Skip to the record
The definitive source for everything Noosa Council.

Council archive · source document

App D - Legal Review · 132008.299.02

of 14

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

Check the original when the exact wording matters.

                                                                                                  5 August 2025




The Court has considered this distinction between the assessment framework for an impact
assessable development application and an Other Change application, finding that (emphasis
added):3

      [41] It was uncontroversial as between the appellants and corespondent that s 82 of the PA conferred a
      broad discretion on the responsible entity (or this court on appeal) to decide the change application as if
      it were impact assessable…

      [42] I agree the discretion to decide the change application is broad and, subject to contextual changes,
      is guided by, inter alia, relevant principles discussed in Ashvan Investments and Murphy. An important
      contextual change is identified in ss 82(2) and (4) of the PA. Both of these provisions include the phrase
      ‘in the context of the development approval’. The purpose of this phrase is to make clear that the
      assessment and decision making process occurs in the context that the application is one to change an
      existing development approval, as distinct from a fresh development application. In practical terms, this
      means the assessment and decision making process for a change application under s 82 of the PA is
      founded upon, but not limited to:

           a.   an identification of the change/s proposed to the development approval;
           b.   an identification of the planning issues, be they positive or negative, arising for consideration
                as a consequence of the change/s proposed to the development approval; and
           c.   an assessment of the planning issues arising as a consequence of the change/s to the
                development approval, having regard to the requirements of the ‘relevant provisions’, and
                assessment benchmarks, to the extent they are relevant.
       …

      [46] Whilst it can be accepted that the assessment process for a change application under s 82 of the PA
      involves more than a comparison of approved and amended plans, it is of little assistance to describe
      the assessment, in general terms, as broad or narrow. This is because the breadth of an assessment will
      be a product of the precise changes proposed to an approval, and the planning issues arising for
      consideration as a consequence of those changes. In some cases, the extent of change may require a
      broad assessment. In other cases, the extent of the change may require a more limited assessment. No
      hard and fast rule can be prescribed as a consequence. It will inevitably turn on the facts and
      circumstances of each case. Two points can however be made with certainty about the breadth of an
      assessment under s 82 of the PA.

      [47] Having regard to s 82 of the PA, it is clear the assessment process does not require the
      development, including the change, to be assessed as if it were a fresh development application. Nor
      does the exercise involve an assessment of the changes proposed in isolation, or out of context…”
      (footnotes omitted).

Therefore, while both an Other Change application and MCU application would require impact
assessment (including public notification) against the current version of the Noosa Plan 2020,
making an Other Change application is often advantageous due to the differences in the assessment
and decision-making framework.

Applying the above framework for Other Change applications, in relation to making such an
application for the Proposed Changes, we note:



3
 Catterall & Ors v Moreton Bay Regional Council & Anor [2020] QPEC 52; see also, Upan Company Pty Ltd v
Gold Coast City Council [2022] QCA 75.

                                                                                                         Page 10

Used in these records

About this file

File size
677 KB (small file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

App D - Legal Review.pdf · 677 KB (small file)

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.