Council archive · source document
App D - Legal Review · 132008.299.02
5 August 2025
receiving technical assessments1 of the effect of the Proposed Changes on the development as
approved, we consider on balance it is more likely than not that the Proposed Changes would not be
considered a minor change.
In these circumstances, and as we understand from our instructions that an Other Change
application would be palatable for you, we do not deliberate further on the prospect of seeking the
Proposed Changes through a Minor Change application.
Alternative change proposal (works to existing building)
As previously noted, you have suggested that it may be an option to seek alternative changes to the
development that involve renovating/extending the existing building to accommodate additional
guests (likely not as many as under the Proposed Changes), instead of a new building as shown on
the Proposal Plans. We understand Council referred to this as an option during the PLM, suggesting a
Minor Change application would be preferable to avoid the need for assessment against the Noosa
Plan 2020 (which would apply to an Other Change Application or MCU application). We understand
there may be some advantages in applying the Noosa Plan 2006 (v.1) to the change application,
however while we have not prepared a comparative assessment of the minimum carparking
requirements under each Planning Scheme, due to the existing site coverage we understand that
providing any further parking for additional guests (however many) would be at least difficult, if
practically possible. We understand Russell Green has advised you about this and additionally, that is
highly unlikely the existing building would be able to be updated to achieve compliance with the
National Construction Code requirements applying to Hostels (under Class 3), relating to fire safety.
Therefore, we have not considered this option further.
MCU Application
We refer to the definition of ‘material change of use’, extracted above.
In consideration of the Approval and the relevant use definitions from the Noosa Plan 2006 (above),
and your instructions about the proposal, we have formed the view that the Proposed Changes meet
the relevant definitions for the approved use of Visitor Accommodation (Type 4).
While not involving the start of a new use of the premises, the Proposed Changes would constitute a
material change of use if they result in a material increase in the intensity or scale of the Visitor
Accommodation (Type 4) use. This is arguable, and for similar reasons as noted above with respect
to the ‘substantially different development’ issue, the advice that follows is provided on the basis
that you are interested in an Other Change application, avoiding the need to argue this point either
way.
A MCU application seeking the Proposed Changes to the development would involve a fresh
assessment of the development as a whole (including that not proposed to be changed, on Lot 5)
against the Council’s Planning Scheme in effect at the time the application is properly made under s
51 of the Act.
1
Including evidence of the effect of the Proposed Changes as mentioned above.
Page 7
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
App D - Legal Review.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 677 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.