2017-08-14 General Committee Agenda

Page 20 of 31

NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL                   Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation

                   NAME OF TENDERER                                                  PRICE
                   (Conforming Tenders Only)                                      (excl of GST)
                1 [B&M Kleaning Services P/ L
                2  [Ecovist P/Lt/as Ecovia
                3  |Harvent P/Lt/as Total Buildmg Maintenance - Qid
                4  [CMBM Facility Services P/L
                5S [MMS Group P/L
                6  [2 Wog Girls Cleaning P/L
                Tf
                ST
                a CO
                MOP
                Md
                V2
                M3
                SF
                 i
                a
                V7
                WS
                SF a
                20
                2a
                22
                23
                oS
                   NON-CONFORMING TENDERS

                                                                                        1                    2                    3                    4                   5                   6                   7                   8                   9
                                                  5                           E&M Kleaning Services     -             . | Harvent P’Lt/as Tota   CMBM Facility                          W og Girls Ceaning
                                    PARTA~- Non p     Jement                            -          Ezovist P/Lt/as Eee     a       -                  -            MMS Gr      F/L
                                              abies cecal                             P/L            “         “soe Building Maintenance          Services P/L             ee                 PL
                                                                                         Resultant            Resultant            Resultant            Resultant           Resultant           Resultant           Resultant           Resultant             Resultant
                   Evaluation Criteria                       Weighting (%)                 score x              score x              score x              score x             score x             score x             score x             score x             score x
                                                                                          weightin;              ‘ightin;           weightin;            weightin;           weightin;           weightin;           weightin;           weightin;           weightin;

                   Achievement
                 foo                                   ee Pte Te                                               a0 Toe Paso Pte                       fase Pt Paso Pe | vm |e Tom To fom To | oe
                      omnacom                 |e fp [pte p«fsps>= [== [spe pele [wl po

                                    aaa               ae                                                                                                                                                          es
Pan                                           Prectement                                          [Revie Pts Revie ing Maitenance| “Sonne                      | MMSGowPL [TEU UME
                                      PARTB- Pr:    Jement                                         Eeovist P/Lt/as Fe                                               MMS Group P/L
                                 —                                                    PL              “~       Os  0N8 V Building Maintenance     Services P/L               =                PL
                  Total Fees (Pc)                                 50%               $140,000              $259,926             $341,900             $567,357           $639,707            $2,274,000
                   Average Fees (Pav) S....0..0..20000000ceee   $703,815
                   mss                                                        ee a                                                                                                    eee
                 perma       Pe or)                                           wee ee                                                                                                  ed                              dd
                   wet en)

                                                                                                                                                         The Contract Administrator confirms the above scores
                         Contract Administrator & Assesment Panel Member 1            Parks and Natural Areas Coordinator (SC)                                   and weightings of this evaluation
                                    Assesment Panel Member 2                                  Technical Officer (MH)
                                    Assesment Panel Member 3                        Workplace Health & Safety Advisor (MS or PR)                              Contract Administrator's signature:                     Parks and Natural Areas Coordinator (SC)
                                    Assesment Panel Member 4                      Consulting Procurement & Contracts Advisor (AH)