Council archive · source document
Information Response MCU12/0208
peak flows are not increased. It should be noted that the attenuation that will be provided by the bio-
retention basins and rainwater tanks has not been included in the flooding analysis. These will provide
some additional attenuation, particularly for the minor storm events. Therefore the developed case peak
flows that have been modelled are a conservative assumption. Appropriate erosion and scour control
measures will be required on all outlets and culvert crossings.
Lake Weyba Water Quality Objectives (WQOs) are provided and it‘s further mentioned
that Healthy Waterways undertakes regular monitoring under an Ecosystem Health Monitoring
Program. It is further claimed in relation to this that MUSIC modelling (for the WSUD)
background concentrations can be higher in some instances than the WQOs (eg background
Total P concentration in bio-retention systems is assumed to be 130 µg/L, >WQO concentration)
and therefore concentration based WQOs cannot be determined through MUSIC modelling.
From this, the consultant recommends that the results from water quality monitoring carried out
by the Healthy Waterways be used to determine whether there is an impact from the
development.
Whilst these results can be used, the applicant will need to be responsible by implementing an
appropriately tailored water monitoring program as the Healthy Waterways monitoring may
not suit the specifics of the proposal and cannot be relied on to continue for the life of the
development especially where a State Government could either halt or reduce funding for such
programs.
Response:
Section 5.3 of the amended Stormwater Management Plan addresses this item (see Attachment 16). A
monitoring program has been proposed for the site so that the existing water quality parameters can be
defined, and the effectiveness of the proposed stormwater treatment devices can be established.
Information Required
90 Provide information including revised MUSIC modelling results, amended plans and all relevant
details that demonstrate the above issues have been addressed.
Response:
Section 8.3 of the Stormwater Management Plan amended addresses this item.
The MUSIC analysis was re-run to determine the increase in bio-retention treatment size that would be
required to compensate for the loss of the rainwater tanks and still meet the stormwater quality
objectives. As the proposed development has targeted a higher level of treatment than typically required,
the increase required was not as significant as that necessary for similar developments. It was found that if
the bio- retention filter media area in the basins and swales was increased by 25 percent then the WQOs
could be met. The exception was for areas F and G, where a 50 percent increase in the bio-retention
gardens was required. It would also be necessary to drain the roof areas to the road, rather than directly to
underground drainage. The resultant load removal for the combined site was 83% for TSS, 60% for TP and
48% for TN.
While the water quality objectives can be met if the bio-retention areas are increased, it is still
recommended that rainwater tanks be adopted on site. The proposed development aims to promote the
use of ecologically sensitive design and the use of rainwater tanks plays an important role in this regard. As
this will be a Body Corporate development there will be more control available on the development
conditions for each lot. The use of rainwater tanks will significantly reduce the water demand of the site
(by up to 53%), reduce stormwater flows being discharged off-site and allow the remaining treatment
devices to be better target utilised treating ground and road runoff, rather than relatively clean roof runoff.
60
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
Information Response MCU12/0208Related documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 1.6 MB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.