2017-08-14 General Committee Agenda

Page 21 of 31

NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL                     Weighted Attribute Evaluation Spreadsheet - Final Evaluation

   NAME OF TENDERER                                                      PRICE
    (Conforming Tenders Only)                                        (excl of GST)
 1
 2  [lan Tattersall & Kerry Tattersall
 3  |Harvent P/Lt/as Total Buildmg Maintenance - Qid
 4  [QGean Management Solutions P/L
 5  [E&M Kleaning Services P/L
 6  |[Austraphil Cleaning Services
 7 [MMS Group P/L
 Sd
 Of
VO
De
12
M3
M4
WS
16
VT
WS
V9
20
2
22
23
2
    NON-CONFORMING TENDERS

                                                                            1                     2                     3                     4                    5                    6                    7                    8                    9
                                    a                               aguna Contracting    an lattersall & Kerry | Harvent P/Lt/as Tota: Clean Management      E&M Kleaning        ustraphil Ceaning
                     PART A - Non price element                             -                                      py    -                   .                    -                      -                         7
                                =    = Skements.                       Services              Tattersall       Building Maintenance      Solutions P/L         Services P/L          Services          ae rea
                                                                             Resukant              Resukant              Resukant              Resukant             Resultant            Resultant            Resukant              Resultant             Resultant
    Evaluation Giteria                          Weighting (%)                  score x               score x               score x               score x              score X              score x              score x              score x               score x
                                                                              weightin;               ightin;               ightin;             weightin;            weightin;            weightin;            weightin;           weightin;                ightiny
 pw                                                          pe                       Po pe pm fee fe pete p ele f=]                                                                                       lope lwp [ew
    Achievement

                 Sema aa                                                                                                                                                                                                             es
    Pan Prccctement                                            |       Somes         |          tora        [Bung Mamvenance|          Solutions PL    |     SoveesPE              Sarees         | MMSGowPL            ||
                                                                    a     Ci             a           &  Kerry  [Fa     P/L t/        e,    Mf                EAM KI    i                 Cg    i
                                                                       Services              Tattersall       Building Maintenance      Solutions P/L         Services P/L           Services
    Total Fees (Pc)                                  50%                 $84,815              $118,400               $119,340             $140,743             $165,000              $214,349             $251,693
    Average Fees (Pav) S................--.0000+  $156,334
  foie ewe                                                       pete
    Smt              eo                                                  we                                       ee                sw                                             ee              ee
    weaned        Sor                                                                                                                                                                                                               es

                                                                                                                                                The Contract Administrator confirms the above scores
         Contract Administrator & Assesment Panel Member 1                Parks and Natural Areas Coordinator (SC)                                       and weightings of this evaluation
                     Assesment Panel Member 2                                     Technical Officer (MH)
                     Assesment Panel Member 3                          Workplace Health & Safety Advisor (MS or PR)                                  Contract Administrator's signature:                        Parks and Natural Areas Coordinator (SC)
                     Assesment Panel Member 4                         Consulting Procurement & Contracts Advisor (AH)