Skip to the record
Mmm.. taste the original NoosaWatch™

Council archive · source document

Information Response to DNRM MCU12/0208

of 10

Text shows just the words. Original shows the document exactly as it was published.

28 October 2013

Planning Services, South Region
Department of Natural Resources and Mines
PO Box 573
NAMBOUR QLD 4560

Attention: Dale Bell


                                       INFORMATION REQUEST RESPONSE
                            DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION – MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE
 PRELIMINARY APPROVAL FOR MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE UNDER SECTION 242 OF THE SUSTAINABLE PLANNING
  ACT 2009 TO VARY THE EFFECT OF THE NOOSA PLAN AND MAROOCHY PLAN 2000 PLANNING SCHEMES FOR A
                                  MIXED USE COMMUNITY TITLE DEVELOPMENT
                          EENIE CREEK RD, 99 & 191 HOLLETT RD NOOSAVILLE QLD 4566
                                                      AND
                              106, 108-142 TIDSWELL RD WEYBA DOWNS QLD 4562
 Described as Lot 2 RP160983, Lot 2 SP179590, Lot 7 RP46782, Lot 53 SP163571, Lot 11 SP250714, Lot 12 RP893393
                                              and Lot 1667 M37772

                                    DNRM Reference: IC0213NAM0001_SC14279
Dear Dale,

Following receipt of the Department of Natural Resources and Mines Information Request under Section 276 of the
                                      th
Sustainable Planning Act 2009, dated 4 March 2013, we respond to the issues raised as follow. We also refer to your
               th
letter dated 17 June 2013 extending the date for responding:

INFORMATION REQUESTED:


 1. Strategic Cropping Land (SCL)

     Introduction

     The proposed development is for a material change of use (MCU) and requires referral to the Department of
     Natural Resources and Mines (DNRM) as per, schedule 7, table 3, item 27 of the Sustainable Planning Regulation
     2009. The proposed development will be assessed against SPP 1/12 Protection of Queensland’s strategic
     cropping land (SPP 1/12).

     In the application you have elected to treat the land as SCL for the purposes of this application (Question 3 of
     IDAS form 35—Strategic cropping land). As indicated on Form 35, where the land is potential SCL and the
     applicant has elected to treat the land as if it were SCL for the purposes of the development application, the
     assessment will be based on the land being SCL (as per section 84 of the Strategic Cropping Land Act 2011).
     Should you choose to dispute that the land is SCL, you will need to submit an SCL validation application. An SCL
     validation application is not an application under the Sustainable Planning Act 2009. The SCL validation
     application must be made under the Strategic Cropping Land Act 2011. The outcome of an SCL validation
     application can not be considered as part of the MCU application, until a decision on the validation application
     has taken effect and you change the MCU application as per section 351 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009.




                                                         1
                                                         1
Full text of the other 9 pages

Page 2

     Results of preliminary assessment

     MCU applications that involve particular development on SCL are assessed based on the extent/location of the
     development footprint in relation to the SCL on the subject lot under the relevant section of SPP 1/12. For SCL
     assessment purposes, footprint has the same meaning as Schedule 26 of the Sustainable Planning Regulation
     2009. For preliminary approvals unless demonstrated otherwise, the development extent as per the plan of
     development is taken to be the footprint of the development.
                                                                     2
     The proposed development has a footprint greater than 3000 m and is located within the strategic cropping land
     management area. Section 4.5 of SPP 1/12 states that development that is for a MCU in the management area,
     only complies with the requirements of SPP 1/12 if it satisfies the requirements in section 4.2.2 of the SPP.

