Council archive · source document
RFI - App D - Liveit RFI Response · 132008.299.02
Reference #70250009-ENAC-LTR01-R1 LIVE IT ACOUSTICS ABN 74 161 234 626 33 Tombarra Street, Mooloolaba QLD 4557 1300 775 800 [email protected] Friday, 27 February 2026 Reference #70250009-ENAC-LTR01-R1 RFI Response This document provides Live It Acoustics’ formal response to the acoustic matters raised in Council’s Information Request 132008.299.02 dated 11 February 2026 relating to the proposed expansion of the Dolphin Backpackers accommodation at 14-16 Duke Street, Sunshine Beach. The original Noise Impact Assessment (Document Ref: 70250009-ENAC-RPT01-R1, dated 21 October 2025) has been updated (Document Ref: 70250009-ENAC-RPT01-R2, dated 24 February 2026) to incorporate the clarifications and additional modelling outlined in this response. Each Council item (Items 6-13) is addressed individually below: Item 6 Council Comment: The Report is based upon site architectural plans that differ to those submitted with the development application. Update the report to represent the plans upon which the application was made. Our Response: It is acknowledged that discrepancies exist between the drawings appended to Revision 1 of the Noise Impact Assessment and the final lodged architectural drawings. The Noise Impact Assessment has now been updated to reflect the architectural plans submitted with the development application. The acoustic model has been revised to incorporate the current building footprints and elevations, terrace configurations, setbacks and proposed locations of mechanical plant. Live It Acoustics Page 1
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 6 pages
Page 2
Reference #70250009-ENAC-LTR01-R1
Item 7
Council Comment:
Clarify how the ambient noise data obtained by the noise logger on the site was adjusted for
extraneous noise and as to whether this included insect noise and whether the measurement
equipment included a frequency analyser to permit assessment of insect noise contribution.
Our Response:
Unattended noise monitoring was undertaken using a Rion NL‑42 Class 2 sound level meter in
accordance with AS1055:2018. Periods affected by adverse meteorological conditions (wind
speeds > 5 m/s or rainfall > 0.3 mm/hr) were excluded. The logger recorded broadband
A‑weighted statistical descriptors only; one-third octave logging was not undertaken.
The dataset was reviewed graphically to identify anomalous events and potential insect-related
contributions. Periods not considered representative of the prevailing ambient environment were
manually excluded prior to deterring the Rating Background Levels (RBLs).
The adopted RBLs of 37 dBA (day), 35 dBA (evening) and 29 dBA (night) confirm a low ambient
environment. The measured night-time levels in particular do not indicate insect dominant
conditions that would influence the RBLs. Accordingly, frequency analysis was not required.
Item 8
Council Comment:
Clarify/provide the source and meteorological data used to exclude weather affected noise
measurements.
i. Clarify the location of the noise logger with respect to the adjacent concrete wall and
whether the equipment location was free field.
ii. In respect to noise criteria, include assessment in respect to Sleep Disturbance and the
LAmax parameter.
iii. Provide assessment of the cumulative noise impact of the development in regard to both
time varying noise and continuous noise.
Live It Acoustics Page 2
Page 3
Reference #70250009-ENAC-LTR01-R1
iv. The assessment of patron noise has been provided for the LAeq parameter only, include
assessment of the LAmax parameter also for outdoor areas that will be used in the 10pm
to 7am time period.
v. Justify the patron numbers used in the assessment as Table 7 indicates only 18 persons
spread over three outdoor areas whereas the proposal is for 48 persons. Provide revised
assessment with more realistic patron numbers in outdoor areas.
Our Response:
Meteorological data used to identify and exclude weather affected periods was obtained from the
Bureau of Meteorology (BOM) Tewantin Weather Station, being the nearest representative station
to the subject site.
Item 8 (i)
The noise logger was installed at a height of approximately 1.5 metres above ground level and
positioned to minimise the influence of reflective surfaces. The monitoring location is considered
generally representative of free-field conditions in accordance with AS1055:2018.
Item 8 (ii)
The revised Noise Impact Assessment includes a sleep disturbance assessment for relevant
night-time maximum noise events. Specifically, LAmax screening has been undertaken for:
• Car door closure events within the on-site car park; and
• Patron activity associated with the kitchen-adjoining area.
These sources represent the only applicable night-time maximum noise events associated with
the development.
Item 8 (iii)
Time-varying sources (e.g. patrons, intermittent car park activity) and continuous sources
(mechanical plant) have been assessed separately because they are characterised differently.
Mechanical plant is assessed as a continuous source against a background referenced criterion
(i.e. RBL + 0 dB limit), which is inherently conservative because it requires plant to remain
effectively at or below the prevailing background noise level to avoid intrusive impacts.
In contrast, patron activity and vehicle movements are intermittent and transient in nature. These
sources do not necessary operate continuously over the full assessment period and are more
appropriately assessed using background + 5 dB LAeq criteria.
Live It Acoustics Page 3
Page 4
Reference #70250009-ENAC-LTR01-R1
Combining continuous plant noise into a single “cumulative” scenario with intermittent activity can
be misleading and can artificially mask continuous plant audibility during quiet periods.
