Council archive · source document
2013-05-09 Negotiated Decision Notice Request (MCU12-0133) · MCU12/0133
Attached to the e-mail Representations for Negotiated Decision Notice.
9 May 2013
The Chief Executive Officer
Sunshine Coast Regional Council
Locked Bag 72
Sunshine Coast Mail Centre QLD 4560
Attention: Mr Denis Wallace
By email: [email protected]
Dear Sir
– REQUEST FOR NEGOTIATED DECISION NOTICE –
DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR A MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE FOR EDUCATION TYPE 2 SCHOOL AT
2 GIRRAWEEN COURT, SUNSHINE BEACH (MCU12/0133)
On behalf of our client and the applicant, Trustees of the Christian Brothers (QLD) Pty Ltd, we hereby request
a Negotiated Decision Notice in accordance with section 361 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009.
A Development Permit for a Material Change of Use for a School (Education Type 2) was approved
(MCU12/0133) for the site at 2 Girraween Court, Sunshine Beach (Lot 3 on RP887636) on 20 March 2013 and
received by the applicant on 25 March 2013. The applicant’s appeal period was suspended on 15 April 2013
in accordance with sections 366 and 680 of the Act.
We note that a request for a Negotiated Adopted Infrastructure Charges Notice was lodged on 16 April 2013
in accordance with section 677 of the Act and is concurrently under assessment. The applicant’s appeal
period remains in suspension until the determination of both of these requests.
We have now considered the conditions of approval and request amendments as follows.
Condition 6(a) – Landscaping Strip at Frontage
This condition requires “a 10 metre wide landscaping strip along the Girraween court road frontage of the
subject site, exclusive of the access road only, uncompromised by infrastructure items” (emphasis added).
We agree with the general intent of this condition to retain an undisturbed vegetation strip at the site’s
frontage. However, we note that the wording of the condition allows only for the access road, yet the
approved plans show a pedestrian pathway through this area and some trenching for infrastructure
connections (e.g. water) will also be required. We have advice from Council that that the pedestrian path and
infrastructure connections should be acceptable; however, we wish to take this opportunity to clarify the
condition and prevent possible compliance issues in the future. Therefore, we request this condition to be
amended generally as follows:
6. The development site must be landscaped… and must include in particular:
(a) a 10 metre wide landscaping strip along the Girraween court road frontage of the
subject site, exclusive of the access road, pedestrian path and infrastructure
connections only, uncompromised by any other infrastructure items. Infrastructure
connections should be co-located wherever feasible, particularly with the access road
1/9 Camford Street, Milton e-mail: [email protected] Phone: (07) 3217 5771
[PO Box 2088, Milton BC Qld 4064] ABN: 4911 6492 123 Fax: (07) 3217 6292
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalFull text of the other 7 pages
Page 2
CRAVEN OVENDEN TOWN PLANNING PAGE 2
and pedestrian path, to minimise disturbance to this landscaping strip. Multiple
connection points should be avoided. …
Condition 17 & 18(d) – Access Driveway Surface Treatment
These conditions require the proposed access driveway to have a sealed surface treatment. However, to
accord with the strategy of the approved Stormwater Management Plan, which is to preserve the natural
hydrology of the site by minimising ground-level impervious surface, the applicant would like to construct the
access driveway using a permeable pavement surface. The driveway would need to be constructed to an
appropriate Council-endorsed standard in terms of vehicles per day or Equivalent Standard Axles, which can
be determined and conditioned at the Operational Works stage - we expect it would be designed to the
standard of Easement Road as Planning Scheme Policy 5 Engineering Design Standards – Roads, Drainage
And Earthworks.
Therefore we request wording of these two conditions generally in accordance with the following:
17. A sealed or permeable surface access driveway must be provided from Girraween Court to
all parking and manoeuvring areas of the development….
18. The works must be undertaken in accordance with an Operational Works approval and
must include in particular:
…
(d) a sealed or permeable surface driveway for the full length of the access to the
proposed internal boundary, including underground service conduits for the necessary
services.