     Additional information required to assess the application

        Further information is required to demonstrate how the proposed development will satisfy SPP 1/12—
         specifically how the proposal meets s4.2.2 (d) of SPP 1/12 and should include but is not limited to a report
         that demonstrates:
        That the development provides a public benefit and no other site is suitable for the particular purpose
         (overriding need).
        How permanent impacts on SCL have been avoided to the greatest extent possible.
        How permanent impacts on SCL have been minimised where impacts could not be avoided.
        The location and area of permanently impacted land and the mitigation value (s139 Strategic Cropping Land
         Act 2011) including:
     
                                                   [1]
         Map/s or plan/s (at an appropriate scale)     showing all areas of SCL and the location/extent of all footprint
         components.
               Calculate of the area of the footprint and the mitigation value.
         How the applicant proposes to mitigate the impacts on SCL or potential SCL where they cannot be avoided.
         Mitigation has the meaning defined in s138 of the Strategic Cropping Land Act 2011 and for permanently
         impacted land, means that either of the following, or a combination of the following has taken place for the
                                2
         land’s mitigation value
              A payment to the mitigation fund.
              The entering into of a mitigation deed.

Response:


  Further to the Information Request issued by the Department of Natural Resources and Mines DNRM, a Strategic
  Cropping Land (SCL) validation application has been undertaken over the proposed Noosa on Weyba site area in
  accordance with chapter 2, part 2 of the Strategic Cropping Land Act 2011 (SCL Act). The validation application was
  submitted, has undergone public notice and was subsequently approved by DNRM. The approval confirmed that
  Lot 7 RP46782, Lot 52 SP163571, Lot 2 RP160983, Lot 11 SP250714, Lot 1667 M37772 and Lot 12 RP893393 fail to
  meet the requirements necessary to satisfy the SCL Cropping History Test and therefore are not considered SCL.
  Notwithstanding this the SCL Validation Decision stipulates that Lot 2 on SP179590 does meet the required
  cropping history necessary to satisfy the requirement of s49 of the SCL Act and therefore this site is still mapped as
  potential SCL.




                                                          2

Page 3

Despite Lot 2 on SP179590 being identified as SCL, it is concluded that the proposed Noosa on Weyba
Development Application no longer requires referral for SCL under Schedule 7, Table 3, Colum 1, Item 27 of the
Sustainable Planning Regulation 2009 for the following reasons:

               Upon review of the Sustainable Planning Regulation 2009 (Qld) (SPR), it is apparent that (as at 20
                December 2012, when the application was lodged):
         o    Schedule 7, Table 3 prescribed the concurrence agencies for ‘Development made assessable under a
              planning scheme, temporary local planning instrument, preliminary approval to which section 242 of
              the Act applies or State planning regulatory provisions’.
         o    Item 27 of Table 3 provided that ‘the SCL chief executive-as a concurrence agency’ was the
              concurrence agency for a ‘Material change of use, other than a use or in an area mentioned in
              schedule 13A, of a lot of 5 ha or larger if the footprint for the change of use is – (a) wholly or partly on
              SCL or potential SCL; and (b) more than 750 m2’.
         o    Schedule 13A of the SPR, ‘Excluded matters for SCL or potential SCL concurrence agency jurisdiction’
              includes ‘5. An area zoned under a planning scheme for rural residential or future rural residential
              purposes’.
         o    Rural residential is defined in the State Planning Policy 1/12: Protection of Queensland’s strategic
              cropping land (SPP) as: “Rural residential areas are identified in a local planning instrument as
              specifically intended for residential development on large lots, generally on the urban fringe where
              the primary land use is for residential living rather than agricultural production. Rural residential
              areas must be identified in local planning instruments on a map (e.g. a        zoning map) that:
                   (a) identifies the areas using cadastral boundaries and
                   (b) is used exclusively or primarily to assess development applications.

        Lot 2 SP179590 is zoned as ‘Rural settlement’ within the Tewantin & Doonan Locality Plan (Zone Map
         ZM9) of the Noosa Plan. The overall outcomes for the Rural Settlement Zone are:—detached housing on
         large lots—
         o is the dominant building form, to the general exclusion of other uses;
         o incorporate designs that respond to, and are integrated with site characteristics including slope and
              native vegetation;
         o contribute to the rural or semi-rural character and amenity of the area;
         o may be located in close proximity to working farms or other rural industries; and
         o offers a relaxed rural lifestyle for residents.

