V6_edited 17.12.15_JC

Code Objective                  Developer’s Assessment          Objectors’ Assessment

                                                                suitable.” The Applicant furthermore
                                                                provides no justification for its
                                                                derived value of 30% other than it is
                                                                what will fit on the site given its
                                                                proposed configuration.

                                                                The design of the facility on the
                                                                Property as currently proposed clearly
                                                                is not suitable as the Applicant is
                                                                unable to comply with the planning
                                                                scheme and must be rejected.
BUIDLING WORKS CODE
O1 Buildings and other          S1.1 Complies                   Does not Comply
structures are appropriately    Setbacks comply with            The setbacks specified in Schedule 1
designed and sited to— a)       Schedule 1.                     address probable, but not definitively
provide amenity for users of                                    compliant solutions in the specific
the premises as well as                                         circumstances. Given the nature of
preserve the visual and                                         the proposed Development the
acoustic privacy of adjoining                                   Applicant has not demonstrated that
and nearby land uses;                                           structures are appropriately designed
                                                                and sited to preserve the visual and
                                                                acoustic privacy of the adjoining
                                                                School.


O18 Lighting associated with    S18.1- S18.3 Not Applicable     Does not Comply
the use or works does not                                       ‘where possible’ is insufficient, an
have an adverse impact          S18.4 Complies                  obfuscation, and furthermore an
upon the amenity enjoyed        All lighting will comply with   acknowledgement that it is not
by users of adjoining or        the relevant requirements       possible for the Applicant in its
nearby premises nor do it       where possible.                 current proposal to comply with
cause unreasonable                                              relevant requirements without
disturbance to local fauna.                                     qualification as required under the
                                                                planning scheme.
                                                                The Applicant has failed to show by
                                                                any reasonable objective justification
                                                                that Lighting associated with the use
                                                                or operation of the proposed
                                                                Development does not have an
                                                                adverse impact upon the amenity
                                                                enjoyed by users of the adjoining
                                                                School.




                                                                                                    20