2017-08-14 General Committee Agenda

Page 19 of 31

NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
[cence                       Fics ct rusicnenseacesansamenities Groves

          INAME OF TENDERER                PRICE
          (Conforming Tenders Onty)       (excl of GST)
         1
         2
         3
         4
         5
         6
         7 [MMSGroup P/E
         8
         oC rrrrrrrr™r™.OOOOOCOCOCOCSCSdSC
         OEE
         a
         wate
         3 TTTdOOCOCSCSC*S
         “«fTTrrrrtrtrti‘“TOOOOOOOOOOOCOCOCOCOCOC*sdSCSSCSC‘“‘CSNNC#CNC#”
         sof]
         Mp
         vfOOOCOCSCSCSSSC*dSCSSSSCSSSSCSSSCsS
         gO
         sfrrrrrt™~—“—TTTTOOTTTOOOOTCOCOCOCOCOCSYSSSSOCOSOSOSCSCSCSCSCSCSC*S
        mp
        a                              OSs
        2d
        3              EEE       OEE    OEE
        a
          NON-CONFORMING TENDERS

                                             1         2          3         4         5s         6         ?         8         s
                                        FRM Rieaning Servic   Harvernt PAL otal CMBI Fact) lak iylia              vy Gls Clean
          |        ARTA: Nompriesements. |  nn    |ECOMSEA/L tes Ecovic Laicsne wintenance-|_ Services P/t | The Cleaning Crew | Mt Thclena h/t | amescroupen |" TEC p, | |
          pommowe           | wees | om frame] om fom] om ose] [Se |                  [| Sel =             (| - (Eel          (|
         lchecement         |         | 3s | nae | seses | rar | aan | 97 | r4oms | sser | raves | sea6 | 907s | 2o0r | o993 | a573 | x33 | 249 | 0 | 000 |
          Comtract Experience, Track Record and

          Peennasetry        |   tee   | wm | to | ors | ae | os | oe | oes | se | os | se | mm | sso | oo | a0 | io | a | 0 | om |
          Emironment&sustainabanty | som || so | om | ae | om | es |        | as | so | oso | so | 2s | os [ars | os | 22s | io | om |
         Kontitutiontotecattconomy | asm | atzs | aco | so | ss00 | tas | aso | vias | ae | 25 | s2s | sm | 1500 | as | sas | as | sas | o | om |
         feetvecnictscore Tm]                  Tews || ee Tee                                                             |   om

                                                             tlh ie
             Fees (Pc)                                $189,796  $150,060   $269,997                      $378,074  $1,564,000
          Average FeOS (PAV) S—...eeecremerremeen
          Price Score                   meee ee
          permatoed Pic Score Pa)  Pe                              se se                       css     ew         es          tt

Patent                                           tte                         The Contract Administrtor confirms the ebove scares
          |__ Contract Administrator & Assesment PaneiMembert | Parks and NaturalAreas Coordinator (SC) _—_—| Gad weightings of this evalsation
  | Assesment PaneiMember2             |       Technical Officer (MM)
         |        Assesment PaneiMember3 | Workplace Health & Safety Advisor (MS orPR) | Contract Administrator's signature:
  | Assesment PanciMembers             | Consulting Procurement & Contracts Advisor (AH) _|
                                                                                                                              Page 19 of 31