Council archive · source document
App D - Legal Review · 132008.299.02
5 August 2025
We do not agree, nor consider there to be any support at law, for the position of Council as stated in
paragraph 6 of the PLM Notes, as follows:
‘The proposal in its current form triggers an Impact consistent development application.
Should the extent of works relate to a renovation to the existing building, the more
appropriate application pathway would be an Other Change. Should the works consist of a
full demolition and redevelopment, a material change of use application is the appropriate
pathway.’
As mentioned above, we have not formed a view on whether works to a renovate/extend of the
existing building on Lot 3 would require an Other Change application. There is no requirement for an
MCU application to be made, instead of an Other Change application, simply due to the scale of the
Proposed Changes. The Proposed Changes can be sought via an Other Change application to the
Approval, notwithstanding any resultant dramatic changes to built form or impacts of the
development as under the Approval. Although it may be Council’s preference for a MCU application
to be made to facilitate the Proposed Changes (for example, due to the differences in the
assessment framework when compared to an Other Change application), that does not mean a MCU
application is required.
OTHER RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS: assessment of Other Change application v. MCU application
By way of background, the Other Change application mechanism was introduced to the planning
regime with the commencement of the Act in 2017. Under previous regimes, the only mechanisms
available to change an approval were similar to that of a Minor Change application (e.g. a
‘permissible change’ under the Sustainable Planning Act 2009). The Act introduced a separate
process for change applications other than for a minor change which, relevantly, requires that Other
Change applications be assessed and decided ‘in the context of the development approval’. In
relation to this, the Explanatory Notes for the Planning Bill 2015 provide:
‘The intent of the reference to assessing and deciding the change application “in the context
of the development approval” is that the proposed change should not be considered in
isolation. Neither however is the entirety of the development including the change re-
assessed. Instead, it is intended the change be assessed with reference to the context of the
development approval already existing for the development.’
Before the introduction of the Other Change application mechanism under the Act, if a proponent
wished to make changes to an approved development, but a minor/permissible change application
(or similar) could not be made, for example because the changes would result in substantially
different development, there was no alternative mechanism to change the approval and a new
development application (such as a MCU application) would be required. In that case, while
assessment of any development application must be carried out having regard to any development
approval for the subject premises,2 such MCU applications were not assessed (and subjected to the
assessment provisions in effect at the time) only to the extent relevant to the proposed changes
from the development as previously approved (as is the case for Other Change applications).
2
For the Act, see the Planning Regulation 2017, ss 27 and 31.
Page 9
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
App D - Legal Review.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 677 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.