        Therefore, the Noosa Plan categorisation of ‘rural settlement’ clearly falls within the definition of ‘rural
         residential’ as required by the SPR as-
         o There is not a zoning classification in the Noosa Plan that is actually called ‘rural residential’ and no
              other zoning aside from ‘rural settlement’ that could be considered comparable.
         o Others include: Rural, Open space recreation, Open space conservation, etc.
         o Furthermore, the Draft Sunshine Coast Regional Council Planning Scheme proposes to zone Lot 2
              SP179590 as Rural Residential, further indicating that the current zoning of rural settlement is
              consistent with rural residential for the purposes of interpreting the SPR.

As determined in the above analysis of Lot 2 on SP179590 against the Sustainable Planning Regulations and the
2.  Vegetation
State  Planning Management
                Policy 1/12 itAct
                               is 1999
                                  concluded that the site in question is excluded from SCL concurrence agency
jurisdiction.
     Introduction
The remaining six lots within the Subject Land (Lot 7 RP46782, Lot 52 SP163571, Lot 2 RP160983, Lot 11 SP250714,
     The proposed development is for a material change of use (MCU) and requires referral to the Department of
Lot 1667 M37772 and Lot 12 RP893393) are Decided Non-SCL and therefore are not subject to DNRM SCL
     DNRM as per, Material change of use - Clearing vegetation (Sustainable Planning Regulation 2009 – Schedule 7,
jurisdiction either.
     table 3, item 10).
Although the original application was lodged with ‘potential SCL’ noted, the validation application decision notice
withThe DNRM
     respect to assesses  Material
                six lots, and       Change
                              the rural     of Use applications
                                        settlement zoning of Lotusing    the Concurrence
                                                                   2 SP179590   means thatAgency
                                                                                            there Policy  for no
                                                                                                    are now   Material
                                                                                                                 SCL
    Change  of Use (MCU)   21  October 2009  (MCU
considerations with respect to the Subject Land.   Policy). A copy  of relevant vegetation Policies and  Codes  can be
    accessed at www.dnrm.qld.gov.au .
Notwithstanding this it is noted that DNRM will continue to remain a concurrence agency for the application due
    For developments
to other issues that fallthat result
                          within theirinjurisdiction
                                         the clearing  of remnant
                                                     (such         vegetation,
                                                           as vegetation       applications
                                                                         matters), but not forare also assessed against the
                                                                                               SCL.
    Regional Vegetation Management Code for South East Queensland Bioregion – version 2.1, 30 November 2012
    (RVM Code). Please note that DNRM is directed to consider clearing as a result of the MCU. This application
    requires assessment against the above mentioned MCU Policy and RVM Code. A copy of the current Regional
                                                            3

Page 4

     Ecosystem Map – v6.1 can be downloaded at www.derm.qld.gov.au/remap .



     Results of preliminary assessment

     The referral of your application was not accompanied by sufficient information demonstrating compliance with
     the MCU Policy and RVM Code.

     It is apparent from the submitted Property Vegetation Management Plan (PVMP) and information that the intent
     of the project is to avoid clearing remnant vegetation by ensuring infrastructure is adequately setback from
     vegetation. The exception is the clearing proposed for access to the site from Hollett Road.

     A preliminary assessment has been conducted based on provided plans, specifically the Master Plan, Proposal
     Plan, Structure Plan and Koala Habitat and Vegetation Offset areas. There is an inconsistency in these plans in
     identifying the extent of development proposed which results in uncertainty about the amount of vegetation
     clearing required.