Condition 20 – Service Vehicles
This condition requires the carpark to be designed and constructed to allow service vehicle access through the
carpark to the refuse enclosure to collect rubbish bins. This assumes the development requires industrial
sized bins and onsite collection, but this is not the case: the approved development does not require and will
not utilise industrial sized bins. Instead, domestic sized wheelie bins will be used and taken to the kerb for on
street collection. Therefore, service vehicle access to the refuse enclosure is not required. Nevertheless, the
access driveway connecting to the adjoining eastern lot will be designed and constructed to allow service
vehicle access to that adjoining lot.
As such, we request this condition to be amended generally as follows:
20. Service vehicle manoeuvring and access must be provided on the site for servicing the
adjoining lot to the east. The works must be undertaken in accordance with an
Operational Works approval and in particular must include area sufficient to allow a refuse
vehicle future access the adjoining lot to the east.
Condition 22 – Lawful Point of Discharge and Flood Detention
Condition 22 requires the site be provided with a formal stormwater drainage system connected to a lawful
point of discharge. While this is a relatively standard condition, the approved development intends a highly
efficient stormwater management system that manages all of its stormwater generation on site, without
generating any off site runoff. The development minimises the creation of ground level impervious surfaces
and utilises the naturally very high permeability of the site’s sandy soils, resulting in:
A net reduction in peak flow rates compared with the site’s current pre-developed state.
A net reduction in runoff volumes compared with the site’s current pre-developed state.
A net reduction in pollutants compared with the site’s current pre-developed state.
Because the development reduces natural stormwater runoff instead of increasing it, a lawful point of
discharge is achieved by allowing, in major storm events, excess runoff to drain to the kerb and channel
system via sheet flow, without need for a piped stormwater connection to Council’s drainage infrastructure.
Please refer to the attached memo for details.
Page 3
CRAVEN OVENDEN TOWN PLANNING PAGE 3
Furthermore, the analyses provided in the attached memo demonstrate that the sizing of flood detention in
the Stormwater Management Plan dated 8 August 2012 by Bligh Tanner Pty was conservative (it was derived
using the simplified method from QUDM2007 which is no longer supported in QUDM2013. The memo also
explains why the rational method lacks accuracy on highly pervious soils). It is now clear that the overall
strategy avoids any increase in peak flows, and so the condition in relation to flood detention is not
necessary.
Therefore, we request that this condition be amended as follows:
22. The site must be provided with a stormwater drainage system generally in accordance with
the Site Based Stormwater Management Plan dated 8 August 2012 by Bligh Tanner Pty
Ltd. The works must be undertaken in accordance with an Operational Works approval
and the Noosa Plan’s Water Sensitive Urban Design Code requirements.
Please consider our representations and if you require further information or clarification please do not
hesitate to contact our office on (07) 3217 5771.
Yours faithfully
Michael Edrich
CRAVEN OVENDEN TOWN PLANNING
Encl.
Page 4
MEMORANDUM
To: Fulton Trotter Level 9, 269 Wickham St
PO Box 612 Fortitude Valley
ATT: Mark Kalinowski QLD 4006, Australia
T +61 7 3251 8555
CC: Michael Edrich – Craven Ovenden F +61 7 3251 8599
Leon Rowlands – Sunshine Coast Council [email protected]
www.blightanner.com.au
Date: 8st May 2013 ABN 32 061 537 666
From: Alan Hoban
Pages: 5 in total.
RE: Noosa Flexi Learning Centre – Stormwater Runoff
SUMMARY
This memo provides further information to support the Site Based Stormwater Management Plan
for the Noosa Flexi Learning Centre (Bligh Tanner 8th August 2012). It further describes how the
site minimises ground-level impervious areas and seeks to mimic the pre-development hydrology
of the site. This memo has been prepared for the purposes of:
1. Demonstrating that the site does not need a formalised stormwater connection to the
street.
2. Demonstrating that the site has no effective impervious area for the purposes of
calculating Infrastructure Charges, based on Council’s definition.
APPLICATION STATUS
Please note that there is a current negotiated decision notice lodged in relation to this
development application.
DESCRIPTION OF STRATEGY
In order to avoid affecting the vegetation communities of the Girraween Nature Reserve through
increased wetness, the site seeks to avoid the generation of stormwater runoff by avoiding, to the
extent practicable, any ground level impervious areas. This is consistent with the low-impact
design intent of the site, and also plays a key role in reducing upfront and ongoing costs to the
school, and to Council, associated with the provision of stormwater infrastructure.
The occurrences and magnitude of surface runoff events from the site are reduced as a result of
the proposed strategy due to the detention and reuse of runoff.
