Council archive · source document
Attachment 13- Amended Flood Study MCU12/0208
Very large file (37.1 MB): the whole original can take several minutes to open, especially on a phone. Text is quick to read.
Original PDF page 127, section 1. The text section number identifies this passage in the reader.
Table 8.1 Sensitivity Analysis – Culvert Blockage
100 Year ARI Local Peak Water Level
(mAHD)
Comparison
Point Blockage Factor
0% 20% 50% 80% 100%
H0 3.72 3.72 3.72 3.72 4.09
H1 3.07 3.07 3.07 3.16 4.09
H2 2.62 2.62 2.62 3.11 4.09
H3 2.25 2.26 2.35 3.10 4.09
The results show that there is minimal impact upstream, even with 50 percent blockage of the culverts. If the
blockage factor is increased to 80 percent then there is a significant impact directly upstream of the culverts,
however, the impact is significantly reduced before it affects areas where there are existing properties (H0
and H1). It is only when there is 100 percent blockage of the culverts that upstream properties are
negatively impacted upon.
It is considered that this situation is extremely unlikely given the large size of the proposed culverts (flow
area totalling 32.4 m 2) and the low flow velocities in the area. However, in order to reduce the likelihood of
blockage it is proposed to install debris deflector walls on the culvert inlets for the southern crossing of
Keyser Creek. An example of debris deflector walls is shown in Figure 10.07 of QUDM (2007). The purpose
of the debris deflector walls is to allow built up debris to rise with the flood waters, allowing flows to pass
underneath.
Project 11 of AR&R: Blockage of Hydraulic Structures (2013) details the levels of blockage that should be
considered for culvert crossings. Table 3.16 summarises the proposed blockage values that should be used
for various types of culverts. For culverts with effective debris control measures, such as debris deflector
walls, the design blockage is 10 percent and the severe blockage amount is 25 percent. Given that even
with 80 percent blockage there is minimal impact to upstream properties, the provision of debris deflector
walls is considered to sufficiently reduce any increased flood risk to upstream properties resulting from the
proposed development.
Item 88
Issue
With respect to loss of floodplain storage it is stated in the Flood Study that the loss of flood storage
within the site is minor when compared to the surrounding floodplain and Lake Weyba. The
cumulative impact of all sites within the Noosa River and Lake Weyba floodplain being developed
with a loss of floodplain storage has however not been considered. In such a large catchment area it
is the cumulative impact rather than site specific impact of lost floodplain storage which is of
concern. In addressing this issue a revised Flood Study considering the cumulative impact of loss of
floodplain storage on other sites is not the intention because continued loss of floodplain storage is
not the Strategic Plan for either the former Noosa or Maroochy Council areas.
Section 9 of the Flood Study (Cardno, April 2013) addresses this item.
A cumulative flood assessment was conducted to look at the potential impact of filling in flood affected
residential areas, limited development areas and rural use areas that have been predominantly cleared
(similar to the area of filling proposed on site). The existing Noosa Airport and sportsgrounds on Weyba
Road were also filled. The 100 year ARI flood inundation extent was taken from SCRC mapping. The
volume of fill assessed was more than 14 times that proposed for the site.
The results showed that there was a negligible increase (maximum of 5mm) in regional flood levels as they
are dominated by the storm surge levels within the Noosa River. Filling of the low-lying areas around Noosa
River and Lake Weyba would have minimal impact on storm surge levels, which are expected to further
increase with the impact of climate change. However, filling to the extent modelled would not be achievable,
as it is likely that there would be impacts on local flood levels for neighbouring areas. Therefore the scenario
modelled is a conservative overestimation of the achievable fill within the catchment area.
Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd 13 September 2013
O:\5101-19-03\wp\R1v4 Flood Study\Appendices\App J - RFI responses.docx Page 2
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
Attachment 13- Amended Flood Study MCU12/0208Related documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 37.1 MB (very large file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.
Original file
Log in to download the original file
The download may take a few minutes. On mobile data, it is best to wait for Wi-Fi.