Response:

An assessment of the proposed Noosa on Weyba development against the relevant Performance Requirements of the
MCU Policy and the RVM Code is provided within the amended Property Vegetation Management Plan within Table 3-
1 and Table 3-2 respectively (see Attachment 1). We further note to the Department of Natural Resources and Mines
that the amended reports have taken into account the issues with clearing for the Hollett Road extension and
subsequently the amended documentation identifies that only a small proportion of Hollett Road will be constructed.

Department of Natural Resources and Mines

     Additional information required to assess the application

     Further information is required to be submitted to DNRM which includes:

          A plan and GIS shapefile of the setbacks proposed between mapped remnant vegetation and proposed
              infrastructure around all mapped remnant vegetation.

          Clarify the tracks to be created through mapped remnant vegetation – in particular any new
              roads proposed through the endangered remnant vegetation on lot 11. Picture below is from
              the provided ‘Illustrative Concept Master Plan’.




                                                        4

Page 5

Response:

The requested GIS shape file showing the relationship between areas of remnant vegetation and minimum
building setbacks is contained within Attachment 2 on the CD labeled “Noosa on Weyba PVMP v3 (Cardno
2013)”. Section 2.4 of the amended Noosa on Weyba PVMP (see Attachment 1) addresses the apparent areas of
inconsistency raised in the DNRM Information Request.

The Illustrative A1 Concept Master Plan included within Attachment 3 provides an indication of the type of uses
that could be established if the Noosa on Weyba development application is approved. However the details are
illustrative and are not in all instances an accurate reflection of the types of uses that could be established.

As points of clarification it is confirmed that:
> there would be no new roads, tracks or other forms of infrastructure established within the mapped area of
RE12.5.3 situated on Lot 11 that require the clearance of assessable vegetation; and

> the illustrative details shown on the extract opposite are consistent with an intent to maintain a number of
existing cleared access tracks through this mapped area of RE12.5.3 as pedestrian and property maintenance
and bushfire management trails.

Therein it is noted that the above details contained in the amended PVMP concerning the proposed location,
extent and purpose of remnant vegetation clearance that is proposed as part of the Noosa on Weyba
development should be relied upon in the event that there is any potential inconsistencies with the details
provided in other documentation submitted in support of the development application.

To confirm, there will be no new roads or any other infrastructure requiring the clearance of assessable
vegetation within that part of Lot 11 mapped as remnant vegetation.




     Clarify whether Stage 4 identified on the ‘Proposal Plan’ is part of the development proposal. If
      development is proposed in this area, please address the Regional Vegetation Management Code
      with regard to clearing in a least concern regional ecosystem. Below is a snap shot of the area in
      question (outlined in red) on the Proposal Plan.




                                                    5

Page 6

Response:



Refer to Section 2.4 of the Noosa on Weyba PVMP (see Attachment 1).

The extract referred to is sourced from JF&P Drawing Ref: M1775-00-12 (F) dated 18 July 2012 which is a
development layout over Lot 53 on SP163571 was formally approved by the Planning and Environment Court on
5 July 2013 (Appeal Ref: 344/09). As part of the Court judgment, the development is the subject of a Vegetation
Management Act Concurrency Agency Response (Ref: Elvas #2006/012181, Trackjob #IC1106NAM0002).

The Noosa on Weyba development application does not propose any clearance of assessable vegetation in the
area indicated opposite.

The only areas where remnant vegetation clearance is proposed within Lot 53 are the areas detailed in Section
2.2.2.




     Clarify the extent and location of the ‘rural settlement zone’ and ‘retirement village’ identified on
      submitted plans. Below is a snap shot of the submitted ‘Precinct Plan – MP-006 [C]’ identifying Precinct J
      as ‘rural residential lot’ and Precinct L as ‘retirement living / aged care’.




Response:



The extent of land that would be available to accommodate dwellings and other above ground infrastructure
within the areas of interest, which now form part of Precinct 4, will be substantially constrained by the
requirement to maintain appropriate bushfire setbacks from areas of potentially hazardous vegetation.