In the rare occurrences when surface runoff is generated, it will discharge across the front
boundary of the site via overland flow to the existing kerb and channel, as it currently does,
without causing any nuisance conditions.
The site currently has high infiltration rates
Percolation testing on the site was carried out in September 2012 by Soil Surveys . The field test
method employed in this investigation, ie. Constant Head Test, was carried out in accordance
with AS1547-2000, Appendix 4.1F. At the test location, a 100mm diameter borehole was drilled to
a depth of 500mm. The test hole was then filled to a depth of 250mm, the well permeameter was
put in place and the test commenced. When the fall became constant, ie. 10% or less change
between successive readings, or flow eased, the test was completed. Readings were taken at 30
Page 5
Bligh Tanner Page 2 of 5
second intervals. At four locations across the site, saturated infiltration rates of 4.0, 4.2, 4.6 and
3.9 m/day were recorded, or an average rate of 170 mm/hr.
High infiltration rates are preserved in the design
• For 95% of the site, ground-level permeability is maintained.
• 68% of the site is free of structures, and significant amount of the site will remain
untouched by construction activities.
• 25% of the site is roofs, and most of the buildings are lightweight structures which sit on
raised piers, preserving ground-level permeability beneath them. Buildings are connected
via raised boardwalks rather than concrete pathways;
o 40% of roofs drain to tanks
o 40% of that water is used, primarily for toilet flushing (accounting for about a 0.4
ML/yr reduction in runoff volumes).
o All surplus roof water discharges to infiltration trenches beneath buildings (the
infiltration trenches have a 100 mm extended detention, are filled with clean
washed gravels, and have been incorporated into the structural design of the
building footings)
• Only 5% of the site consists on slab-on-ground construction. This was necessary to
provide for the Sound building (for acoustics), and part of the Create building sits on a
mounded area where it made sense to build directly onto natural surface. Roof runoff
from the roofs of slab-on-ground buildings is directed into infiltration trenches located
beneath adjoining buildings/boardwalks.
• 7% of the site is carpark, and a permeable gravel carpark pavement is proposed using the
Geobrics geoweb product (refer Figure 1 below).
Figure 1: Sample installation of ‘Geoweb’ trafficable permeable pavement at Hervey Bay.
High infiltration rates will be preserved post-construction
Construction activities have the potential to impact on the natural permeability of the site soils
through generation and inappropriate disposal of fine materials, silts and slurries, and excessive
compaction of soils. This will be managed on this site as follows:
• Construction drawings require infiltration tests to be conducted before and after
construction (refer drawing C001 and C100).
• Construction vehicle access will be limited to defined routes to minimise compaction,
although the infiltration rate of the site sands is likely to be fairly resilient to moderate
compaction.
Page 6
Bligh Tanner Page 3 of 5
• The avoidance of slab-on-ground construction will reduce the risks of concrete slurry and
the like being poorly disposed of.
• The contractor is to submit detailed work method statements to the superintendent for
approval that clearly document how the infiltration rate of site soils will be preserved (as
documented on drawing C001 and C100). This is to include details about:
o how the site will be accessed and how potential compaction from vehicle and plant
movement will be managed
o how the infiltration systems beneath buildings will be constructed, and protected
from construction debris
o how liquid, slurry and fine particular materials will be handled
o rectification measures to restore pre-development infiltration rates where
necessary.
ANALYSIS
Conventional hydrologic analysis techniques are not well suited to analysing the hydrologic
performance of the site due to the high infiltration rates of the in-situ soils and the atypical nature
of the development. For example, the commonly used rational method is based on a coefficient of
runoff approach, and so would estimate some runoff would be generated from almost any storm.
However the rainfall intensity (I100yr, 26 min) of 163 mm/hr is less than the infiltration rate of the site
soils, and so no surface runoff is likely to be generated for a 100 yr event across the whole site.
Note that very short times of concentration would lead to some runoff from the front of the site
due to partial area affects.
A continuous simulation over a 10 year period was undertaken with MUSIC (the modelling
approach is described in more detail in the Stormwater Management Plan). This analysis takes
into account baseflows as well as surface runoff, and demonstrates that post-development flows
were never higher than predevelopment flows, as shown in the cumulative frequency graph
shown in Figure 1 below.
