Council archive · source document
App D - Legal Review · 132008.299.02
5 August 2025
It is important to note that, just because there is a material change of use of premises, does not
mean a MCU application is required. A MCU application could be made for the Proposed Changes,
however, for the reasons set out further below, it is generally advantageous in circumstances such as
these to make an Other Change application, due to the different context and rules that apply to
assessment of these applications.
Other Change application
As noted previously, an Other Change application is a change application other than for a minor
change to an approval.
An Other Change application is the appropriate mechanism for seeking to change an approval where
the proposed changes do not meet the definition of ‘minor change’, such as where the changes
would result in substantially different development from that under the approval. As such, where it
would be unsuitable to make a Minor Change application because the Proposed Changes would
result in substantially different development due to a dramatic change to built form, or increase in
impacts associated with the development under the Approval, an Other Change application may be
made.
The Act does not prohibit the making an Other Change application where the change would be
considered a material change of use, for example because it involves an increase in intensity of the
approved use. Conversely, where an Other Change application is made instead of a Minor Change
application because the proposed change would result in substantially different development, it
stands to reason that in most circumstances, the proposed change involves a material change of use.
We would anticipate that this principle is uncontroversial, consistent with our experience, and the
Other Change applications considered by the Court.
For an Other Change application, as a matter of statutory interpretation, we note the proposed
new/changed development must at least be related to the existing approval to an extent, to satisfy
that the proposal involves a change to the approval and the proposed development is not so
distinct/unrelated that the approval could not be changed to facilitate it, thus necessitating a new
MCU application.
For example, an Other Change application would not be suitable where there is an approval for a
material change of use of premises for a dwelling house and the proposal is to replace the dwelling
house with a commercial development – that proposal involves replacing (rather than adding to) the
development under the approval (being use of premises for a dwelling house), therefore a requiring
a MCU application for the commercial development instead of an Other Change application.
As noted above, we consider that following the Proposed Changes, the development would continue
to operate as Visitor Accommodation (Type 4), therefore no new use of premises is proposed. We
consider it unambiguous that the Proposed Changes to the development on Lot 3, could be
facilitated by a change to the Approval; that is, the proposed development is not so distinct that the
Approval could not be changed to incorporate the Proposed Changes, via an Other Change
application.
Therefore, it is appropriate to seek the Proposed Changes as a change to the Approval – this could
be facilitated through an Other Change application, avoiding the need for a MCU application for a
new approval.
Page 8
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
App D - Legal Review.pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 677 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.