In this respect the developable sectors of areas L, J and K shown in the plan extract above would correspond
with the areas surrounded by the 30m wide firebreaks to adjacent areas of potentially hazardous vegetation to
be retained (or established) on adjacent land. The general locations of these areas were outlined in blue in
Figure 4 of the PVMP dated 30 November 2012, an extract of which is provided below.




                                                     6

Page 7

Please refer to Attachment 4 for a copy of the amended Urban Design Report and associated amended Urban
Design Maps, Figures and Diagrams which clearly define the extent of the precincts. Please find below the
amended Structure Plan for the Noosa on Weyba development.




Above: Identification of Specific Precinct Areas




                                                   7

Page 8

Above: Conceptual Development Footprint of both the Rural Settlement Zone and the Attached Housing Zone




     Clarify whether rural allotments are proposed within lot 53 along the boundary of lot 902 SP163309.
      Below is a snap shot of provided ‘Precinct Plan – MP – 006 [D]’ with area in question circled in red.




Response:

The development potential of the area indicated is substantially constrained by:
> the presence of high voltage power transmission lines and an associated easement that traverses this area;
and
> the limited extent of land that would be available for development once appropriate bushfire separation
distances have been provided.

Due to these constraints it would not be possible to construct a dwelling in this area and the most likely use for
this area will be as part of a single Rural allotment that encompasses this area and the adjacent area to the south
                                                     8

Page 9

where there is sufficient unconstrained land to establish a single building envelope for a rural residence.



The information provided in this letter adequately addresses the matters raised in the Department of Natural
Resources and Mines, Information Request. Under the provisions of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009, the
above represents a response in full to DNRM’s information request. We request that DNRM continue with its
assessment of the application. I trust that the information provided is sufficient to allow the Department of
Natural Resources and Mines to approve the proposed development.

Should you wish to discuss this matter further please contact me on 3666 0766 at any time.

Thank you for your assistance in this matter.

Yours faithfully,
Planning Initiatives




Peter Catchlove




                                                      9

Page 10

                        Notice of Response to Information Request



Northbrook Corporation Pty Ltd
C/- Planning Initiatives
PO Box 1774
NEW FARM QLD 4005




DNRM References:        IC0213NAM0001_SC14279


Planning Services, South Region
Department of Natural Resources and Mines
PO Box 573
NAMBOUR QLD 4560



Dear Sir/Madam


DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL FOR MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE UNDER SECTION 242 OF
THE SUSTAINABLE PLANNING ACT 2009 – LOT 2 RP160983, LOT 2 SP179590, LOT 7 RP46782, LOT 53 SP163571, LOT 11
SP250714, LOT 12 RP893393 & LOT 1667 M37772 (EENIE CREEK RD, 99 & 191 HOLLET RD, NOOSAVILLE & 106-142
TIDSWELL ROAD, WEYBA DOWNS) – RESPONSE TO INFORMATION REQUEST


I am responding to your Information Request by:


         Enclosing all of the information requested.

         Enclosing part of the information requested and asking that the requesting authority proceed with the
          assessment of the application.

         Advising that I do not intend to supply any of the information requested and asking that the requesting
          authority proceed with the assessment of the application.



Signed




                                                               [Signature]

 Peter Catchlove                                              [Print name]

 28/ 10/ 2013                                                 [Date]




                                                        10

Used in these records

About this file

File size
1.0 MB (small file)
File type
PDF

No other editions are linked here.

Original file

Log in to download the original file

Information Response to DNRM MCU12_0208.pdf · 1.0 MB (small file)

The supporting record

Open full page ↗

Source document

Analyse documents ↗Open full page ↗

My Comparisons

Choose two to four records of the same kind. Drag using a handle or use the “Compare” buttons.

Your selected records are saved in this browser for your account. Results use the filters on the page where you choose “Compare selected”.