A subsequent analysis in MUSIC, using ‘secondary links’ to isolate surface runoff from baseflow,
shows that, for the peak surface flow for the period of analysis reduces from about 270 L/s to 220
L/s, a reduction of about 20%. Further results of this analysis are presented in Table 1. It is
important to note that these results are highly conservative (i.e. they overestimate runoff) as they
assume standard rain-fall runoff parameters from the MUSIC modelling guidelines (Water by
Design V1 2010) that were calibrated to streams in catchments with lower infiltration rates than
the sandy soils of this site. Nonetheless, as the same ‘forested’ rainfall-runoff parameters have
been used for the pre and post development cases 1 they provide a useful guide as to the relative
impacts of the development.
Table 1 Summary of results from MUSIC modelling
Predevelopment Post development
Maximum flow (surface flow and 275 L/s 225 L/s
baseflow)
Maximum flow (surface flow only) 274 L/s 220 L/s
Mean annual flow (surface flow 2.9 ML/yr 2.08 ML/yr
and baseflow)
Mean annual flow (surface flow 1.8 ML/yr 1.3 ML/yr (rainwater
only) tanks account for 0.4
ML/yr)
1
The 600 m² turfed area uses ‘Urban’ rainfall runoff parameters to reflect the reduced infiltration rates
associated with turfed area associated with topsoil and compaction resulting from prolonged use.
Page 7
Bligh Tanner Page 4 of 5
Figure 2 Cumulative frequency graph showing post development runoff rates are expected to be
lower than pre-development rates (note logarithmic axis).
STORMWATER CONNECTION AND LAWFUL POINT OF DISCHARGE
Development Condition #23 requires that ‘the site must be provided with a stormwater drainage
system connecting to a lawful point of discharge’
According to QUDM (2013 Provisional edition) Section 3.4 Lawful point of discharge:
A ‘lawful point of discharge’ test has been used by the industry to assess whether
discharge at a particular location is lawful. The test is focused on whether all applicable
regulatory and other legal requirements have been met or consent has been obtained to
allow stormwater to discharge in a particular location.
The term lawful point of discharge has no prescribed legal meaning, but it is commonly
used by the industry to refer to a point where the stormwater flow discharge is ‘lawful’.
Ensuring a lawful point of discharge exists will be necessary if stormwater discharge has
changed since the development was initially designed. This may not be the case where
the changes to discharge flows are not significant and happen in the natural and ordinary
use of the upstream property.
Where there is doubt as to whether a lawful point of discharge exists it is recommended
that it be sought (through the undertaking of a due diligence assessment and by obtaining
the required consents, approvals and/or tenure) in order to minimise the risk of legal
disputes arising with affected landowners or the local government.
Based on the analyses presented above, the requirement for a lawful point of discharge is
considered to be met by avoiding any increase in stormwater discharge, and allowing any
overland flows to pass across the allotment frontage as sheet flow into the road reserve as it does
in its current, undeveloped state. No formal connection to the piped drainage system, nor kerb
and channel drainage system, is necessary.
Page 8
Bligh Tanner Page 5 of 5
IMPERVIOUS AREAS FOR THE PURPOSES OF INFRASTRUCTURE CHARGES
Sunshine Coast Regional Council levies an infrastructure charge on new development to provide
trunk infrastructure. The stormwater network charge is based on the amount of impervious area
on a site, which ensures that the charge is proportional to the stormwater impact created by that
site.
According to Sunshine Coast Regional Council Adopted Infrastructure Charges Resolution (No.
2) 2011 Dated 7 December 2011:
‘impervious area means the area of the premises that is impervious to rainfall or overland
flow that results in the discharge of stormwater from the premises.’ (Page 8).
The above analyses demonstrate that the site is effectively pervious to rainfall and overland flow,
and that the development leads to:
• A net reduction in peak flow rates compared with its current pre-developed state.
• A net reduction in runoff volumes compared with its current pre-developed state.
• A net reduction in pollutants compared with its current pre-developed state.
Therefore, based on Council’s definition, the site has zero impervious area for the purposes of
calculating Infrastructure Charges.
Yours faithfully,
Alan Hoban
Principal Environmental Engineer
BLIGH TANNER PTY LTD
Used in these records
2013-05-09 Negotiated Decision Notice Request (MCU12-0133).pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 314 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.