Skip to the record
For the highest quality transcripts.

Council archive · source document

Response to Further Advice · MCU22/0139

of 4

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

Date: 24 September 23


The Chief Executive Officer
Noosa Shire Council,
PO Box 141
Tewantin QLD 4565

Via Email ([email protected])

Attention: Samuel Osakwe

Dear Sir,

RE:         Response to Further Advice Letter relating to a Development Permit for Material Change of
            Use of Premises to establish a Dual Occupancy at 36 Elanda Street, Sunshine Beach (Council
            Reference: MCU22/0139)

I refer to Council’s Further Advice letter issued on 30 August 2023 in relation to the abovementioned
application.

Please see below a response to the items raised by Council.

Issue – Building Bulk and Scale

Acceptable outcome AO20.1 of the Medium Density Residential Zone Code requires building and structures to
avoid reduction of sunlight to the private open space areas of any adjoining residences to 40% or less than two
hours between 9:00am and 3:00pm on any day of the year. The Performance Outcome also requires
development to not unreasonably impact on the amenity including access to sunlight. Further, Performance
Outcome PO9 of the Medium Density Residential Zone Code regarding how development should not present
an appearance of bulk to adjacent properties.

Noting that the subject site is located at a higher elevation than adjoining parcels to the north and south (see
figures below), the proposed dwelling in its current form will be well over 9 metres at its highest point. The
proposal is likely to cause significant overshadowing to the private open space of these properties and the
application material has not addressed the anticipated visual impacts.

Advice Required

1.     Provide a survey plan of the site confirming the existing levels (AHD). The survey should include the
       location of adjoining dwellings and any windows within 10 metres of the boundary.

2.     Provide two sections (north – south) through the building to confirm the building height and finished
       levels in relation to existing natural ground and adjoining sites.

3.     Noting that Council will not support a proposal that unreasonably diminishes solar access of adjoining
       properties, provide a shadow diagram to demonstrate how the proposal will cast shadow during the
       winter and summer solstice.
Full text of the other 3 pages

Page 2

Response

In relation to Item 1, as acknowledge during our telephone conversation, Council is in receipt of a survey plan
for the property.

In relation to Item 2, please see attached amended architectural plans (Rev 6), which provide two
north/south sections that illustrate the building height and finished levels in relation to the existing natural
ground and adjoining sites. The proposed building is fully compliant with height and setback requirements.

In relation to Item 3, please see attached amended architectural plans (Rev 6), which include shadow
diagrams that demonstrate the building will not unreasonably diminish solar access to the adjoining
properties. Further, the proposal provides fully compliant height and setbacks and would be consistent with
the bulk and form for a dwelling house that could be established on the premises as ‘accepted
development’.



Issue – Setback

Acceptable Outcome AO12.1 of the Medium Density Residential Zone Code requires building and structures to
be setback a minimum of 6 metres from the frontage. Acceptable Outcome AO16 of the Medium Density
Residential Zone Code also require basements to not encroach into building setback areas.

The proposal appears to include structures approximately 3 metres high within the front setback. The
proposed basement also intrudes into the southern side boundary setback with the operational works plans
(not part of this application) detailing structural CFA piles in the setback areas.

Information Required

4.     Provide further plans that demonstrate the extent of structures within the front setback. The plans are to
       specifically detail the height of the stairs and surrounding retaining walls and fences and demonstrate
       that they do not impact on the amenity of the area.

5.     Provide revised plans that detail the basement outside of the side setback. All operational works plans
       are to demonstrate no permanent piling structures in the required setback areas.
Response

In relation to Item 4, please see attached amended architectural plans (Rev 6), which illustrate the extent of
structures in the front setback. The landscaped pathway has been redesigned to provide a softer
appearance and setback from the driveway. The only structure within the 6m setback will be the retaining
wall associated with the basement entry, which has a maximum height of approximately 1.5m above the
ground level and has been softened with landscaped plantings.
In relation to Item 5, the setback of the basement along the southeast side boundary has been increased to
750mm to its outermost projection as agreed during our telephone conversation. This would ensure that the
600mm strip of landscaping along the southeast side boundary was access to deep soils. The remainder of
the setback area comprises a pathway to the washing area and rear of the site and would not need a deep
soil below.


Issue – Roof Terrace

Acceptable Outcome AO19.2 of the Medium Density Zone Code requires developments to not include rooftop
terraces. Acceptable Outcome AO12.1 of the Medium Density Residential Zone Code also requires building and
structures to be setback a minimum of 2.5 metres where above 7.5 metres height. The architectural plan details

Page 3

the roof terrace with a pergola and trellis that exceeds 7.5 metres and with a non-compliant setback to the side
boundary.

Information Required

6.     Revise the architectural plans that details the rooftop terrace setback a minimum of 2.5 metres from the
       side boundaries.

7.     Provide screening that is a minimum of 1.7 metres high and setback from the edge of the rooftop to
       ensure no overlooking.

8.     Provide revised architectural plans that remove the pergola, trellis or any structure that will add to the
       bulk at the roof level.

Response

In relation to Item 6, please see attached amended architectural plans (Rev 6), which clearly illustrates that
the building fully complies with setback requirements.

In relation to Item 7, the amended architectural plans (Rev 6), clearly illustrate that the height of screening
devices at the edge of the rooftop will be 1.7m in height to obscure overlooking. This can be a condition of
approval.

In relation to Item 8, as discussed during our telephone conversation the pergola is an open and lightweight
timber structure that will not incorporate a roof. Consequently, it will not have a bulky appearance and its
purpose is to provide shade to the rooftop area. Further, the shade structure is consistent with the overall
outcomes of the Sustainable Building Design Code which include that:
(a)     Development is located, designed, constructed and operated in accordance with best sustainable
        design principles.
(d)     Development includes passive design elements to respond to the local climate.
(f)     buildings are designed and constructed to be energy and water efficient.


Issue – Operational Works

The response to Councils information request included an amended Form 1 that detailed a change to the
application to include Operational Works. As discussed, fees are applicable for these Operational Works and it
was requested that a separate application for Operational works be lodged.

Information Required

9.     Please confirm how you wish the Operational works application be processed noting that additional
       fees are required.

Response

A separate operational works application has since been made and paid for.

Page 4

Proceeding

This office trusts that the information supplied comprehensively addresses all of the issues relating to the
further advice letter. Should you have any further questions in relation to the proposal, please do not hesitate
to contact the undersigned on 0423 952 928 or via email at [email protected] sincerely,



Marcus Brennan
B. Urb. Reg. Plan.

Used in these records

About this file

File size
127 KB (small file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Response to Further Advice.pdf · 127 KB (small file)

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.