2019-10-08 Services & Organisation Committee Agenda

SERVICES & ORGANISATION COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA   8 OCTOBER 2019




                                                      Page 53 of 69

Final Evaluation SP1 Carpark
       NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL _ Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
               ee
         SL
      INAME OF TENDERER          PRICE
      (Conforming Tenders Only) (excl of GST)
     1
     2
     3
     4
      NON-CONFORMING TENDERS
      a) CS
                                  i        2        3        4       5       6       7       8       9       10
                                           Resultant score Resultant score ‘slant            pata
                                             eS      cee      weight!         gh      eigt    weighti:         st
      eoatinyaeourcing | tem | mf cw |    [om |    | sm |   | so [ o {om [ o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om |
     fomaemmencn      | |» [em [ = ||» [ent «|[m[efeml«|[eml[ fm] elm] [om] = | om
      pemee       Pm pem fp               pm pe pm pm fm fe fem |e pmtefm[»fm> elm]. lo,
      omy          mw fle |               | as [om | as | so | a | 0 | om | io | om | o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om |
      joemy Pm fe fo fw fm pew fa fe fe fom fe fom fe fom fe fom | o fom] o | ww |
      mommy          | =f» fe fm)» fw) »fw]efem, fmf elm] » fm elem]. |,
     foeamwnaemem    | mf fe= |= |) =|m{elm|>fm{+lm[efm[«lm|-[m|-]om
      featteciatscore | ome  |   tee | sose        sess     vas | omc                         mlm
            tomar                                                    a a
                a
      Total Fees (Pc)            $339,069 $351,858 $356,156 $466,138 $0      so             $0       $0
      [Average Fees (Pav) $..scsssusseusssnseee
      Price Score                 110     107      106       7       0       0               °       0
      Normalised Price Score (Pn) 100     97        96       70      0       0               oO      o
      Weighted Price Score (Pw)
          Ta   pe tn pe                                          a

          Evaluation Chair & Assesment Panel Member 1
      |____  Assesment PanelMember2 | Flexure Pty Ltd (external consultant) |
     | __    Assesment PanelMember3|Project Coordinator, Infrastructure Services |
     | _     Assesment Panel Member | Technical Officer ~ Capital Planning, Infrastructure Services _|
[Assesment PanelMemberS | WH&S Advisor, Executive Services |

[Mechanical Engineer Specialist [RPG Consulting Engineers Ptyttd
    1819T084 - Evaluation Workbook_Car Park