Council archive · source document
App D - Legal Review · 132008.299.02
5 August 2025
Assessment Frameworks – Minor Change Application v. Other Change Application
While a Minor Change Application and Other Change Application are both made under s 78 of the
Act, they differ in terms of application process, assessment framework and decision-making power.
For brevity, we provide the following simplistic overview/comparison between the change
application types:
• a Minor Change Application is not treated under the development assessment framework as
if it were a development application made under s 51 of the Act (for the development
including the proposed changes) – the application is administered, assessed and decided
under ss 77-81B of the Act, and the planning instruments that were in effect at the time of
the original development application are applied (though weight may be given to new or
amended instruments, if appropriate in the context of the proposed changes);
• an Other Change Application is effectively treated under the development assessment
framework as if it were a development application made under s 51 of the Act for the
development including the proposed changes (notably, meaning public notification of the
application is required in certain circumstances), though in the context of the Approval
(discussed further below) – relevant planning instruments that are in effect at the time of
the change application are applied, instead of the instruments that were in effect when the
development application was made (e.g. a new planning scheme, superseding the planning
scheme relevant to the approval).
APPLICATION OF LEGAL FRAMEWORK TO THE FACTS: appropriate application type for the
Proposed Changes
Minor Change application
Proposed Changes (as per Proposal Plans)
On a brief consideration of the matters listed in (b)(ii) of the minor change definition extracted
above, we do not consider these matters would apply as a result of the Proposed Changes. The issue
requiring further consideration would be whether the Proposed Changes would result in
substantially different development. To mount an argument that the Proposed Changes would not
result in substantially different development compared to the Approval, the matters in the above list
extracted from the Development Assessment Rules should be considered; we would suggest by
evidence substantiating that the Proposed Changes do not result in an adverse outcome in terms of
changes to built form and scale, impacts on visual and acoustic amenity, and traffic flow.
We expect it would be difficult to successfully argue that the Proposed Changes do not result in
substantially different development from that under the Approval, due to the increase in visitor
accommodation guests in proportion to the approved maximum, and (likely) associated material
differences in impacts of the visitor accommodation use. For example, we anticipate Council would
raise that the additional guest numbers would increase severity of acoustic amenity impacts,
resulting in substantially different development. Consistent with this suggestion, we note from the
PLM Notes that Council suggests that the proposal (as shown on the Proposal Plans) would need to
be ‘scaled back’ to be considered a minor change. While that is a matter of Council’s
position/opinion (and not a matter of fact or law), which we could consider further subject to
Page 6
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
App D - Legal Review.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 677 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.