4 in Table G3 to compare the existing and developed case peak flows. The flood modelling that was conducted for the developed case assumed that all of the site had developed case inflows (i.e. increased due to the greater impervious areas), except for catchments E3, F7 and F8, as these flows will be reduced to existing case levels by the proposed detention basins. The details of these basins will be determined at the detailed design stage. Although Precinct H drains to a point in Keyser Creek downstream of the proposed culvert crossings, the over-attenuation provided by these crossings is sufficient to ensure that peak flows are not increased. It should be noted that the attenuation that will be provided by the bio-retention basins and rainwater tanks has not been included in the flooding analysis. These will provide some additional attenuation, particularly for the minor storm events. Therefore the developed case peak flows that have been modelled are a conservative assumption. Appropriate erosion and scour control measures will be required on all outlets and culvert crossings. Lake Weyba Water Quality Objectives (WQOs) are provided and it‘s further mentioned that Healthy Waterways undertakes regular monitoring under an Ecosystem Health Monitoring Program. It is further claimed in relation to this that MUSIC modelling (for the WSUD) background concentrations can be higher in some instances than the WQOs (eg background Total P concentration in bio- retention systems is assumed to be 130 g/L, >WQO concentration) and therefore concentration based WQOs cannot be determined through MUSIC modelling. From this, the consultant recommends that the results from water quality monitoring carried out by the Healthy Waterways be used to determine whether there is an impact from the development. Whilst these results can be used, the applicant will need to be responsible by implementing an appropriately tailored water monitoring program as the Healthy Waterways monitoring may not suit the specifics of the proposal and cannot be relied on to continue for the life of the development especially where a State Government could either halt or reduce funding for such programs. Section 5.3 addresses this item. A monitoring program has been proposed for the site so that the existing water quality parameters can be defined, and the effectiveness of the proposed stormwater treatment devices can be established. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd 13 September 2013 O:\5101-19-03\wp\R3v4 SMP\Appendices\App G - RFI responses.docx Page 2
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
Attachment 16- Amended Stormwater Management Plan MCU12/0208Related documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 10.0 MB (large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
Log in to download the original file
The download may take up to a minute.