Council archive · source document
2013-05-09 Negotiated Decision Notice Request (MCU12-0133) · MCU12/0133
Attached to the e-mail Representations for Negotiated Decision Notice.
Bligh Tanner Page 3 of 5
• The avoidance of slab-on-ground construction will reduce the risks of concrete slurry and
the like being poorly disposed of.
• The contractor is to submit detailed work method statements to the superintendent for
approval that clearly document how the infiltration rate of site soils will be preserved (as
documented on drawing C001 and C100). This is to include details about:
o how the site will be accessed and how potential compaction from vehicle and plant
movement will be managed
o how the infiltration systems beneath buildings will be constructed, and protected
from construction debris
o how liquid, slurry and fine particular materials will be handled
o rectification measures to restore pre-development infiltration rates where
necessary.
ANALYSIS
Conventional hydrologic analysis techniques are not well suited to analysing the hydrologic
performance of the site due to the high infiltration rates of the in-situ soils and the atypical nature
of the development. For example, the commonly used rational method is based on a coefficient of
runoff approach, and so would estimate some runoff would be generated from almost any storm.
However the rainfall intensity (I100yr, 26 min) of 163 mm/hr is less than the infiltration rate of the site
soils, and so no surface runoff is likely to be generated for a 100 yr event across the whole site.
Note that very short times of concentration would lead to some runoff from the front of the site
due to partial area affects.
A continuous simulation over a 10 year period was undertaken with MUSIC (the modelling
approach is described in more detail in the Stormwater Management Plan). This analysis takes
into account baseflows as well as surface runoff, and demonstrates that post-development flows
were never higher than predevelopment flows, as shown in the cumulative frequency graph
shown in Figure 1 below.
A subsequent analysis in MUSIC, using ‘secondary links’ to isolate surface runoff from baseflow,
shows that, for the peak surface flow for the period of analysis reduces from about 270 L/s to 220
L/s, a reduction of about 20%. Further results of this analysis are presented in Table 1. It is
important to note that these results are highly conservative (i.e. they overestimate runoff) as they
assume standard rain-fall runoff parameters from the MUSIC modelling guidelines (Water by
Design V1 2010) that were calibrated to streams in catchments with lower infiltration rates than
the sandy soils of this site. Nonetheless, as the same ‘forested’ rainfall-runoff parameters have
been used for the pre and post development cases 1 they provide a useful guide as to the relative
impacts of the development.
Table 1 Summary of results from MUSIC modelling
Predevelopment Post development
Maximum flow (surface flow and 275 L/s 225 L/s
baseflow)
Maximum flow (surface flow only) 274 L/s 220 L/s
Mean annual flow (surface flow 2.9 ML/yr 2.08 ML/yr
and baseflow)
Mean annual flow (surface flow 1.8 ML/yr 1.3 ML/yr (rainwater
only) tanks account for 0.4
ML/yr)
1
The 600 m² turfed area uses ‘Urban’ rainfall runoff parameters to reflect the reduced infiltration rates
associated with turfed area associated with topsoil and compaction resulting from prolonged use.
See the original
The page text is free to read. Viewing or downloading an original file needs an account.
Log in to see the originalUsed in these records
2013-05-09 Negotiated Decision Notice Request (MCU12-0133).pdfRelated documentApplication case desk ↗
About this file
- File size
- 314 KB (small file)
- File type
No other editions are linked here.