Accordingly, separating these noise categories is a more conservative and technically correct
assessment method.
Item 8 (iv)
The Operational Management Plan will adopt quiet hours from before 10:00pm and will
specifically prohibit guests congregating outdoors after this time, with outdoor areas subject to a
before 10:00pm curfew and BBQ / outdoor cooking ceasing prior to curfew.
On this basis, it is not reasonable or representative to assess outdoor patron LAmax impacts for
the BBQ / outdoor terrace areas during the 10pm-7am period, because those areas are not
intended to operate as social spaces during quiet hours. The revised assessment therefore
focuses on the only realistic residual activity which may occur during late hours, being the kitchen-
adjoining area (terrace).
Item 8 (v)
The proposed capacity of 48 persons refers to overall guest capacity, not the number of patrons
that can practically congregate within a small outdoor BBQ area and/or kitchen-adjoining area at
any one time. Assuming all 48 occupants are simultaneously outside in these areas is not a
realistic operating scenario due to:
1. Physical space limitations;
2. Typical hostel behavioural patterns which involve guests spending substantial periods
offsite during the day and evening for sightseeing, dining and social activities;
3. Occupancy being dispersed across bedrooms and other common areas when onsite;
and
4. Activity levels reducing significantly during late-night hours when the majority of guests
are resting or sleeping.
Accordingly, the assessment adopts patron numbers that reflect practical maximum occupancy
of the relevant outdoor areas, rather than an implausible “all guests outdoors” scenario.
Item 9
Council Comment:
Live It Acoustics Page 4
Page 5
Reference #70250009-ENAC-LTR01-R1 The Report did not consider amplified sound i.e. music in either indoor or outdoor areas. Provide assessment including amplified sound (music) in at least outdoor areas reflecting the common practice of use of Bluetooth speakers. Our Response: The Operational Management Plan will prohibit amplified sound and portable speakers on site. Notwithstanding this management control, the updated report includes a conservative scenario modelling a small portable Bluetooth speaker operating in the BBQ area to demonstrate compliance even under a non‑approved use scenario. Item 10 Council Comment: Provide assessment of noise from within accommodation rooms and how this complies with the relevant noise criteria and provide specifications for acoustic ratings of façade elements. Our Response: The accommodation rooms are shared dormitory-style rooms intended primarily for sleeping and not social use. Guests are expected to utilise communal areas for socialising and activity within bedrooms would generally be limited to brief conversations. In addition, even standard external wall and glazing constructions typically provide a reduction of sound through the façade in the order of 20-30 dBA. Any breakout noise from normal room use would therefore be negligible at the site boundary and well below the adopted assessment criteria. Item 11 Council Comment: Provide clarification of the adopted location of air‑conditioning units for the development on an elevation and how these are included in the noise model. Our Response: Live It Acoustics Page 5
Page 6
Reference #70250009-ENAC-LTR01-R1 The proposed air-conditioning units for the development are Mitsubishi Electric split system units (Model MSZ-AP35VGD, 3.5 kW cooling / 3.7 kW heating), with one unit proposed to service each accommodation room. The air-conditioning units are modelled at 0.5m above the finished floor level specified on the architectural drawings. Item 12 Council Comment: Assessment of carparking noise appears to only represent car movements, include assessment of carparking noise including car door closures, engine starts and people talking the carparking area. Our Response: The scale of the car park is small with only five spaces total, and therefore vehicle activity is inherently limited. Car door closure events within the car park have been assessed as part of the sleep disturbance (LAmax) assessment. Engine start events are comparable (but slightly lower) in noise level compared to door closures and are covered within the sleep disturbance assessment. Conversation between one or two people within the car park would be negligible. Any such activity would be brief, as guests/staff would typically park and immediately walk into the site rather than remain in the car park area. When averaged over the relevant assessment period, this contribution would be very low and minor compared to patron activity within the designated communal areas. Item 13 Council Comment: Assessment of service vehicles appears to only represent the noise of vehicle movements, include noise associated with loading/unloading and refuse collection. Our Response: Live It Acoustics Page 6
Page 7
Reference #70250009-ENAC-LTR01-R1 Refuse collection for the development will occur via standard kerbside collection. Waste bins will be moved to the kerb for collection and serviced in the same manner as surrounding residential properties. Therefore, waste servicing within the development will not introduce noise impacts beyond those already occurring within surrounding neighbourhood. In addition, there are no regular service vehicle requirements. All laundry is undertaken onsite, there is no onsite café requiring food deliveries, and cleaning supplies and minor consumables are transported by the onsite manager using a private vehicle. Conclusion The Noise Impact Assessment has been updated in response to Council’s Information Request and addresses the matters raised. On the basis of the revised assessment and provided the recommended mitigation measures are implemented in full, the proposed development is predicted to comply with the applicable noise criteria. Should you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact us. Yours faithfully, John Barker BEng (Mech) MIEAust MAAS Senior Acoustic Consultant Live It Acoustics 1300 775 800 Live It Acoustics Page 7
Used in these records
RFI - App D - Liveit RFI Response.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 184 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.