2019-10-08 Services & Organisation Committee Agenda

SERVICES & ORGANISATION COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA   8 OCTOBER 2019




                                                      Page 54 of 69

Final Evaluation SP2 Community House
          NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL _ Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation
              erie           ise cmmiyiose ae acre           |
[ewan                        femme CS
          INAME OF TENDERER                 PRICE
          (Conforming Tenders Only)       (excl of GST)
         1
        2
        3
        ‘4
          NON-CONFORMING TENDERS
                                             1          2           3          4         5         6         7         8          9         10
          a
                                                         Resultant score Resultant score ‘slant                         pata
                                                           eS        cee        weight!              gh        eigt      weighti              st
          somoanyaneroung   |   tome Tm | em | so | sm |           | so |     | vm | o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om | o | om |
         fomatmewsemy f= [= [w=[ = [=| ~|ue[s[=[~f=l>[~>e[o[-[=[e[ml> ||
         peomene —P m                       fm fp [ om ps [= fe lm fe peol?lmfe fms lm) elo] fo
         uy               me fw Pe fas Pm fase |                              foam To fom fo fiom fo fom fo fom | io fom | oo | om |
         power]                             fof fo fm fm fof fe fmfefm] fm] ef] = fem] fom
        foommasaammy        | =f» [|= |») |=,e[»[-fa[»[=>efm[«lm]e[o] ||
       fmameaewm             [fetes [~ [~~ )=>=[m>efeolefm[-p]>f=[>f=>o |w,
         ferttecnentsewre Pm                tee         as         sss        msec
                  ona  oa                                                               a
 [atacand Ren [incon [ncn Towommmee [TPT Td
          Total Fees (Pc)        40%       $2,569,328 $2,597,199  $2,676,418 $2,971,360 $0        $0                   $0        $0
          Average Fees (Pav) S.ccssseesssseesneees $2,703,576
          Price Score                       105         104        101         90        0         0                   0          0
          |Normalised Price Score (Pn)      100         99         96          86        0         0                   0          0
          Weighted Price Score (Pw)
               (na oreipaeenpaecene                                                                                                 or
              Evaluation Chair & Assesment Panel Member 1
         |_______ Assesment PanelMember2 | Flexure Pty td (external consultant) |
         |___     Assesment Panel Members| Project Coordinator, Infrastructure Services|
         |______ Assesment Panel Member | Technical Officer - Capital Planning, Infrastructure Services _|
          L____AssesmentPanelMemberS | WHS Advisor, Executive Services |

  [Mechanical Engineer Specialist]            RPG Consulting Engineers Ptyltd
       1819T084 - Evaluation Workbook_Community House