Council archive · source document
Attachment 13- Amended Flood Study MCU12/0208
Very large file (37.1 MB): the whole original can take several minutes to open, especially on a phone. Text is quick to read.
Original PDF page 126, section 1. The text section number identifies this passage in the reader.
HYDROLOGY AND FLOODING The following are the responses to SCRC RFI (DW008:MCU12/0208) received on the 28th of February 2013. Item 86 Issue For PMF events trafficability has been assumed if the depth is less than 400mm with a dV product of 0.45m2/s. Insufficient justification has been provided to confirm that this depth and dV product is acceptable for emergency vehicles to access the site. Section 7.2.1 of the Flood Study (Cardno, September 2013) addresses this item. During PMF events, access for emergency vehicles would be required. These vehicles are typically larger than standard vehicles and so can handle greater flow depths across roads. Based on Project 10 of Australian Rainfall and Runoff (AR&R): Appropriate Safety Criteria for Vehicles (2011), large 4WDs can cross roads with maximum depths of 500mm, with a limiting dV product of 0.6 m 2/s. Large passenger cars can cross roads with maximum depths of 400mm, with a limiting dV product of 0.45 m 2/s. For PMF events trafficability was therefore conservatively assumed if the depth was less than 400mm with a dV product of 0.45 m2/s. The Queensland Department of Community Safety was contacted regarding the trafficability criteria used for emergency vehicles. They advised that scenarios were assessed on a case by case basis and that a specific guideline was not used. However, it should be noted that the AR&R project references the Emergency Management Australia (EMA) manual for emergency vehicle 4WD operation that states that “if water reaches to the bumper bar or higher, upon entering the water accelerate until a bow wave forms in front of the vehicle. Maintain this bow wave at all costs, to keep water out of the engine.” In water depths of greater than 750mm, it is suggested that either a snorkel extension to the engine air inlet and exhaust system is fitted or a canvas sheet or tarp is placed across the grille to prevent water entering the engine bay.” For similar developments in Brisbane a maximum depth of 500mm and dV product of 0.6 m 2/s has been utilised to determine PMF trafficability for emergency vehicles. This is based on the Brisbane City Council (BCC) Subdivision and Development Guidelines (2008), Chapter 1 Part A which states that with flood depths less than 500mm and a dV product less than 0.6 m2/s, that evacuation of persons and possessions via trucks is possible and that fit adults can wade through floodwaters. Item 87 Issue A sensitivity analysis has been undertaken to determine the impact of culvert blockage. In accordance with QUDM; 20% blockage of the proposed culverts has been considered. 20% culvert blockage is considered suitable in situations where there is a relief overland flowpath which will function prior to houses being inundated. However, the proposed minimum road level of 4.00m AHD for the Northern Keyser Creek Crossing means that proposed floor levels on upstream lots will be inundated prior to any relief overland flowpath beginning to function. Section 8.4.3 of the Flood Study (Cardno, September April 2013) addresses this item. Since the original application was prepared, the location of the access road to the site has been relocated to the southern boundary. It has been offset from this boundary to minimise flood impacts to the neighbouring properties. This road crossing is now located upstream of Areas F and G, and so blockage of culverts would have minimal impact to these proposed lots. The results of the analysis showed that even with complete blockage of all proposed culverts that sufficient flood immunity is provided for all of the proposed lots. However, the increase upstream of the Keyser Creek crossing is significant, as the minimum road level (3.83 mAHD) had to be set high enough to maintain trafficability during a regional PMF event. This could potentially exacerbate existing flooding issues for some upstream properties. A range of blockage factors was trialled, to look at the potential impact at comparison points H0, H1, H2 and H3 which are located upstream of the site in Keyser Creek. The results are shown in the table below. Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd 13 September 2013 O:\5101-19-03\wp\R1v4 Flood Study\Appendices\App J - RFI responses.docx Page 1
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
Attachment 13- Amended Flood Study MCU12/0208Related documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 37.1 MB (very large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
Log in to download the original file
The download may take a few minutes. On mobile data, it is best to wait for Wi-Fi.